The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Comment

“This is an attack not just on Paris, not just on the people on France, but an attack on all humanity and the universal values we share.”

Comment.

Or, as the French would say, Comment?

10 comments

Why Is It My Fault?

I realize this story probably isn’t of much interest to anybody who doesn’t live in the state of Illinois but it’s stuck in my craw. Illinois, which has been operating without a budget for six months and the largest city of which is on the verge of bankruptcy, is shelling out $2 million:

The University of Illinois’ decision last year to revoke a job offer to controversial professor Steven Salaita will cost more than $2 million, including an $875,000 settlement that trustees approved Thursday.

Salaita, who lost a tenured faculty position after posting a string of anti-Israel comments on social media, will get $600,000 in the deal in exchange for dropping two lawsuits against the university and agreeing he will never work at U. of I.

Salaita’s attorneys will get $275,000.

The settlement — to be paid out within 30 days — is on top of the $1.3 million in legal fees the university has spent during the past 14 months on Salaita-related issues, including a federal suit brought by Salaita that alleged breach of contract and violation of his free speech rights.

Trustees voted 9-1 to approve the agreement, in which the university admits no wrongdoing. The settlement will be paid for by self-insurance and institutional funds, which includes some taxpayer money. Trustee Timothy Koritz voted against it, saying the trustees’ decision last year to rescind the offer was “in the best interest of students.”

My question is whether Dr. Salaita’s termination was consistent with written university policies? If it wasn’t, I see no reason the university and, ultimately, the state should be saddled with the bill. If it was, fire the university’s lawyers. And think about legal malpractice.

The key point here is that I, in my capacity as Mr. Illinois Taxpayer, am paying for this nonsense and I have virtually no control over it. I have virtually no say in who becomes a university president. I have virtually no say in the rules under which the state universities operate. And yet I’m on the hook for their malfeasance.

6 comments

Your Word for the Day

Your word for the day is ochlocracy. As Aristotle reckoned things, ochlocracy is democracy, spoiled by the triumph of the passions over reason as oligarchy is aristocracy spoiled by corruption or tyranny is monarchy spoiled by lack of virtue. It is sometimes translated as “mob rule”.

Ochlocracy is not the friend of minorities. Rather the rule of law is.

9 comments

Why Support the TPP?

The editors of the Washington Post support the ratification of the Trans-Pacific Partnership trade agreement:

But at the end of the day, it is an agreement that seeks to facilitate the free flow of goods, services and investment, to the mutual benefit of hundreds of millions of people. That is the core purpose on which the TPP should ultimately be judged and, we hope, ratified.

Note the careful wording of that endorsement. The agreement does not “facilitate the free flow of good, etc.” but seeks to do so. Since the terms of the agreement became public I’ve learned several things:

  • The agreement does not end Japan’s agricultural tariffs. It reduces them but does not end them. Since the agreement omits any measures to counter currency manipulation, it vitiates the effects of reducing tariffs. This alone is a stopper for me.
  • It does not extend labor rights to Viet Nam. Contrary to the WP’s editors’ claims that is a trade issue as are environmental and safety standards.
  • The agreement has serious problems in privacy and security standards.
  • The U. S. has not agreed to moderate its intellectual property laws.

I don’t think that anti-currency manipulation provisions are quite as elusive as the WP’s editors do. How’s this? “Any country holding foreign currencies in excess of World Bank standards shall be subject to tariffs and penalties in the amount of the excesses.” The sticking point is not in coming up with a formula; it’s that currency manipulators want to keep manipulating.

Team spirit is not enough of a reason for me to approve or disapprove of the agreement as it is for some. I need a substantial argument, backed up with facts and figures, that the agreement will be of net benefit to the people of the United States. So far I haven’t seen that.

5 comments

Your Science News for the Day

If you’ve been wondering how to make methicillin-resistant staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) more virulent, they’ve discovered how to do it—feed it antibiotics. The wrong kind of antibiotics:

A brand new study indicates that MRSA-induced diseases with the incorrect antibiotic could worsen the infection.

Researchers in America unveiled the findings of their study printed in the journal Cell Host & Microbe. The researchers detected that common or first-line antibiotics such as beta lactam antibiotics can make superbugs stronger and the infection more severe.

“Individuals infected with MRSA who receive a beta lactam antibiotic–one of the most typical types of antibiotics–could wind up being worse than if they received no treatment whatsoever,” George Liu of Cedars-Sinai Medical Center and co-senior study author said in a press release.

“Our findings underscore the urgent need to improve knowledge of MRSA and rapidly diagnose these diseases to prevent prescribing antibiotics that could put patients’ lives at risk,” he added.

Their study, which was conducted on lab mice, promises that MRSA does not only react to beta lactam antibiotics, it truly adjusts to them, becoming more powerful in the method. Apparently, beta-lactam antibiotic’s mechanism of action calls for neutralizing the enzymes in bacteria.

Examples of beta lactam antibiotics include cefazolin and cephalexin. I wonder how this study comports with the prescription of ceftaroline for MRSA. That’s supposed to be effective against MRSA but it’s a beta lactam antibiotic, too.

4 comments

VW Flatfooted

Will VW’s woes never stop? There are new reports of the company’s fudging emissions tests, this time with respect to carbon dioxide:

Has Volkswagen been rigging Carbon dioxide emissions tests as well as diesel emissions? “The government believes the accusations are serious and that Volkswagen has a duty to transparently and fully clear them up”, said Steffen Seibert, adding that “Volkswagen has made this promise”. Everything erupted back in September when United States authorities exposed VW for using “defeat devices” to cheat several critical tests for emissions of nitrogen oxide, something that causes smog. That cheat-ware scandal affects 11 million or more cars – now Volkswagen says an internal probe has uncovered 800,000 vehicles that emit unexpected levels of carbon dioxide, which is a greenhouse gas. The two main cars affected are the VW Polo and Golf, but a few cars from the Audi, Seat, and Skoda brands are also included.

Recently, I’ve heard about an offer of $1,000 (in credits) to disgruntled U. S. customers of its diesels as compensation on the part of the company which strikes me as taunting those customers to sue the company. Meanwhile, the company’s stock continues slouching downward, trying to find bottom.

0 comments

Fighting for Kurdistan

The Kurdish assault on the city of Sinjar in Northern Iraq is getting quite a bit of attention:

MOUNT SINJAR, Iraq—Kurdish forces backed by U.S. and allied warplanes began a major assault Thursday aimed at retaking an Iraqi city from Islamic State and severing the extremist group’s crucial supply line to Syria.

Some 7,500 so-called Peshmerga fighters were deployed in the attack on Sinjar city, which has been held by Islamic State for more than a year, the local Kurdish administration said.

By the afternoon, they had seized control of 22 miles of highway south of the town, part of an effort to block Islamic State from sending reinforcements, said Maj. Qasim Samu Shingali, the administration’s head of security in the surrounding Sinjar district.

Not to diminish the bravery of the peshmerga in any way but there’s something most of the news coverage isn’t mentioning. Sinjar, a mostly Yezidi city, is in Kurdish territory or, at least, territory claimed by the Kurds. The Kurds are fighting for their homes and for the land that they consider theirs.

There is very little evidence that the Kurds will fight for Iraq much less for Syria. The peshmerga are a sort of National Guard. My point is that there are distinct limits in the value of the Kurds as allies.

And that doesn’t even take into account the reaction of the Turks who are quietly supporting DAESH. Ataturk’s secular Turkey is truly dead but the country is still a member of NATO. We may face a time when we’ll be forced to choose between the Turks and the Kurds.

11 comments

The End of Bipartisanship

You might want to take a look at this New York Times article summarizing remarks from Ray LaHood, the only elected Republican member of the Obama cabinet. Here’s a snippet:

While Mr. Gates was held over from a Republican administration, Mr. LaHood was the only Republican in the first cabinet who had been elected to public office. In his second term, Mr. Obama appointed former Senator Chuck Hagel, a Republican from Nebraska, as defense secretary, although he did not last long.

In the interview and the book, Mr. LaHood recounted his excitement at joining the new administration — and his quick disappointment at its opening gambits. In the interest of passing an economic stimulus package quickly to counter the deep recession he inherited, Mr. Obama agreed to a strategy of allowing Nancy Pelosi, the California Democrat who then served as House speaker, to pass it without Republicans.

“I think they felt like they need to push this through quickly to get the economy moving,” Mr. LaHood said in the interview. “And, boom, they made a decision that they were going to pass economic stimulus with just Democratic votes. That was the beginning of the end of bipartisanship.”

When Mr. Emanuel asked him to call 10 to 15 of his former Republican colleagues to lobby for the stimulus, Mr. LaHood said each complained of being shut out by Democrats. As a result, he refused to help anymore.

“I called Rahm and said, ‘This is mission impossible,’” he recounted in the book. “I stopped making calls. I did not expect Republicans to roll over and accept the president’s ambitious economic recovery agenda whole cloth.”

Mr. LaHood said that set the tone for the rest of Mr. Obama’s administration. “House Republicans deserve a fair amount of blame for the lock-step vote on stimulus,” he wrote, because they would not meet Mr. Obama halfway. But in handing the project over to Mrs. Pelosi, he said, “the price we paid was incalculable.”

He added, “The White House had reached this decision without consulting me, the person they had selected to promote bipartisanship.”

That comports completely with the many reports from White House insiders of insularity and isolation in the Obama White House, a “my way or the highway” approach to governance.

19 comments

Where Have You Gone, Joe DiMaggio?

The editors of the Wall Street Journal point to a remarkably mature response to the goings-on at Yale and University of Missouri and, as fate would have it, it’s from the single Republican I most wish were running for president:

We’ve been wondering all week what happened to the grown-ups on American university campuses, and it appears we have a sighting. Mitch Daniels, the president of Purdue University, spoke up Wednesday about the children’s revolt at Yale and Missouri in a letter “to the Purdue community.”

It deserves to be quoted at length: “Events this week at the University of Missouri and Yale University should remind us all of the importance of absolute fidelity to our shared values. First, that we strive constantly to be, without exception, a welcoming, inclusive and discrimination-free community, where each person is respected and treated with dignity. Second, to be steadfast in preserving academic freedom and individual liberty.

“Two years ago, a student-led initiative created the ‘We Are Purdue Statement of Values,’ which was subsequently endorsed by the University Senate. Last year, both our undergraduate and graduate student governments led an effort that produced a strengthened statement of policies protecting free speech. What a proud contrast to the environments that appear to prevail at places like Missouri and Yale. Today and every day, we should remember the tenets of those statements and do our best to live up to them fully.”

So a commitment to tolerance can coexist on campus with a commitment to free speech and open debate. What a concept.

I doubt it’s a coincidence that resembles what I wrote on the subject yesterday. Maintaining a society that serves all of its members requires a counter-balancing of values rather than a celebration of one value at the expense of all of the others. Freedom without compassion is license. Inclusiveness without freedom is tyranny.

If it were easy, anybody could do it.

5 comments