Fighting Terrorism Without Fighting

If this article at The Diplomat is to be credited, the way the Chinese plan to reconcile their non-interventionist policies without their pledge to fight terrorism doesn’t actually involve any fighting:

A recent Xinhua piece outlined China’s vision for how to fight terrorism in Africa, and it had nothing to do with military operations against groups like Boko Haram, Al-Shabaab, and al-Mourabitoun (which claimed responsibility for the November 20 hotel attack in Mali). Instead the piece focused on supporting the affected states to fight their own battles against extremists, by providing “technological aid and intelligence sharing.” Xinhua also argued that, by arming rebels around the world, the West has made terrorist groups stronger, rather than weakening them.

In this light, China sees its economic outreach to Africa (and the Middle East) as steps forward in the fight against terrorism – ways to tackle terrorism at the root by eliminating poverty and providing employment for those who might otherwise be drawn to extremist groups.

Of course, China’s understanding of the “root causes” of terrorism can be called into question based on its actions in Xinjiang province, where heavy-handed security measures may actually be backfiring and increasing terrorist activity. China seems to cling to the belief that economic development can cure all ills, whether in Xinjiang, Mali, or Afghanistan — despite evidence to the contrary in China’s own far-western province. Still, Western military efforts haven’t proved much more successful either.

Maslow’s hammer. It explains both our eagerness to use military force and China’s reluctance.

0 comments

What the Kurds Will Do

There’s an interesting article at War on the Rocks on the takeaways from the campaign to retake Sinjar. Here’s the critical passage, at least from my standpoint:

The Kurds’ priority in this campaign is not to expel ISIL. Rather, it is to remain strategically significant, consolidate control over territories and resources, and maintain long-term coalition support to help protect their expanded borders. These nationalist priorities mean that capturing Sinjar will not necessarily embolden the Kurds to expel ISIL outside areas they consider Kurdish, at least not without Sunni Arabs taking the lead. Washington should recognize these limitations and also focus on the Sunni Arab local partners that can and should liberate ISIL strongholds, in coordination with the Iraqi government.

The Kurds will fight for Kurdistan but not for Iraq. The Iraqis have shown little desire to fight for Iraq. If they won’t, who will and, more importantly, why should we? To what end?

There are other ways to mitigate the risks posed by terrorism than fighting other people wars for them and I’ve suggested some. The greatest obstacle we face in mitigating the risks is that we won’t acknowledge that our notional allies are actually the greatest supporters of terrorism.

7 comments

The Best Laid Plans

I think there’s something Martin Feldstein is missing in his remarks on China’s 13th Five Year Plan. When he writes:

Finally, and perhaps most important, the population of working-age individuals is no longer growing, a result of the 35-year-long policy of restricting most families to no more than one child. Although the government recently replaced the one-child limit with a two-child limit, it will be nearly two decades before that change can increase the size of the working-age population. Until then, increasing the growth rate of the effective labor force requires shifting workers from low-productivity employment in agriculture to the urban labor force.

The Chinese government is therefore considering several policies to increase the pace of urbanization, including the creation of several new large cities to accommodate some of the 600 million individuals who still live in rural China. Similarly, the government will phase out the hukou system of residency permits that now prevents migrants to the cities from obtaining full health care and education benefits.

Here’s the problem. China’s agricultural productivity has been decreasing for the last decade. China has followed the same path that the Soviets did. As Dr. Feldstein put it “shifting workers from low-productivity employment in agriculture to the urban labor force”. China did a better job of it because for two decades (1985-2005) they were able to reduce the rural labor force and increase agricultural productivity at the same time. Since then they haven’t. Unless they can increase productivity, further reducing agricultural labor will result in China producing less food. They have polluted their soil, water, and air to the extent that IMO that’s unlikely to happen.

Which is why they’ve been leasing farmland, e.g. in Ukraine and in Africa. That’s their strategy for maintaining their food self-sufficiency policy in the face of declining agricultural productivity.

There’s something to be concerned about: that the Chinese will use the same poor practices that has injured their own land elsewhere.

2 comments

The Second Variety

Writing in the New York Times, Peter Thiel remarks:

What’s especially strange about the failed push for renewables is that we already had a practical plan back in the 1960s to become fully carbon-free without any need of wind or solar: nuclear power. But after years of cost overruns, technical challenges and the bizarre coincidence of an accident at Three Mile Island and the 1979 release of the Hollywood horror movie “The China Syndrome,” about a hundred proposed reactors were canceled. If we had kept building, our power grid could have been carbon-free years ago.

Instead, we went in reverse. In 1984, Ohio’s nearly finished William H. Zimmer nuclear plant was abruptly converted into a coal-burning facility: a microcosm of the country’s lurch back toward carbon.

and

The single most important action we can take is thawing a nuclear energy policy that keeps our technology frozen in time. If we are serious about replacing fossil fuels, we are going to need nuclear power, so the choice is stark: We can keep on merely talking about a carbon-free world, or we can go ahead and create one.

Now he tells us. I was saying that forty years ago.

There are two sorts of environmentalists: practical environmentalists who genuinely want to solve the problems caused by our growing need for energy and romantics among whom there is a strong Luddite streak. The latter group are not merely unhappy with technology for producing the problem, they don’t want to use technology to solve it, either. Hence the emphasis on conservation by the poor, a plan which can only succeed if the poor produce enough carbon to make a difference, something of which I’m skeptical.

As I’ve pointed out before, I am not a global warming skeptic. More of an agnostic. I am, however, a global warming remediation plans skeptic. I have yet to see a plan proposed by anybody that will actually solve the problem it is claimed is before us. Show me your plan so I can evaluate it.

7 comments

Claims and Counter-Claims

A dizzying array of claims and counter-claims are being made about Turkey’s shooting down of a Russian Su-24 bomber. CNN reports that Turkey is repeating its claim that the Russians violated Turkish airspace and the Russian aircraft was shot down in self-defense, along with a somewhat bizarre expansion:

Erdogan said Friday that Turkey didn’t initially know the nationality of the warplane shot down.

“Turkey did not shoot down Russian plane on purpose. This was only an automatic reaction to a border breach. This is an exercise of the rules of engagement. The nationality of these planes who are flying towards our border were unknown despite the warnings,” Erdogan said. “It is impossible to know this at that time.”

The Russians for their part have made some interesting counter-claims, as explained in this post at zerohedge. Summarizing the Russians’ claims:

  1. The Russian aircraft received no warning of any kind prior to being shot down.
  2. The Russians had given their flight plan to the Americans well in advance.
  3. Russian radar monitoring data suggest that the Turkish fighter must have set out to intercept the Russian plan before it was visible on Turkish radar.
  4. Consequently, the most likely scenario is that the Turks ambushed the Russian plane with the assistance of information provided by the Americans.
  5. The Russian plane was returning from the border when it was attacked by the Turks and therefore did not constitute a threat.
  6. Which means that the Turks committed a war crime.
  7. That the shooting down of the plane was videoed from the ground suggests preparation.
  8. That the recovery of the pilot’s body by terrorist forces on the ground was videoed also suggests preparation.

I think what we really need now is some U. S. satellite imaging or radar monitoring data that confirms the Turks’ side of the story. Absent that the preponderance of the evidence suggests the Russians are right.

What if the Russians are right?

7 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Swiss Vote “No Burqas”

I’ve mentioned before that Switzerland has as close to a direct democracy as any modern country. Any law of any magnitude is turned over to the people to be approved or rejected by direct popular vote. In Switzerland the people have spoken and they’ve said “No” to burqas. From The Express:

Muslim women can no longer wear the full-body garment in shops, restaurants or public buildings and anyone caught flouting the ban could be struck with a £6,500 fine.

The local government of Ticino approved the referendum after the Swiss Parliament ruled that the ban did not violate the country’s federal law.

Two in three voters in the canton backed the move in an overwhelming result for a referendum, in the wake of heightened terrorist alerts across Europe.

The law which MPs voted for only applies to veils which covers the body from head to foot worn by the 40,000 Muslim women in Switzerland and also applies to all tourists visiting the area.

I have what I fear is a very unpopular opinion. I think that the citizens of a country have total authority within the constraints of prior law to control what is or is not acceptable behavior within its borders. In effect, what it means to be Swiss. The Swiss have decided that burqas are unacceptable in Switzerland.

My prediction is that this will not be the last similar law in the ethnic states of Europe.

3 comments

Fighting Terrorists

I wanted to remark on a particularly astute comment left by one of my regular commenters. My remarks were inspired by this section:

There are groups of people who want to foist their agenda and ideology on others, but instead of doing it peacefully or violently against the primary targets, they use violence against unrelated targets – terrorist tactics.

and this:

As far as fighting the Islamist terrorist organisations using tanks and artillery, good luck. You can fight the conventional military branch of the organization, and you may defeat it. That leaves the remaining organizations without military branches free to do what they want to do, but I am sure it feels good.

Some nostalgic people wish we could fight the terrorists with the tactics that were effective during World War II against the Germans and the Japanese. We can’t. Contrary to the war movies you might have seen, during World War II the important campaigns were not the big set piece battles but the campaigns against the enemies’ productive capacity and civilian morale. What became clear during the Viet Nam War was that we were no longer willing to wage wars against civilian morale but the enemy was quite capable of waging war against ours, hence “asymmetrical warfare”.

The terrorists don’t have much productive capacity to speak of. They’re less an army as we understand such things than bandits. If they’re successful in their objectives, tens or hundreds of millions of their subjects will die, simply because they can’t be supported under the form of society and economy they want to impose.

They capture the munitions they use or the resources they sell to buy munitions. Consequently, they aren’t dependent on the morale of the people in the territories they control. Honestly, I don’t think they give a damn about their morale.

Objectively, we could fight a war of extermination against them if we were willing to kill terrorists and civilians alike. Alternatively, we can just let them have their way within the borders of the countries who won’t or can’t put them down and otherwise have no commerce with them other than under very constrained conditions. By “no commerce” I mean no trade, no communications, no seats in the UN, no travel other than within designated “trade towns”.

Since I don’t think we’re willing to wage a war of extermination or quarantine them, I think that the greatest likelihood is that we’ll just put up with the situation. Given the degree of personal empowerment in the modern world, that means we’ll put up with hundreds or thousands of deaths at the hands of terrorists every year and deteriorating conditions of security and freedom within our own borders.

However, our leaders will feel good about their high-mindedness.

17 comments

Just Politics

I see that columnist John Kass has noticed the same thing about the video of the execution of Laquan MacDonald that I did:

Rahm sat on the video, and kept sitting on it, all the way through his re-election, as black ministers and other African-American political figures rallied to his side to get out the black vote and deny that vote to Jesus ‘Chuy’ Garcia. … If the video had come out during the election campaign, Rahm Emanuel would not be mayor today.

I think I’ve mentioned the situation I experienced with my then employer, a Fortune 500 company. A scandal involving the manager of a regional organization was discovered. Headquarters send in a team of investigators. One of one all of the managers in the regional organization was called before the investigators and asked just two questions. Did you know? Could/should you have known? Unless the manager could make convincing arguments that he didn’t know and there was no way he could have known, he was terminated right then and there. Very few managers kept their jobs.

Something of the sort needs to happen in Chicago. Neither the mayor nor the police are “at will” employees. It’s practically impossible to get rid of them. The state probably has the authority to conduct a tribunal of the sort described above but even if such a thing were legal the state’s officials are probably just as corrupt as the city’s and, indeed, may well be involved in the cover-up as well.

And yet people keep re-electing them. Despite the corruption trials that have been going on for most of my adult life. It’s not a hopeful situation but rather one that ends with guillotines in the town square.

8 comments

Assumptions About the Turkey-Russia Incident

Writing in the Washington Post, Dan Drezner asks three questions about the shooting down of a Russian aircraft by Turkish forces:

1. Does irrefutable evidence emerge of the SU-24’s location when it was shot down? Although the plane crashed in Syria, its flight path very well may have crossed Turkish airspace. It’s not like Russia has explicitly acknowledged previous reports regarding planes being shot down, but such reports would tend to reduce Putin’s ability to build international support.

2. Does Putin ratchet up tensions elsewhere? If Putin has a modus operandi, it’s to foment tensions in a new region when the situation is worsening in an ongoing area of conflict. So it wouldn’t surprise me if Putin tries to coerce or intimidate the Baltic states soon, as a way of signaling to NATO that Russia has leverage elsewhere. If that happens, it’s a worrying sign.

3. Can Barack Obama lead NATO? Contrary to realist fears, U.S. alliances have not dragged the United States into needless wars. But for alliances to increase security, smaller states must feel that the United States has their back. U.S.-Turkish relations have been, let’s say, “bumpy” in recent years, so it will be interesting to see whether the United States can constrain Turkey from escalating the conflict further. Similarly, if Putin does ratchet up tensions elsewhere, will Obama be able to coordinate a resolute but measured NATO response?

Note the unstated assumption that Russia crossed into Turkish airspace and that the Turks were within their rights to shoot the plane down. I think I’d add to the questions Dr. Drezner asks one of my own: what if the Russians produce incontrovertible proof of their side of the story? Their side of the story is that the Turks shot the plan down without warning of any kind. That’s been bolstered by the testimony of the aircraft’s surviving crew member. The Turks for their part have produced a recording of a warning. If you give me a little time, I’ll produce a video of the Turks recording their warning into somebody’s cell phone. My point: recordings are cheap.

So far nobody has produced any evidence (and the Turks have not claimed) that the Turks followed regular protocols for such incidents, e.g. if warnings on the international frequency fail try other frequencies, close flybys, signals, warning shots with tracers, prior to shooting the Su-24 down.

Update

Here’s an update from CBS News:

Turkey says the Russian plane strayed just over a mile into its airspace, and was there for only 17 seconds when it was fired on by a Turkish F-16. The Russian jet crashed in Syria, but Turkey’s president said Wednesday that some pieces of it fell inside his country.

And that’s what Turkey says. 17 seconds and kablooey sure sounds trigger-happy to me.

Update 2

Retired U. S. Air Force Gen. Charles Dunlap, at The Hill, notes:

The problem here is that the Turks are not asserting that any armed attack took place or, for that matter, that any armed attack was even being contemplated by the Russians. Instead, in a letter to the U.N., the Turks only claimed that the Russians had “violated their national airspace to a depth of 1.36 to 1.15 miles in length for 17 seconds.” They also say that the Russians were warned “10 times” (something the Russians dispute) and that the Turkish jets fired upon them in accordance with the Turks’ “rules of engagement.” Of course, national rules of engagement cannot trump the requirements of international law. Moreover, international law also requires any force in self-defense be proportional to the threat addressed.
Thus, the legal question is this: Is a mere 17-second border incursion of such significance and scale as to justify as “proportional” the use of deadly force as the only recourse — particularly where there is no indication that the Russians were going to actually attack anything on Turkish soil?

The U.S., so far, is staying mum about what it may know about the precise location of the planes (which the Russians insist never entered Turkish airspace). What is more is that even if the Russians had penetrated Turkish airspace, that fact alone would not necessarily legally authorize the use of force, absent a showing of hostile intent (which the Turks are not alleging). Additionally, it is quite possible that the Russian aircraft may have penetrated Turkish airspace — if at all — because of a bona fide navigational misunderstanding occasioned by the satellite guidance system the Russians employ. Navigation errors are not an adequate reason to use deadly force.

There are rumors floating around that the Turkish action was revenge for interfering with the lucrative oil trade it was carrying on with DAESH. In related news, Erdogan’s son is Turkey’s Minister of Energy and owner of an oil company.

15 comments