Unendorsement

Does the former Bush and Obama Defense Secretary Robert M. Gates’s description of the “president we need” sound anything like the incumbent or any of the candidates out there to you? Me, neither. This in particular sounds like a slam on the whole bunch:

We need a president who understands the system of government bequeathed to us by the Founders — and grasps the reality that with power divided among three branches of government, building coalitions and making compromises are the only ways anything lasting can get done. Primal screaming may be good therapy, but it is a poor substitute for practical politics. Arch-conservatives may want little government and arch-liberals may want a lot, but many functions of government are critical to our well-being, and they can be carried out effectively only if Congress and the president work together. Those who believe that compromise is synonymous with selling out or giving up one’s principles need to retake eighth-grade American history. The next president needs to have a core philosophy and set of principles, but he or she also needs to be a pragmatic and skilled political leader — like Franklin D. Roosevelt and Ronald Reagan.

And this:

The next president must be resolute. He or she must be very cautious about drawing red lines in foreign policy, but other leaders must know that crossing a red line drawn by the president of the United States will have serious — even fatal — consequences.

sounds quite a bit like a direct criticism of President Obama to me. I hate to be the one to break it to Sec. Gates but whomever is elected will not greatly resemble the picture he’s painting.

2 comments

Suiting Means to Ends

Here’s the conclusion of Bjorn Lomborg’s paper in which he analyzes the effects of all current climate change proposals:

Based on climate model simulations, the emission cuts that have been proposed by the US, the EU, China and the RoW will reduce temperature increases by the end of the century, but almost all of the expected warming will still take place by 2100.

Because the climate policy impacts from individual countries are almost additive, they can be almost perfectly partitioned as is evidenced in Table 1. This shows that in the optimistic case, the EU and China each reduce mean global temperature by 2100 of about 0.05°C, and the US and the RoW each reducing a bit more than 0.03°C.

As Wigley (1998) found for the Kyoto Protocol, the emissions reductions promised until 2030 will do little to stabilize the climate and their impact will be undetectable for many decades. This clearly indicates that if we want to reduce climate impacts significantly, we will have to find better ways than the ones currently proposed.

which certainly supports what I said a day or so ago.

5 comments

The Faceless

They haven’t managed to come up with a picture of her yet but evidence has emerged that Tashfeen Malik, one of the two individuals to whom the murders in San Bernardino are being attributed, pledged allegianace to Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi:

One of the two people involved in the San Bernardino attack that killed 14 people pledged allegiance to the leader of the Islamic State, the clearest indication yet that this was an act of terrorism, according to two law enforcement officials.

The officials said Tashfeen Malik, 27, the Pakistani wife of the other shooter, made the statement on a Facebook page. It’s not immediately clear when she posted the declaration referring to Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, the emir of the self-proclaimed Islamic State, the terrorist group that says it has established a caliphate in Syria and Iraq.

When news of the attack was first reported, my immediate reaction was that it was either a game or a rehearsal. Subsequent events, if only the sheer volume of weapons and matériel recovered from the couple’s home, have lent some weight to the idea that attacks of a very different sort were being planned which suddenly transmogrified into shooting up an office Christmas party. Some are suggesting that a certain level of volatility should be expected of someone who’s planning a terrorist attack but I don’t know that.

8 comments

There’s Corruption and Abuse of Power and Then There’s Corruption and Abuse of Power

Writing in the New York Times columnist Charles Blow declaims:

Emanuel may not be able to save himself. Everything about the killing of McDonald over 400 days ago, including the slithering about of Chicago officials in their efforts to suppress video of his murder, stinks to high heaven. There is the $5 million settlement with the family, the timing of that settlement, the strenuous efforts to keep the tape from public view, the long delay in charging the officer who did the shooting.

It all makes one ask: How much is the life of a teenager worth? To what length would officials go to bury visual evidence that he had been shot down in the street like a dog? Are officials so desperately afraid of losing their jobs that they would conceal details about the loss of a boy’s life?

and

Police officers “doing whatever they wanted to do” with no worry about repercussions or accountability? That is the very nature of corruption and abuse of power. The federal government will have no choice but to step in if it cares at all about public confidence in the local officials in America’s third largest city.

I would bet a shiny new dime that Mayor Emanuel will be just fine until and unless the ongoing outcry begins to touch the incumbent president or affect Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaign adversely. In which case off the sled he goes!

6 comments

To Protect and Serve^Ourselves

Speaking of making friends, Steve Cohen, writing at the New Republic, points out that part of the problem with the Chicago Police Department is its collective bargaining agreement:

The collective bargaining agreement between the City of Chicago and Lodge No. 7 of the Fraternal Order of Police (FOP) is not an exciting document. Many of its 158 densely worded pages are devoted to topics like insurance subrogation and access to the mailboxes at department headquarters. In 2014, the City Council voted unanimously, 49-0, to approve the current agreement, which runs through June 30, 2017. Until recently, the next set of negotiations promised to play out the same way the last one did, the same way similar ones have, for years, in municipalities big and small, all across the country: quietly, behind closed doors, far from the eyes of the communities most affected by the outcome.

Now, as racial justice activists shine new light on the troubling consequences of police union contracting nationwide, Chicago has its own morbid reasons to scrutinize what has long been a fatally overlooked aspect of a fatally overlooked crisis. Within the pervasive system of corruption, complicity, and negligence that led to Laquan McDonald’s death and then facilitated its cover-up, Chicago’s police officers union has emerged not just as a political impediment to reform, but also as a major institutional foundation underpinning racial injustice.

Let’s say, arguendo, that Mr. Cohen is right and the CPD’s collective bargaining contract is a barrier to effective oversight? What’s the proper policy solution?

For a follow-up question is there a problem with providing proper oversight to any other groups of public employees with union representation and if not why not?

3 comments

The Frog Test

The editors of the Chicago Sun-Times are calling for the release of yet another dash cam video of a police shooting the CPD has been sitting on:

City officials are said to be wavering in their determination not to release a dashboard camera video that shows the 2014 shooting of a black man named Ronald Johnson III.

They should stop wavering and release the video. At a time when many Chicagoans are angry about what a similar video showed of the 2014 shooting of Laquan McDonald, the city can’t appear to be stonewalling.

Police fatally shot Johnson in October 2014 after police pulled over a car in which he was riding with friends at 53rd Street and King Drive. Johnson ran, pursued by officers. Another officer pulled up, jumped out of his car and fired five times at Johnson, killing him.

Just as in the McDonald case, the police video has been under wraps. Johnson’s mother and a lawyer representing her in a wrongful death lawsuit say the video shows Johnson had nothing in his hands as he ran. They say the video shows the officer beginning to fire within seconds of leaving his car. They want a Cook County judge to order the video be released publicly.

but are still holding their peace on criticisms of the mayor or other city higher-ups. Meanwhile, Chuy Garcia blames Emanuel for the delay in the release of the video of Laquan McDonld’s shooting:

CHICAGO — Cook County Board Commissioner Jesus “Chuy” Garcia says Mayor Emanuel is also to blame for the Laquan McDonald controversy.

“The mayor has been involved in an effort to conceal information regarding this incident, this tragedy, miscarriage of justice,” Garcia said in an interview on CNN. “It was obvious that the video would have had profound impact had it been released when it occurred. and the mayor has taken great steps to ensure that it’s concealed.”

Garcia went on to say that the city’s quick settlement with Laquan McDonald’s family is another indication that Emanuel was trying to hide something.

Garcia also says releasing the video would have had a significant impact on the runoff election between himself and the mayor.

while the mayor is trying to dodge the bullet:

CHICAGO — On the day after he dismissed his police superintendent, Mayor Rahm Emanuel on Wednesday faced new questions over a police shooting and his administration’s delay of several months in releasing a video of that episode. But he said that he did not intend to resign.

“We have a process; it’s called the election,” Mr. Emanuel, in his second term as mayor, said during a prickly interview with reporters from Politico, a political news organization, at the Willis Tower.

“The voters spoke. I’ll be held accountable and responsible for my actions and decisions I make, and that’s how I approach it.”

I think that argument would have a bit more force if the mayor had stood for election after the video was released. As it is, the video was suppressed until the election was safely over. The people may have spoken but the specific question at hand is whether they would have said the same thing if they’d been in full possession of the facts.

Ron Fournier, writing at National Journal summarizes:

I’ve got noth­ing against Emanuel. I’ve known him since 1992 and be­nefited from his stra­tegic leaks in the Clin­ton White House. And I know this: Emanuel epi­tom­izes a brand of polit­ics that puts loy­alty and elect­or­al suc­cess above all else. He was edu­cated in the school of Clin­ton, where the ends jus­ti­fy the means, and ruled the Obama White House when it ca­pit­u­lated to the cul­ture of Wash­ing­ton that his boss had vowed to fight.

And then off he went to Chica­go, a his­tor­ic­ally cor­rupt city with a po­lice de­part­ment known for hid­ing mis­con­duct and bru­tal­ity.
On Oct. 20, 2014, po­lice of­ficer Jason Van Dyke fired 16 times at 17-year-old Laquan Mc­Don­ald, killing him. The next day, a po­lice de­part­ment state­ment claimed the teen­ager was shot while ap­proach­ing po­lice of­ficers. That was a lie.

A dash-cam video that au­thor­it­ies had ac­cess to with­in hours of the shoot­ing shows Mc­Don­ald hold­ing a knife and veer­ing away from of­ficers when he was shot. Why did the po­lice de­part­ment claim oth­er­wise? Why wasn’t the video re­leased to the pub­lic? Why didn’t the city in­vest­ig­ate the fact that 86 minutes of oth­er video sur­veil­lance foot­age of the crime scene was sus­pi­ciously miss­ing?
The most lo­gic­al con­clu­sion is that po­lice wanted to duck ac­count­ab­il­ity and Emanuel wanted to avoid los­ing his Feb. 24, 2015 reelec­tion amid na­tion­al un­rest over a po­lice shoot­ing in Fer­guson, Mis­souri.

Mr. Fournier opens his column with an imagined actual from the president:

Pres­id­ent Obama needs to mail Rahm Emanuel a dead fish in a box. Hil­lary Clin­ton should de­liv­er it. For the in­teg­rity of the party that rep­res­ents a vast ma­jor­ity of black voters, Demo­crat­ic lead­ers every­where need to send the Chica­go may­or a mes­sage: You’re dead to us.
A long­time lieu­ten­ant for the Clin­ton fam­ily and former chief of staff in the Obama White House, Emanuel nev­er hes­it­ated to muscle weak or dis­loy­al Demo­crats out of power. It’s time to flip the script on the en­for­cer nick­named “Rahmbo.”
Emanuel once sent a poll­ster who was late de­liv­er­ing a sur­vey res­ult a dead fish in a box. The night Bill Clin­ton won the 1992 pres­id­en­tial elec­tion, his aides were cel­eb­rat­ing around a pic­nic table when Emanuel picked up a knife and shouted the names of politi­cians who had “f****ed us.” After each name, Emanuel de­clared, “Dead man!”

There isn’t a chance of this happening. Emanuel knows where the figurative bodies are buried.

I never expected Rahm Emanuel to serve out his second term as mayor—I expected him to be needed to work on Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaign. Unfortunately for Chicago, his value to the Clinton campaign is waning as this scandal waxes. The cracks are starting to appear, as reported by CNN:

(CNN)Hillary Clinton supports an independent investigation into the Chicago Police Department, her campaign spokesman said Wednesday, days after the department released video of the Laquan McDonald’s shooting death at the hands of police.

“Hillary Clinton is deeply troubled by the shooting of Laquan McDonald and the outstanding questions related to both the shooting and the video,” said Brian Fallon, Clinton’s press secretary. “Mayor Emanuel’s call for a task force to review practices of the Chicago Police Department is an important step, but given the gravity of this tragic situation, she supports a full review by the Department of Justice.”

This lines Clinton up against Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel, a longtime Clinton aide who worked for former President Bill Clinton in the White House.

instantiating the wisecrack that if you want a friend in Washington, buy a dog.

1 comment

Folie à deux

Like many other of my fellow Americans, last night my attention was fixed to the story unfolding on my television screen of the shooting in San Bernardino in Southern California:

SAN BERNARDINO, Calif.—Police were still searching for a motive late Wednesday night after two shooters stormed a holiday gathering for county employees and killed 14 people in the deadliest mass shooting in the U.S. in three years.

Syed Farook and his wife, Tashfeen Malik, dropped off their six-month baby girl with Mr. Farook’s mother early Wednesday morning, a family member said. Mr. Farook, a San Bernardino County employee, later attended a work holiday event and at some point, left the party in anger, law-enforcement officials said.

Mr. Farook, 28 years old, then allegedly returned 10 minutes to 30 minutes later, with Ms. Malik, 27. The pair, dressed in “assault-style clothing” opened fire, according to police, killing 14 people and wounding 17 others.

Hours later, the couple were killed in a gunbattle on the street with police, just 2 miles from where the mass shooting had occurred. Authorities said the pair were found armed with assault rifles and semiautomatic handguns.

Officials didn’t rule out terrorism and said they were investigating any possible connections to Islamic State, but so far had uncovered nothing linking the pair to the terrorist group.

Law-enforcement officials said they were just starting what would be a long investigation, and were searching for others who may have been involved in planning the attack. A third person was still in custody, but officials said it was unclear if that person was connected to the shooting.

Based on what we know now, the situation is a worst case: domestic terrorism and Islamist terrorism and workplace-related violence. Already there have been calls for simplistic solutions only tangentially related to this particular incident including from the president of the United States. Something I think we should keep in mind is that for some of our people a ban on certain classes of weapons is no less inflammatory (or unconstitutional) than a ban on Muslims would be to others.

Here’s my proposal. First, let’s stop the endless repetition of provably untrue generalizations. Then let’s start thinking in terms of mitigating risks rather than ending threats.

8 comments

Brooks’s Policy Preferences

David Brooks puts his policy preferences on dealing with carbon emissions into Alexander Hamilton’s mouth:

Well, I ventured, if you’re skeptical about our own policies, Mr. Founding Father, what would you do?

Look at what you’re already doing, he countered. The United States has the fastest rate of reduction of CO2 emissions of any major nation on earth, back to pre-1996 levels.

That’s in part because of fracking. Natural gas is replacing coal, and natural gas emits about half as much carbon dioxide.

The larger lesson is that innovation is the key. Green energy will beat dirty energy only when it makes technical and economic sense.

Hamilton reminded me that he often used government money to stoke innovation. Manzi and Wehner suggest that one of our great national science labs could work on geoengineering problems to remove CO2 from the atmosphere. Another could investigate cogeneration and small-scale energy reduction systems. We could increase funding on battery and smart-grid research. If we move to mainly solar power, we’ll need much more efficient national transmission methods. Maybe there’s a partial answer in increased vegetation.

Some quick notes and then I’ll counter with my own. There’s something that non-science types like Mr. Brooks simply refuse to understand. There is no Moore’s Law of batteries (there may soon be no Moore’s Law period but that’s a subject for another post). Investments in batteries may pay off in one year or ten years or never.

IMO geoengineering is an area crying out for an X-Prize sort of competition. That would be tremendously better than a government program which would inevitably benefit the politically connected.

And why do people always mean “roads and bridges” when they talk about infrastructure spending? Roads and bridges tend to be constructed based on an expectation of a 30-50 year cycle. Would you really bet that a new road will have a life expectancy of 50 years? Power grid investment is a much better bet, it’s something that’s necessary for all of the green energy schemes the Brookses of the world posit, and private companies won’t build a better grid any more than they will build roads.

Here’s how I’d prioritize things. I think that the biggest sources of carbon emissions are:

  1. U. S. transportation
  2. Chinese heavy industry
  3. The Chinese construction industry

With me so far? I don’t think we can do anything about (c). My first step in reducing the emissions in (a) would be stop subsidizing it. After that I’d impose a stiff carbon tax (mostly for geopolitical and stewardship reasons).

We can actually do more about (b) than we care to think. The Chinese aren’t running all those coal-fired power plants for fun, you know. They’re generating exports. If you want to reduce China’s industrial carbon emissions, stop importing Chinese stuff.

6 comments

Visa Abuse

I found this Buzzfeed post on the abuse of H-2 work visas about as upsetting as it gets:

MOULTRIE, Georgia — “All you black American people, fuck you all…just go to the office and pick up your check,” the supervisor at Hamilton Growers told workers during a mass layoff in June 2009.
The following season, according to a lawsuit filed by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, about 80 workers, many of them black, were simply told: “All you Americans are fired.”

I know from first hand experience that this sort of abuse of work visas has been going on for at least the last 40 years and probably a lot longer. And it’s not limited to H-2s. It’s true of H1-B visas and L1 visas, too. It’s precisely why I’ve argued for a central job clearing house where employers who are seeking work visas for imported employees need to post the jobs they’re putting on offer. The article lists a lot of the tricks.

I find this particularly galling:

What’s more, companies often do this with the complicity of government officials, records show. State and federal authorities have allowed companies to violate the spirit — and often the letter — of the law with bogus recruitment efforts that are clearly designed to keep Americans off the payroll. And when regulators are alerted to potential problems, the response is often ineffectual.

And people wonder why the suicide rate is going up among Americans.

I agree with Chesterton. It is terrible to contemplate how few politicians are hanged in this country.

5 comments

Rahm and the Editors

Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel is taking a beating at the hands of the country’s newspaper editors this morning. The editors of the New York Times are no more impressed by the steps the mayor took yesterday than I was:

Mayor Rahm Emanuel demonstrated a willful ignorance when he talked about the murder charges against the police officer who shot Mr. McDonald, seeking to depict the cop as a rogue officer. He showed a complete lack of comprehension on Tuesday when he explained that he had decided to fire his increasingly unpopular police superintendent, Garry McCarthy, not because he failed in his leadership role, but because he had become “a distraction.”

Mayor Rahm Emanuel of Chicago, left, and police Superintendent Garry McCarthy announcing first-degree murder charges against the police officer who shot Laquan McDonald.Op-Ed Contributor: Cover-Up in ChicagoNOV. 30, 2015
Mr. Emanuel’s announcement that he had appointed a task force that will review the Police Department’s accountability procedures is too little, too late. The fact is, his administration, the Police Department and the prosecutor’s office have lost credibility on this case. Officials must have known what was on that video more than a year ago, and yet they saw no reason to seek a sweeping review of the police procedures until this week.

The question they can’t quite bring themselves to ask is why has the Justice Department, apparently, been sitting on its hands? It opened its investigation a year ago. Where’s the beef?

The Washington Post‘s editors have noticed that, too:

And what about the feds? FBI and Justice Department officials began investigating the McDonald killing just weeks after the fact. If Ms. Alvarez wouldn’t move to bring Mr. Van Dyke to justice, why couldn’t they? It’s not just that Chicago’s police force needs an overhaul (though it does); in the McDonald case itself, there must be accountability for the apparent lies, evasions and coverup that goes beyond the prosecution of one police officer.

They also call for Anita Alvarez, the Cook County States Attorney, to be more forthcoming about her inaction or resign.

Astonishingly, our local papers are giving the mayor a day off today.

4 comments