What’s Emanuel’s Big Picture?

After cataloguing Rahm Emanuel’s woes, this article in Forbes brings up a really interesting point:

Worryingly for Emanuel’s administration, the union seems to be framing the dispute as a tradeoff between education and economic development, with Sharkey noting that, “We need to be asking why we’re spending on things like river walks when our schools aren’t funded.”

He was referring to a $99 million overhaul of the Chicago Riverwalk, a path running along the Chicago River’s south bank in the middle of downtown. The Riverwalk, which Emanuel touts as a prime urban attraction, it is one of the steps his administration has taken to make Chicago more welcoming and economically viable.

The city’s 2012 draft plan to revitalize the local economy, “A Plan for Economic Growth and Jobs,” concluded that the city’s future rests on its ability to compete with other regions around the globe. But it gave the Windy City poor marks compared with other major metropolitan areas.

The report noted that New York and Los Angeles grew four times faster than Chicago over the most recent decade as Chicago lagged behind in creating jobs and boosting income. While entrepreneurship rose, manufacturing—a strong source of middle class jobs for decades—has slowed, the draft plan found.

Riverwalk is an easy target because it is highly visible, has a large price tag, and is financed with a federal loan backed by a local motor fuel tax that, some argue, could be better used for purposes such as municipal schools. At the same time, Emanuel, who avoided raising taxes in his first term, in September asked for a huge property tax increase to cover some of the city’s shortfall—a proposal that is anything but popular as he fights to recover the trust of city residents.

That’s the kind of thing that’s made me wonder from time to time if Rahm Emanuel’s plan for curing the city’s problems weren’t gentrification: driving poor people out of the city and providing amenities to attract the well-to-do into the city. When you look at the long list of regressive taxes and the list of lifestyle-type upgrades he’s supported it’s a really tempting hypothesis.

4 comments

Is the TPP the Least-Loved Treaty in History?

I have yet to read a coherent defense of the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement from anybody who wasn’t actually part of the Obama Administration. Here are eight reasons the TPP shouldn’t be approved.

0 comments

How to Make Friends and Influence Aldermen

Well, if Anita Alvarez hasn’t started updating her resume, this might be a good opportunity:

Embattled State’s Attorney Anita Alvarez chose to not attend a marathon City Council committee hearing Tuesday on police misconduct in the wake of the ongoing scandal at the Chicago Police Department.

The Public Safety Committee’s vice chairman, Ald. Joe Moreno (1st Ward), said Alvarez was invited to face questions from aldermen but did not give a reason for declining.

“It’s a shame she wasn’t here to answer to the public on why it took 400 days to bring charges against Van Dyke,” Moreno said. “We arranged a meeting on this date to accommodate her schedule and her office didn’t inform us that she wasn’t coming until late last evening.”

Sally Daly, a spokeswoman for Alvarez, responded with the following statement:

“The State’s Attorney has been accountable in discussing her decision to bring the charge of first degree murder against Officer Van Dyke for the murder of Laquan McDonald. Alderman Moreno should be made accountable to explain why he and other City Council members sat on their hands and approved a $5 million settlement without viewing the video or demanding its release. Shame on them for virtually ignoring this case when they were in a position to do something about it and then trying to politicize it after they were caught napping.”

I can understand why she might not want to submit to the ordeal but in Chicago City Council members are powerful politicians. Just the sort of people whose support you’ll need for what will undoubtedly be a grueling re-election campaign. You don’t stonewall and/or insult them. At least not if you want to keep your job. Cook County Board President Toni Preckwinkle and Illinois Attorney General have already thrown her under the bus. Doesn’t she think she needs friends?

3 comments

And the Not So Welcome

However, this apparent course correction in U. S. policy is not nearly so welcome. Via Reuters:

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The U.S. Navy is unlikely to carry out another patrol within 12 nautical miles of Chinese-built islands in the South China Sea this year as officials had initially suggested, three U.S. defense officials said on Monday.

Naval commanders had hoped to carry out another “freedom of navigation” exercise in the region as early as December as part of a plan to regularly send vessels into the area and exercise what the United States views as its rights under international law, officials have said.

But the Obama administration, which is weighing the risks of raising tensions with Beijing at a time when the United States is focused on the fight against Islamic State, has not approved the next such patrol, said the officials, who asked not to be named.

One official said the next U.S. Navy sail-by was likely to come in January, in what would be the second direct challenge to the territorial limits China effectively claims around seven artificial islands in one of the world’s busiest sea lanes.

The Navy conducted a similar exercise in October to underscore the U.S. position that the crucial sea lane should be treated as international waters.

In that exercise, the guided missile destroyer Lassen sailed close to one of China’s manmade islands in October, drawing an angry rebuke from China and a shadowing patrol.

Ensuring the freedom of navigation of the sealanes has been a critical part of the U. S. grand strategy for more than 200 years. The Chinese moves in the South China Sea are clearly aggressive and equally clearly threaten the freedom of navigation. The Navy was right to conduct its exercises and the Obama Administration is wrong in curtailing them.

I’m probably one of the few who doesn’t consider the Chinese a major threat but that doesn’t mean we should abandon our long-running strategic objectives for the sake of making nice with them, either.

Hat tip: The American Interest

8 comments

Change of Course

I was surprised when I saw this article at ABC News:

Following lengthy talks with Russian President Vladimir Putin in Moscow today, U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry has said the United States is not seeking regime change in Syria and that the U.S. and Russia see the conflict “fundamentally very similarly.”

“The United States and its partners are not seeking so-called regime change as it is known in Syria,” Kerry said in a news conference inside the Kremlin, before immediately adding that the U.S. continues to believe that Syrian President Bashar al-Assad has no possibility of remaining the country’s leader in the future. However, Kerry said the talks didn’t focus on “what can or can’t be done immediately about Assad” but rather on establishing a political process where Syrians will be able to choose their own leader.

The statement appeared to be the most explicit sign yet that the U.S. is softening its policy towards Assad and marked a significant rhetorical shift for the U.S. towards Russia’s policy in Syria, which previously American officials have said was almost fundamentally at odds with their own.

Short form: Assad stays for now; getting rid of the Alawite regime is not U. S. policy. That strikes me as a major and welcome course correction in American policy.

My immediate reaction was that Sec. Kerry had spoken out of turn and the Obama Administration would be reversing him shortly. However, those who’ve seen the pictures of Victoria Nuland’s reaction to Sec. Kerry’s announcement (to paraphrase it looks as though she’s just eaten a whole cow pie) suggests that she’s been overruled.

16 comments

It’s All About Rahm

Writing at City Journal Aaron Renn summarizes Rahm Emanuel’s tenure in office as mayor of Chicago:

Emanuel’s leadership style came with fatal flaws. A political streetfighter by inclination, he lacks an operational orientation. He didn’t appear to grasp the scope of the city’s financial problems until four years after he was first elected, when Chicago’s bond rating was cut to junk. His infrastructure trust fizzled. The schools went from bad to worse, with his first CPS leader forced out and his second pleading guilty to corruption. He didn’t get it that Chicago’s police department hadn’t been fundamentally reformed the way New York’s and Los Angeles’s had been.

Emanuel’s governing style has been all tactics, no strategy. He’ll pick up the phone to twist the arm of a CEO or fight to win the day’s media cycle. But what’s his vision for the city?

That’s what happens when public service become entirely about the personal ambitions and goals of the office holders. You get lots of virtue-signalling, big dreams, and major initiatives but, without “operational orientation” no problem-solving.

There’s got to be some third alternative—something other than ideology or personal aggrandizement as motivators for office holders.

What I don’t think that Mr. Renn grasped about Rahm Emanuel when he voted for him in 2011 is that Emanuel has migrated from sinecure to sincecure, buoyed by his success as a fund-raiser which in turn was undergirded by being a partisan firebrand. That doesn’t work in Chicago. There is no other party to blame here. Just Democrats.

7 comments

No Relation Between Medicare and Private Spending?

I’m still digesting this article in the New York Times about a study finding that the important thing to recognize about the relationship between per capita Medicare spending and spending by private insurance is that there isn’t one:

As part of his push for the Affordable Care Act in 2009, President Obama came to Central High School to laud this community as a model of better, cheaper health care. “You’re getting better results while wasting less money,” he told the crowd. His visit had come amid similar praise from television broadcasts, a documentary film and a much-read New Yorker article.

All of the attention stemmed from academic work showing that Grand Junction spent far less money on Medicare treatments – with no apparent detriment to people’s health. The lesson seemed obvious: If the rest of the country became more like Grand Junction, this nation’s notoriously high medical costs would fall.

But a new study casts doubt on that simple message.

The research looked not only at Medicare but also at a huge, new database drawn from private-insurance plans – the sorts used by most Americans for health care. And it shows that places that spend less on Medicare do not necessarily spend less on health care over all. Grand Junction, as it happens, is one of the most expensive health care markets in the country for the privately insured – despite its unusually low spending on Medicare.

My intuition is that it supports the claim I’ve made from time to time, that Medicare functions like a price support system for healthcare, and that otherwise hospitals operate just like restaurants do but given my meager understanding of the article and the underlying study at this point it would be premature to conclude that.

I just wanted to bring it to your attention before I forgot about it.

4 comments

How to Tell the Birds from the Flowers

One way to think about preferences in tax policy is by comparing the preferences to an economically optimal policy. Think about that and the policies your favorite politicians support when you read this post at RealClearPolicy by Jason Fichtner of the Mercatus Center and Jacob Feldman from the Bureau of Labor Statistics:

The most basic goal of tax policy is to raise enough revenue to meet the government’s spending requirements in the way that has the least impact on the economy. Academic research suggests that, to meet this goal, a successful system should be simple, equitable, permanent, and predictable.

The U.S. tax code does not live up to these standards. In fact, while most developed countries have lowered their corporate tax rates and restructured their tax systems to make them simpler, the United States appears to be taking the opposite approach. The current tax code distorts market decisions and hampers job creation, reducing both economic growth and tax revenue.

They argue for a few basic strategies:

  • Don’t raise tax rates.
  • Bring corporate income tax rates into line with those in other OECD countries.
  • Reform the mortgage interest income tax deduction and the “marriage penalty”
  • Adopt “full expensing” of capital expenses.

Although I think the issue of increasing tax rates is a bit more complicated than they’re suggesting, I should point out that most of the things they’re talking about doing are measures that regular readers here would recognize. I’ve been arguing for most of them for decades.

There is no mystery here. They aren’t top secret. Most make sense from an economic perspective.

Diverging slightly, I wonder how many people realize how incredibly regressive the home mortgage interest deduction is? Talk about welfare for the rich!

7 comments

The Search for the Mythical Consumer-Driven Healthcare

I wish more people understood and appreciated what Michael Hitzlik is saying in his LA Times column:

To begin with, true consumer-driven healthcare requires three things. These are: information about the prices charged by competing providers for given treatments; reliable data about the outcomes of medical options for treating any given condition or syndrome; and consumers who are inclined or able to base their healthcare decisions on the first two factors.

Comparative prices are hard to come by today even in intensely competitive healthcare markets such as big cities, much less in regions with only a small number of providers. Comparative outcomes? These often are hard even for trained clinicians to determine, and even then only after years of research; expecting patients to have this data at hand is chimerical. Finally, the vast majority of patient decisions may be utterly independent of cost and known outcome.

The key question really is how consumers actually respond to cost and price incentives. That’s because consumer-driven healthcare invariably relies on price signals to guide consumer behavior.

The answer is that although “consumer-driven healthcare” does result in patients economizing on their healthcare spending it doesn’t necessarily result in lower costs for two reasons.

First, patients frequently don’t distinguish between necessary care and unnecessary care. They’ll skip doses of medication to save money or stop taking it entirely. They won’t make follow-up appointments. And so on.

Additionally, much of healthcare is physician-driven. By training, predisposition, and incentive physicians are inclined to provide more care.

The consumer that we should be looking at is not the patient but the physician. The PPACA took baby steps in that direction but that’s all they were. Baby steps.

1 comment

It’s the Assumptions

I agree with what Fred Barnes has to say in his Wall Street Journal column in one particular:

Now Democrats have a new definition of tax reform. “They want to broaden the base and raise tax rates,” says Douglas Holtz-Eakin, the former head of the Congressional Budget Office. Rather than promote economic growth—a goal of Mr. Bradley and Mr. Gephardt—this approach is almost certain to hamper it. After nearly seven years of sluggish growth during the Obama era, the party seems to think that even an anemic 2% annual increase in GDP is too much.

It takes only a few minutes of watching the Democratic presidential debates to see how profoundly the party’s economic thinking has shifted to the left. Tax cuts are shunned and plans for achieving economic growth are barely mentioned. Tax increases are now the preferred choice of Democrats.

There’s an underlying assumption of slow or no growth. “Economic policy” consists mostly of figuring out how to divvy up the proceeds.

Unfortunately, Mr. Barnes has a weak assumption of his own—he, like most Republicans, assumes that tax cuts always result in economic growth. I think that a better understanding would be that under certain circumstances tax cuts may produce economic growth. I see little evidence that we have those circumstances now.

Fortunately for the Republicans there’s even less evidence that removing money from the private sector (which is what taxation is after all) will result in anything other than less economic growth. Sec. Clinton’s views are clearly that if you get the best minds (i.e. graduates from the best schools) and the biggest companies to put together a plan it will result in more growth, an idea that represents the best economic thought of, say, 1960.

The nostalgia of both political parties is palpable. It might be nice to have some thinking that reflected the circumstances of the early 21st century.

5 comments