Are We Seeing the Death Throes of Multiculturalism?

I believe strongly that people have a right to their own cultures. However, I tend to define such a right along the lines of jus sanguinis rather than jus terra—I think it belongs to the people rather than to the country they happen to be in. It’s one of the reasons I’m so insistent on gradual immigration rather than mass immigration. I think that if what I think of as “my culture” is to survive it will need to assimilate new immigrants relatively slowly, acculturating them over time.

The incident in Cologne on New Year’s Eve was criminal activity but it wasn’t merely criminal activity. It was a cultural clash. Germany now has a significant number of people who believe that unaccompanied women are fair game for harassment and abuse, even rape.

That’s not as extreme as you might believe. Many people in this country believe that if you find a $20 bill in the street taking it isn’t stealing. The basic difference is whether you think of women as property or not.

IMO the reality is that cultures are in fact drastically different and drastically different cultures can’t coexist in the same space. One will dominate; the other will be subordinated and ultimately disappear. “Ultimately” can be a pretty long time if you’re a woman who’s afraid to walk down the street you could walk down without fear last week.

10 comments

How Old Are Fairy Tales?

I found this study interesting. Phylogenetic analysis suggests that the common fairy tales may be 5,000 years old.

I wonder how they distinguished between stories that had been passed along and modified over time and those that were just re-invented somewhere else? There are only so many plot lines (most say three). Jung didn’t think they’d been passed along; he thought they were a reflection of the programming of the human brain.

2 comments

Over-Regulation Is Not a Sufficient Explanation

Do I expect too much from journalists? When I see an article titled “Why America Stopped Being a Startup Nation” and I read it in the expectation that it will actually have a plausible explanation for why so many fewer companies are being started than used to be the case, am I wrong to be disappointed. That was the case with this post from Noah Smith at Bloomberg. Fortunately, it still had something of value—dashing cold water on the idea that it can be explained by over-regulation:

Goldschlag and Tabarrok find that regulation has increased quite a lot in most industries, especially in manufacturing…

But correlation doesn’t equal causation. If the increase in regulation is causing the decrease in dynamism, we would expect that industries where the former has been greater to have experienced more of the latter.

When Goldschlag and Tabarrok run the numbers, however, they find no measurable relationship between rising regulation and declining dynamism at the industry level. Sectors where rules have become increasingly stringent have seen declines in startup rates that are no greater than sectors in which the level of regulation has been little changed.

One of the co-authors of the paper in question is Alex Tabarrok, notably libertarian in his views, so the findings are sufficiently a testimony against interest that they’re worthy of extra credence. If he was grinding an ax, it would be the other way.

That doesn’t mean that regulation is not one of the factors in the reduction in the rate of new business formation but it does strongly suggest that regulation is not dispositive. Off-hand I’d say that there were multiple factors involved including regulation, the number and size of the established companies, the highly-evolved character of product marketing today, and generational differences in attitude towards risk and reward.

As long as new company formation is slow and the large, established companies are more predisposed to reducing the number of employees they have on their payrolls than increasing them, it’s going to be tough to put all of the people who should be working and would be working if there were jobs for them back to work.

3 comments

What Business Are You In?

I don’t write many posts about hoodies but I found a quote from American Giant CEO Bayard Winthrop in this Business Insider post interesting enough that I wanted to comment on it:

“One of the great unspoken, dirty secrets about the apparel industry is that brands for the last 40 years have been investing a tiny amount in the product to sustain huge marketing and huge distribution costs,” Winthrop said. “In American Giant’s case, we do almost the exact opposite of that.”

He’s decided that American Giant is in the apparel business, not in retail or the store management business and he’s also decided to diffentiate his product based on quality and suitability to task.

I don’t think this problem is limited to apparel. If you look at the balance sheets of, say, pharmaceutical companies you’ll find that they’re actually marketing and lobbying companies that do a little medical research on the side.

What business is Apple in? I’d say that it’s primarily a retail and supply chain management company that has used savvy marketing to create mystique and brand loyalty. It’s possible that when Steve Jobs was around he could make the argument that it was a technology company but I’m not so sure that’s still the case.

I can’t help but remember Peter Drucker’s remark to the effect that most managers don’t know what business their companies are in.

17 comments

Will the CPS Declare Bankruptcy?

Republicans in the Illinois legislature are introducing bills to allow the Chicago Public Schools to declare bankruptcy and to place the school system in receivership under state auspices:

Republican legislative leaders on Wednesday are expected to unveil proposals to allow Chicago Public Schools to declare bankruptcy and to put the financially struggling school district under state supervision, sources said Tuesday.

It’s the latest move as Gov. Bruce Rauner and Mayor Rahm Emanuel continue to play the blame game over CPS’ $480 million budget shortfall that threatens layoffs and has led to heavy borrowing to keep the state’s largest school district afloat.

House Republican leader Jim Durkin and Senate Republican leader Christine Radogno are scheduled to unveil the proposals at a Wednesday morning news conference where an adviser said they’ll “introduce legislation pertaining to the fiscal crisis in the city of Chicago and the Chicago Public School system.” That also could include a provision allowing City Hall to declare bankruptcy as well, the source said.

I honestly don’t know what the state could do about the CPS’s problems. Year after year they’ve made promises they’re unable to make good on. The Illinois constitution prevents the CPS from reneging on the pension commitments they’ve made and which, frankly, there’s no way they can live up to.

I think that Gov. Rauner is making an error in drawing fire onto himself about the CPS’s problems and the failure of Illinois legislators to deliver the balanced budget they’re constitutionally required to enact. He should be letting Madigan (Speaker of the Illinois House) and Cullerton (president of the Illinois Senate) take the heat. After all, they’ve got all the power.

If he thinks he’s invulnerable, he’s wrong. The governor is the only elected official in the state who can be recalled. Thank you, Rod Blagojevich.

7 comments

Fish and Guests

Do you remember that wisecrack I mentioned the other day about fish and guests growing stale after three days? YouGov provides a little empirical evidence that’s the case in Germany:

62% of Germans now say the number of asylum seekers is too high, up from 53% in November – driven mainly by the hardening attitudes of women

Since the events of New Year’s Eve in Cologne, in which dozens of women were sexually assaulted and robbed by men described as of North African and Arab appearance, the tide has begun to turn against Germany’s open-door approach to immigration. Following protests by the right-wing Pegida movement involving fireworks and bottles being thrown at police, Angela Merkel proposed new measures to deny the right of asylum for those who have committed crimes or are on probation – where currently only asylum seekers who have been sentenced to at least three years’ imprisonment, and will not be at risk in their countries of origin, are forcibly deported.

New research by YouGov in Germany for the Bild newspaper reveals a sharp hardening of attitudes to immigration following the attacks in Cologne.

The percentage of Germans who think that they’ve already accepted too many refugees will rise and the percentage of those who think they can accept more will decline. Opinion has not reached the government-threatening level yet.

2 comments

Timing Is Everything

I genuinely wonder what Justice Roberts is thinking in hearing arguments in April on United States v. Texas, the challenge to President Obama’s change to deportation policy? That would suggest a ruling in June, just as the election is starting to heat up.

Does he want to get it out of the way? Is he doing his best to make it an election issue? I don’t get it.

7 comments

‘Splain Me

I’ve got to admit that I don’t know what “Medicare for All” means. We’re presently spending about $10,000 per Medicare beneficiary. A little back-of-the-envelope calcuation suggests spending of $3.1 trillion or about twice as much as we’re spending on healthcare now. Presumably, that isn’t what is meant.

If it’s a nice slogan for a single-payer system, fine. I supported a single-payer system for decades. When Congress stopped conforming to their own Sustainable Growth Rate formula and started passing “doc fixes” year after year, it became obvious to me that we don’t have the steely-eyed determination and, frankly, hardness of heart that would be needed for a single-payer system. Basically, you’ve got to be willing to cut spending. Unless something drastic were to change here single-payer in the United States would, in fact, mean $10,000 per beneficiary. To infinity and beyond!

That would be worse than a crime. It would be a mistake.

20 comments

The Next Technological Breakthrough Will Need More Capital Investment

I don’t see things in quite the same way as Robert Samuelson does, at least as expressed in his most recent column, reproduced at RealClearPolitics. I agree that there was a “special century” between 1870 and 1970:

We all know what happened. Primitive conditions gave way to modern amenities and technologies. In 1870, there were no homes with electricity, and few — if any — with indoor plumbing or central heating. By 1940, about 40 percent of homes had central heating, 60 percent had flush indoor toilets, 70 percent had running water and 80 percent had electricity.

But in some ways, we succeeded too well, suggests Gordon. The spectacular advances conditioned us to believe that rapid technological progress is an inherent feature of our economic system. Invention and innovation can be dialed up to solve any problem: reversing sluggish economic growth, curing cancer or combating global warming.

Not so, says Gordon. Rapid advances are not assured. What he shows is that technology-driven growth has varied substantially over time. It was fastest between 1870 and 1970 — a period he calls a “special century” — and slower both before and after.

How do you explain the growth in the 1990s? It wasn’t an illusion. Here’s my explanation.

Between 1980 and 2000 American businesses engaged in an enormous amount of capital investment and got very little out of it. First, they put computers on every desk. Then they committed to replacing those computers every few years. Then they networked the computers together. During all of that they received very little return for their investment.

But then in the mid-1990s there was a tipping point, synergy. The result was the Internet as we know it today with lots and lots of efficiencies, greater reach, whole new industries.

But today’s managers don’t remember the lean years of the 80s and the early 90s and all of that capital investment. Today’s businesses are very risk-averse.

The difference between today and 1900 is that we’ve picked the low-hanging fruit. There will be future technological breakthroughs but they will take even more capital investment, betting on the future rather than looking for a sure thing in the present.

I also think that some of the factors involved in the extraordinary risk-aversion we’ve seen over the last couple of decades is the growth of mammoth retirement funds and sovereign wealth funds, both groups pushing managers to avoid risk. They’re sowing the seeds of their own destruction.

10 comments

Official Growth vs. Actual Growth

Now that the Chinese authorities have announced that the country’s official growth rate for 2015 was 6.9%, I was relieved to find that Peter Martin’s take in the Sydney Morning Herald is so close to mine:

Its target growth rate is 7 per cent. Its official growth rate, released on Tuesday, is almost exactly the same, 6.9 per cent, suggesting either that China’s leaders are incredibly good at meeting targets, or that their frightened underlings are good at leaning on the figures to make it look as if they are.

The first is unlikely, given the leadership’s spectacular failure to get what it wants out of its own sharemarket, the world’s biggest. The Shanghai composite index plummeted 15 per cent at the start of the year, despite frantic efforts to prop it up.

What’s happening to the share index isn’t that important, except as an insight into a bigger game being played out on a larger canvas.
“Countries are like people,” says Patrick Chovanec, chief strategist at Silvercrest Asset Management in New York. “People do what works until it stops working, and then they keep doing it, because it used to work.”

China latched on to something that worked. Appallingly underdeveloped with embarrassingly low local purchasing power, it turned that weakness into a strength. Like Japan, South Korea and Singapore before it, used its low wages to tap into the rest of the world’s purchasing power. As as it sold more and more cheap goods it invested the proceeds in more and more factories and housing. It was bringing hundreds of millions of workers in from the country to cities.

As the number of its factories and housing units grew, its need for the rest of the world to buy even more of what it made grew; which it did, enabling China build even more factories and more accommodation, mostly with Australian iron ore.

Until China grew to the point where it dwarfed the economies it sold things to. On one measure it is now the world’s biggest economy, on another the world’s second-biggest. With the rest of the world unable to keep buying increasing amounts of what it produced it needed to try something different. It needed to let the growth rate slow and allow the spending of ordinary Chinese drive the economy.

It paid lip-service to the idea, but mostly it kept doing what it used to do.

If building more factories and accommodation had boosted growth before, surely it would do it again, its logic went. And it worked during the global financial crisis, sort-of. Its economy kept growing while the rest of the world’s stumbled.

But the rest of the world never really recovered, and China kept building increasingly useless factories and increasingly empty housing.

I’m not sure which is harder—forecasting China’s GDP growth rate for 2016 or figuring out what its actual growth rate was for 2015. Few believe the official numbers, presumably including the Chinese. If Mr. Martin’s figure is correct, that’s concerning for several reasons. Actual contraction would be bad enough but a nearly eight point gap between official and actual would suggest that official China is going off into Fantasyland even more than usual. I’m not sure how you can ever return to reality from that great a separation.

As Patrick Chovanec notes in the remainder of the SMH article, the Chinese authorities have mounted a tiger that they dare not dismount. In his words “they want a correction without having a correction”. I think they’ll be disappointed.

The one thing that I think is missing from Mr. Martin’s account of China’s rise is that it rose by beggaring its customers. China exported low cost goods and imported employment. We and China’s other customers did the opposite. In the United States that meant that people bought a lot of stuff, some borrowing (or dis-saving) to do it, those in the highest income brackets got a lot richer, and those who depended on an industrial America for their livelihoods lost their jobs.

That would have been bad enough but people living in countries in the next income tiers like Mexico did the same and people living in countries that would have liked to have climbed out of their holes in the same way that Japan, South Korea, and China have find it much harder to do so. China climbed the economic ladder and pulled it up after them.

There are 1,001 other implications for China’s growth and, now, its relative stagnation. Did the Europeans actual reduce net carbon production or did they just move it to China, safely out of sight and beyond control?

I can also list 1,001 things that the Chinese authorities should do but I can’t for the life of me imagine their doing any of them. For example they need to divest state-owned enterprises (as the Reuters article linked above points out). They need to make their banking system less opaque and much, much less government-controlled with the foreign ownership they committed to when they joined the WTO. They need to let their currency trade. If they want to stimulate their economy, they should give money to people rather than to state-owned businesses and discourage saving. They should discourage wealthy Chinese from sheltering their gains in foreign real estate. The list goes on but, as I said, I can’t imagine their actually doing any of them.

The remaining question is just how hard China’s hard landing is likely to be.

2 comments