Round Up the Usual Suspects!

The Guardian is reporting that the Turks have decided that the Syrian Kurds are responsible for Wednesday’s car bomb attack in Ankara:

Turkey has blamed Wednesday’s car bomb attack on a military convoy in Ankara on Kurds based in Syria, as another explosion hit a convoy in the south-east.

Turkish PM Ahmet Davutoğlu alleged that Wednesday’s attack, which left 28 dead, was carried out by a Syrian Kurdish fighter with links to the People’s Protection Units (YPG), a Kurdish militia that has been supported by the US in the fight against Islamic State in northern Syria. The outlawed Kurdistan Workers’ party (PKK) assisted with the attack, Davutoğlu said.

“We collected intelligence all night,” Davutoğlu told reporters in Ankara. “The perpetrators have been fully identified. The attack was carried out by YPG member Salih Necar, who came in from Syria.”

That the Kurds have been conducting a more or less successful campaign against DAESH, both in Iraq and Syria, and it is widely believed that the Turks are providing assistance to DAESH is probably just a coincidence.

7 comments

Modern Problems

As I was driving to work I heard an interview with the German ambassador to the United States. One of the issues that was broached made me prick up my ears. He was pushing for the U. S. to pitch in on providing financial support for Europe’s migrants. My reaction: not on your flameless cooker. No way, no how. The only way I would agree to such a thing is if the Europeans started contributing to the support of our Mexican and Central American migrants and on that they’re in arrears.

Europe is in the fix that it’s in because a) it’s the natural destination for Middle Eastern and African migrants; b) like a bull in a china shop Germany has lumbered into an open migration model; and c) the EU’s Schengen policy has resulted in the burden falling on Germany and Sweden.

Those are their problems. They can fix them any time they care to. They just don’t wanna.

Welcome to the 21st century. Mass migration without assimilation. Both the cost of migration and the cost of not assimilating have fallen. What else do you expect?

11 comments

Should Apple Budge?

Presumably, you’re already up to speed on the story of Apple’s refusal to decrypt an iPhone belonging to one of the San Bernardino terrorists, as reported here at USAToday:

WASHINGTON — Attempts by the FBI to force Apple to unlock the iPhone of a dead terrorist from December’s mass shooting in San Bernardino, Calif. brought new urgency Wednesday to the debate between privacy advocates and security hawks and could spark a renewed push for action by Congress.

Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., a strong privacy rights advocate, said he expects what he called “dangerous” efforts in Congress this spring to force U.S. tech companies to build backdoors into encrypted cellphones and other devices used by millions of Americans.

My view is that

  1. if the Feds have a warrant and
  2. the owner of the phone is dead and
  3. they have a way to decrypt the durned thing within a reasonable amount of time

then Apple should do it. I realize that “reasonable” is in the eye of the beholder but still. What, a week or so? Big companies can’t do anything in less than a week.

On the other hand, if they can’t do it, they can’t do it. The warrant and status of the former owner of the phone are irrelevant.

What do you think?

19 comments

Does a Bear Market Predict Recessions?

I think it was the economist Ezra Solomon who, some years ago, first said that the purpose of economic forecasting is to make astrology look good. In his most recent column at the Washington Post, Robert Samuelson compares the apparently diverging views of economists and stock traders on the state of the economy:

It’s economists vs. the stock market. Economists generally don’t forecast a recession anytime soon. The stock market does — or at least that’s one plausible interpretation of its recent roller-coaster behavior. Who’s right? We’ll know in a few months. Meanwhile, the dispute highlights the incomplete nature of the present recovery, which has lasted a long time but, to millions of Americans, still feels unsatisfactory.

Economists have long disparaged the stock market’s predictive powers. They like to quote the late Paul Samuelson (no relation to this writer), a Nobel Prize winner, who once said that the stock market had forecast nine of the last five recessions — a biting verdict on the market’s clairvoyance. It’s true that modest stock “corrections,” declines of 5 percent or 10 percent, haven’t foretold recessions. But that’s not true of bear markets, conventionally defined as declines of 20 percent or more.

Writing in Real Clear Markets, Brookings Institution economist George Perry notes that, by this standard, there have been seven bear markets in the past 50 years, and five of them have been associated with recessions. The recessions began in 1969, 1973, 1981, 2001 and 2007. Bear markets in 1966 and 1987 were not followed by recessions. Also, recessions in 1980 and 1990 were not predicted by bear markets.

He goes on to look at what the stock market’s been doing:

By the Standard & Poor’s index of 500 stocks, the market’s recent peak occurred May 21 at 2,130.82. At the market’s close Friday, the index had dropped to 1,864.78, a decline of about 12 percent. This suggests that, though the economy may slow (it already has), it won’t succumb to recession. That’s usually defined as two consecutive quarters of economic contraction. However, another index is closer to the historic danger zone. The Wilshire 5000 index covers more stocks. Since its peak on June 23, it has fallen by 15 percent, representing a paper loss of $4 trillion, says Wilshire.

I note that he doesn’t look at the DJIA:

I’m no market analyst but as I read that peak was at 18,448 and the close yesterday was 16,443 or a roughly 12% decline. Just as important is the trend and that’s down.

The one thing I’m missing from Mr. Samuelson’s analysis is that, although he does provide a little analysis of how well the bear markets have predicted recession, he doesn’t give us any clues as to how well economists have done. I’ll provide that. The record of the consensus of economists is practically unblemished in failing to predict recessions. In other words no matter how you stack it, bear markets have done a better job of predicting recessions than economists have.

This looks like a good place for me to reassert something I’ve claimed for decades. There’s a good reason for the failure. Economics isn’t a predictive science but a descriptive one like anthropology or psychology.

What does all of this mean for the U. S. economy? Beats the heck out of me. As I’ve said before I think the global economy will experience a pretty severe contraction and, while there will be a contraction here, it won’t be nearly as severe.

3 comments

The Vulnerable

In his most recent Wall Street Journal column, James Taranto tallied where the most vulnerable Republican senators who were running for re-election in 2016 had come down on the appointment of a replacement for the associate justice seat formerly held by Antonin Scalia:

Here is what McConnell said, in a statement Saturday: “The American people should have a voice in the selection of their next Supreme Court Justice. Therefore, this vacancy should not be filled until we have a new President.”

The Associated Press reports that Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin agrees. So does Sen. Kelly Ayotte of New Hampshire, in a Sunday statement, and the Times reports that Sens. Rob Portman of Ohio and Pat Toomey of Pennsylvania have signed on as well, “leaving nearly every vulnerable Republican incumbent backing Mr. McConnell’s pledge.”

as I’ve been doing. He didn’t mention that Illinois Sen. Mark Kirk had his mug on one side of the fence and his wump on the other, as I pointed out this morning.

Those are the most vulnerable. Make of it what you please.

IMO it reaffirms that November’s election will hinge on turnout and most of them are convinced that Sen. McConnell’s stance is the one that insure their position with the Republican base. If one or both parties run a dark horse candidate it will be a turnout election all right but one like we haven’t experienced in decades if ever.

3 comments

Illinois Mugwump

Illinois Sen. Mark Kirk, holder of the Senate seat generally characterized as the most likely to change hands among incumbent Republican senators standing for re-election in 2016, is trying to straddle the election year Supreme Court nomination issue. The Tribune reports:

The death of U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia has created a new and unsettling issue for Illinois Sen. Mark Kirk, perhaps the most vulnerable of Republican senators seeking re-election this year.

Kirk is offering no clue on whether he will side with leading Republicans, who have termed a final-year appointment by President Barack Obama a nonstarter, or with Obama and Democrats who say an appointment should be considered, regardless of the presidential election year.

Contacted by the Tribune, Kirk’s campaign pointed to a statement the senator issued Monday that avoided taking a stand on the question of Scalia’s successor and described the political maneuvering as “unseemly” at this time.

Kirk’s statement called Scalia a “giant in the history of American jurisprudence” and said the public should “take the time to honor his life before the inevitable debate erupts.”

All three of the Democrats competing to replace him are pressing hard for him to take a stand on the question one way or another.

“Sen. Mark Kirk must immediately level with the people of Illinois and let us know whether he supports the Constitution, or if he’ll be a rubber stamp for (Senate Republican leader) Mitch McConnell’s obstructionist and unconstitutional gambit,” Duckworth said.

Duckworth said taking the congressional oath of office “does not cease to apply in an election year, nor does it cease to exist for the benefit of a political party that lost the last presidential election and wishes to impose a procedural do-over.”

Sun-Times columnist Lynn Sweet seems to think that the controversy will somehow work to Kirk’s advantage:

WASHINGTON — I don’t see Sen. Mark Kirk, R-Ill., who is facing a tough re-election battle, sweating over the red-hot politics following the death of Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia.

Kirk won’t be moved to show his hand at least until after Scalia is buried. There are even ways he can use the battle over filling the Scalia vacancy to his advantage.

[…]

Now, what’s likely ahead for Kirk:

He implicitly took a shot at McConnell when he declined to close ranks with him when Kirk said in a statement: “The political debate erupting about prospective nominees to fill the vacancy is unseemly. Let us take the time to honor his life before the inevitable debate erupts.”

McConnell did Kirk — who has to run in Obama’s adopted home state, where he is popular — no favor by taking the extreme position that Obama should not appoint a nominee. That’s process over substance.

Looking ahead to November, when he will be wooing independent and swing Democratic voters, Kirk would be guilty of political malpractice if he said Obama should not at least send a name to the Senate.

On Tuesday, Obama reaffirmed at a press conference that he would nominate, “in due time, a very well-qualified candidate.” Obama said Republican senators will be “under a lot of pressure” as he asked them to “rise above day to day politics.”

Kirk’s primary opponent, Oswego software consultant Jim Marter, is running to Kirk’s right. Marter’s backers already have a long list of beefs with Kirk, so what he does on Scalia won’t change anything.

So in time, Kirk will likely say Obama is entitled to a nominee who deserves a hearing and a vote. Kirk’s past helps in forecasting his future on Scalia. When he was running for his first Senate term in 2010, Kirk said if he were in the Senate he would vote to confirm Elena Kagan to the Supreme Court. That would have made him a GOP outlier. Kagan was confirmed on a 63-27 vote, with only five Republicans voting yes.

I think that what’s going to work to Kirk’s advantage is that the bigwigs in the Illinois Democratic Party are backing a candidate without much name recognition against the more independent-minded Tammy Duckworth, a female Asian-American disabled veteran. For his part Sen. Kirk seems to be echoing Marshall Foch in his attitude towards his perspective Democratic opponents (“My centre is giving way, my right is retreating, situation excellent, I am attacking.”)

8 comments

Miscalculators

I was going to entitle this post “I wonder what he meant by that?” (attributed to Talleyrand on hearing of the death of the Turkish ambassador).

Mitch McConnell wasted no time after Justice Scalia’s death before planting his foot firmly in his mouth, as reported by Politico:

“The American people should have a voice in the selection of their next Supreme Court Justice. Therefore, this vacancy should not be filled until we have a new president,” McConnell said, at a time when other elected officials, from Sen. Bernie Sanders to future Senate Democratic Leader Charles Schumer, were releasing statements offering condolences to the justice’s family, which includes 26 grandchildren.

There’s more than one way to interpret that. He could be saying that the president shouldn’t nominate someone until after November. Or he could be saying, as it has been interpreted by practically everybody, that the Senate shouldn’t confirm any appointment until after November. Or both.

Whatever he actually meant it was an unforced error since it has handed the Democrats a campaign issue and, once again, cast Republicans in a bad light. But that’s only the first miscalculation.

Most of the Republican nomination-seekers are lining up behind Sen. McConnell’s gaffe. While that may be popular with the base, it certainly sounds terrible beyond the base. That’s the next miscalculations.

However, those who think that all of this miscalculating will give an edge to the Democrats may be miscalculating, too. Both of the president’s previous nominations have been solidly progressive judges with varying degrees of activism. If he seizes this opportunity and nominates another equally progressive justice, that could well be another miscalculation. Gallup’s most recent poll of American opinion on the Supreme Court finds more Americans seeing the Court as too liberal compared to too conservative by almost two to one and within the margin of error of “about right”. Nominating another progressive will all but certainly feed that impression.

What I would like to have happen is for everybody to take a deep breath, for the president to nominate a centrist to the Court (which will still tilt the Court in a more progressive direction), and for the Senate Judiciary Committeee to give the nominee an honest and considered hearing, recommending the nomination be approved if the candidate is worthy and granting the president’s choice a certain degree of deference.

Like that will happen in an election year.

18 comments

Things to Come

Recently, I was asked my opinion of the economy and I’ll repeat my answer here. I think that the odds are about 5:3 that we’ll see a global recession from which the United State is, fortunately, somewhat insulated. The way in which the global recession will have the greatest effect on us is that the U. S. is going to start looking very, very good to a lot of people willing to move for work.

All of this is the long-overdue consequence of trying to integrate China into the global economy. China is just too big and too authoritarian to integrate gracefully. China has extended credit to the hilt and invested all of that borrowing in factories. There is presently enough steelmaking, cement-making, auto production, etc. etc. capacity in China to satisfy the whole world’s prospective demand for decades. There’s no really good way to dig ourselves out of this hole.

5 comments

Ayotte Opposes Lame Duck SCOTUS Appointment

One of the senators I pointed to yesterday, New Hampshire Sen. Kelly Ayotte, has come out in opposition to any Obama appointment to replace Justice Antonin Scalia on the Supreme Court as reported by Politico:

New Hampshire Sen. Kelly Ayotte, a Republican from a state that supported President Obama, announced on Sunday evening that she opposes confirmation of a new Supreme Court nominee before the election.
The move comes as Ayotte has sought to build a pragmatic profile in New Hampshire against her opponent, Democratic Gov. Maggie Hassan. But Ayotte is choosing to back Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell’s blockade on picking a replacement for deceased Justice Antonin Scalia.

Offhand I’d say she is interpreting New Hampshire’s mood as expressed by the New Hampshire primaries last week as broadly anti-incumbent.

16 comments

Not Necessarily As Advertised

In all of the wailing, gnashing of teeth, foaming at the mouth, and rending of garments following the death of Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia and the subsequent drawing of political battle lines, it seems to me that an incorrect view of the Supreme Court is being promulgated and accepted unquestioningly—the essential ideological nature of the present Court.

In the 2015 (present) Supreme Court term of the 18 cases decided since October, 11 were decided unanimously or with only a single dissent (Sotomayor). In the 2014 Supreme Court term of the 74 cases decided, 36 were decided unanimously or with only a single dissent (1 Sotomayor, 2 Thomas, 1 Alito).

Many if not most of these unanimous or near unanimous cases went against the Obama Administration. The Obama Administration is outstanding among presidential administrations in the large number of Supreme Court cases it has lost 9-0.

In the 2014 term an additional 6 cases were decided with just two dissents: 2 with Alito and Thomas dissenting, 1 with Sotomayor and Kennedy dissenting, 1 with Thomas and Ginsburg dissenting, 1 with Scalia and Thomas dissenting, and 1 with Roberts and Scalia dissenting.

That doesn’t sound to me like a Court sharply divided along ideological lines but a Court with a significant amount of agreement. I would further submit that quite a few of the 5-4 cases were cases that should never have reached the Supreme Court to begin with but are failures of Congress.

1 comment