The Missionary Impulse in American Politics

Scott Burns’s recent post at RealClearWorld starts out propitiously enough with a condemnation of interventionist foreign policy that I can get behind:

Throughout the post-World War II era, the United States has embraced its self-assigned role to “make the world safe for democracy” in three main ways: through direct military intervention; through indirect interventions, such as by arming rebel groups to help overthrow hostile regimes; and through economic sanctions. The best of intentions may drive these interventions, but in most cases the outcome has been disaster.

but then he descends into madness. What is his alternative to interventionism? Mass immigration:

Surprisingly, part of the answer lies in loosening immigration quotas for refugees to come into relatively peaceful and developed countries such as the United States, which in the long term can have better results for us and for them.

The number of reasons that this is wrong-headed is so large it’s hard to know where to start. Let me just list a few:

  • Limited employment opportunities
  • Unacceptable risk
  • Superempowerment
  • Societies have carrying capacities
  • We’re not all missionaries

Limited employment opportunities

The United States is a different country than it was in 1850, 1900, or even 1950. The unemployment rate among Somali refugees is around 20% and for decades was around 50%. As it turns out there just aren’t that many opportunities for people without modern skills who don’t speak English.

Unacceptable risk

In all we’ve accepted about 200 Chechen refugees into the United States, a very small number. Of those about 10% were either perpetrators of the Boston Marathon bombings, directly involved with the Boston Marathon bombings, or indirectly involved with the Boston Marathon bombings. I’ll leave explaining why such a high percentage hate us so much to someone interested in the question. I think it’s clear that those refugees present an unacceptable risk. These are not the post-WWII or Ellis Island refugees or even Mexican economic migrants.

Superempowerment

Modern technology makes individuals much more capable of producing enormous carnage than was the case in the past. A 19th century anarchist could kill a couple of dozen people. A modern terrorist can kill or injure thousands. Times have changed.

Societies have carrying capacities

I believe that societies have carrying capacities in terms of the number of immigrants they can support without producing serious social upheaval and that for the United States that’s about 20%. We’re there now: we have the highest proportion of immigrants in our population as at any time in U. S. history—the same as at the turn of the 20th century. We need time to absorb the immigrants we have rather than to bring in a lot more.

We’re not all missionaries

The reality is that most Americans don’t have the impulse or feel the mandate to save the world, whether by going out as missionaries or by overthrowing tyrannical foreign governments. When a missionary goes to a foreign land, that’s his or her right. Bringing the poor and downtrodden here where it’s more convenient and comfortable to care for them is drafting all of us into their missionary efforts and that’s actively immoral.

If you want to save the world, go ahead and do it. Just don’t force me to help you.

14 comments

What’s Next for Republicans?

It’s hardly a state secret that the Republican Party is in the process of tearing itself apart. Things are being said that can’t be unsaid. Things are being done that can’t be undone.

There are four remaining Republican candidates for the presidency: Donald Trump, Ted Cruz, Marco Rubio, and John Kasich.

Ted Cruz is the tactical candidate. Sen. Cruz and his supporters, mostly white evangelical social conservatives, believe that Sen. Cruz can win the general election based on mobilizing turnout among his base. They have less than no interest in expanding that base, indeed his candidacy is based on not expanding that base. Mathematically, they’re probably correct. Practically, I think it’s a fantasy.

Sen. Cruz is presently moving to build an organization in Florida with the express objective of preventing Marco Rubio from taking his home state, thereby forcing him out of the race. That will leave Sen. Cruz as the sole unTrump.

Marco Rubio is the strategic candidate. He’s probably the single candidate who, if he gained the full-throated support of the various factions of his party, has the best chance of winning the general election. Right now he’s hanging on by his fingernails, hoping to win his home state, that John Kasich wins Ohio, and that the four remaining candidates divide the delegates among them, denying Donald Trump an outright victory and taking the decision to the convention.

Donald Trump is the Network candidate. Not network (although probably that, too) but Network. He’s the candidate for voters who are mad as hell and won’t take it any more. He’s not an ideological candidate and it’s hard to characterize him as pragmatic. He’ll say and do whatever it takes to keep getting free publicity and remain the center of attention. His negatives are so high that if he didn’t have the prospect of facing Hillary Clinton in the general election it would be hard to see how he could win. However, he’s probably right. He’s getting support from voters who haven’t been voting Republican in the past, if only for the same reason that people go to watch buildings burning down.

Can you imaging a Trump-Cruz, Trump-Rubio, Cruz-Rubio, or Rubio-Cruz unity ticket? Me, neither.

The strongest ticket for the general election is probably Rubio-Kasich but they’re despised as Republicans in Name Only (RINOs) by a substantial chunk of the party, the Spartan faction from which Ted Cruz derives most of his support (“Never retreat! Never surrender!”).

At this juncture the most likely outcome is that Donald Trump will win outright. The second most likely is a brokered convention.

I agree with those who think that we’re seeing the death of the Republican Party as we’ve known it but I think that many of those who believe that also think it means the end of the Republican Party. That belief is founded on an immature, ill-informed understanding of U. S. politics. The Republican Party will continue, it just won’t look much like the party of the last half century (which it hasn’t much resembled for some time). It is emphatically not the party of Ronald Reagan. If you doubt that, whatever became of Reagan’s Eleventh Commandment: “Thou shalt speak no ill of thy fellow Republican”? That’s been AWOL for some time.

But our political system is oriented towards two political parties, it’s institutionalized with two political parties in mind, and those two parties have advantages that third parties can’t match. The Republican Party will stay around for the foreseeable future.

Movement conservatism is clearly dead along with the generation of those who came of age in the 1940s and 1950s who fostered it. William F. Buckley’s rule of supporting the most conservative candidate with a chance of winning in the general election has given way to supporting the most conservative (whatever that means) candidate full stop. Too many Trump supporters won’t support Rubio or Cruz; too many Cruz supporters won’t support Trump or Rubio; too many Rubio supporters won’t support Cruz or Trump.

What will the emergent Republican Party look like? I have no idea and Donald Trump doesn’t provide much of a model for making that evaluation. It won’t be movement conservatism; it will be a populist-nativist party. Beyond that I have no idea.

Don’t dismiss it as being a regional party incapable of winning general elections. It could well win the next general election.

21 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Now It’s Time to Play…

Now it’s time to play “Interpret These Results”. How do you interpret the Labor Department’s latest jobs report? It’s reported here by the Wall Street Journal:

WASHINGTON—U.S. job growth rebounded in February, easing fears of a slowdown tied to market volatility and weakness abroad.

Employers added 242,000 jobs and the prior two months were revised up by 30,000, the Labor Department said Friday. Unemployment held steady at 4.9% while more Americans jumped into the labor force, pushing the participation rate to its highest level in a year.

The big downside: Americans’ wages declined 0.1% from the prior month, putting the annual gain at just 2.2%. The weak wage performance should leave the Federal Reserve on hold at its meeting this month, though improvement in other gauges will likely raise the prospect of further rate increases this year.

One interpretation, of course, is that the BLS’s numbers are meaningless. They’re so jiggered as to bear little resemblance to the real world.

I think the likely explanation is a little different. In any given month we’re both gaining and losing jobs. If the number of jobs gained is larger than the number lost, you get results like this month’s, with 242,000 jobs being added. If the number of jobs gained is smaller than the number lost, it goes the other way.

If the number of jobs gained was larger than the number lost but those lost paid more than those gained, you get results like those the Department of Labor reported.

1 comment

Let’s See the Evidence

This little tidbit in Noah Smith’s recent post at Bloomberg got my Irish up:

What can be done to make America great again? That’s the slogan of Trump’s campaign, but his mix of grandstanding, self-promotion, media provocation and unworkable policy plans is highly unlikely to have any sort of positive effect. Instead, more serious leaders need to think about more serious policies.

One of the simplest and most obvious steps would be more high-skilled immigration. Switching to a Canada-style points-based immigration system, increasing the total number of immigrants, and giving out green cards instead of H-1B visas would do a lot to boost the skills of the U.S. workforce.

I know of no evidence for that. I do know of lots of testimony from billionaires who are eager to bring in foreign workers so they can chaffer wages down. Testimony is not evidence. Over time that will decrease the skills of the U. S. population if anything.

That employers want to import workers is not necessarily evidence of a deficit in skills. Concentrate on the tech sector and show me the evidence.

5 comments

The Anti-Incumbent Election

I continue to believe that the November elections will hinge on turnout and that in the present mood of the electorate practically anything can happen. I stumbled across this account of a meeting of Rep. Luis Gutiérrez, who represents the Illinois 4th District (highly gerrymandered to concentrate Hispanic votes into a single district) at Hoy Chicago:

Justo en el momento que Gutiérrez llegó, se acercó un grupo de manifestantes que portaban carteles que decían: “Cállate chachalaca”, “Cárdenas HDO”, “Latinos United”, “El pueblo vendido será vencido”, entre otros, y se plantaron frente al lugar donde se realizaría el anuncio de apoyo a Mah.

My Spanish isn’t as good as it might be but I don’t think that the group of demonstrators is very happy with Rep. Gutiérrez. IIRC “chachalaca” is a slang expression for a blowhard.

This is the part that I found interesting:

Acto seguido, Gutiérrez se alejó mientras era seguido por el grupo que lo abucheaba, Gutiérrez dijo temer por su vida.

which I interpret as Rep. Gutiérrez saying that he was in fear for his life. Maybe he was exaggerating. The last time I recall a Chicago Congressional representative being afraid of injury at the hands of his constituents was Dan Rostenkowski.

0 comments

The Energy Delusion

This is the snippet of the Scientific American article on “energy apartheid” that caught my eye:

World Bank President Jim Kim warned that while countries with disposable income and billionaire investors are betting big on the technologies of the future, the rest of the world isn’t waiting, particularly the billions of people who are starved for electrons and Btus, counting on cheap fuels to help them claw out of poverty.

“Right now, people are making choices around their energy mix, and it’s crazy for us to have committed to [keeping global warming below] 1.5 degrees Celsius and not to be moving at lightning speed to try to create huge and demanding markets [for clean energy],” Kim said. “I still don’t think that market forces are aligned to get us to the less-than-2-degree [warming target].”

He called the divide in energy access between wealthy and poor nations “energy apartheid” and said many low- and middle-income countries need strong incentives and subsidies to push them in the right direction on climate change. Otherwise, these massive and growing energy appetites will undermine progress in curbing greenhouse gas emissions.

The “rest of the world” isn’t trying to power suburban homes. They’re trying to industrialize and the sad reality is that fossil fuels remain the only workable energy solution for industrial purposes and it will remain that way for the foreseeable future. In the developed world nuclear is another alternative but, considering that even Japan can’t keep its nuclear reactors maintained, do you really think that Zambia can?

Today solar and wind are being heavily subsidized. Without those subsidies they are not competitive with fossil fuels. Carbon taxes are not a good solution for the developing world.

We should be focusing our attention on amelioration. Prevention is out of reach.

19 comments

A Roadmap for Democratic Anti-Poverty Policy

Over at Brookings Democratic operative Harry J. Holzer urges Democrats to adopt a policy to reduce poverty and increase opportunity in the United States:

As an economist who studies poverty and opportunity, and also as a former Democratic political appointee,1 my pragmatic view is that three key constraints should be taken into account if we are truly serious about making things happen: We need policies that are (1) based on the best available evidence on which factors limit economic success among the poor and which policies are most cost-effective in mitigating those factors; (2) consistent with the values and history of the Democratic party, while adapting to current social and economic circumstances; and (3) consistent with the broad values of Americans, so that they can generate political support and, ultimately, some bipartisan appeal.

The factors that limit success among the poor are pretty clear. The most important are their low education levels and weak skills; the low pay for unskilled work in the US, the correspondingly reduced incentive for many to remain in the job market, and the difficulty in finding or keeping jobs; and various “group-specific” barriers, such as growing up in a very poor family or neighborhood, having a criminal record, being a non-custodial parent, or having a disability.

His proposals rest on three pillars:

  • Raise education and skills among poor children, youth, and adults.
  • Make work pay” for the unskilled, and make more jobs available to them when needed.
  • Address the specific problems of such groups as ex-offenders, non-custodial parents, children in very poor families or neighborhoods, and people with disabilities.

It makes interesting reading. I continue to be skeptical that education policy makes a good substitute for an economic policy. I don’t care how many journalism majors graduate; it won’t increase the number of jobs that are available that require majors in journalism.

1 comment

Which Way, Illinois?

The graph above was taken from a recent poll done by the Paul Simon Institute. The same poll found that Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner’s disapproval rate was outrunning his approval rating in every area of the state.

If anybody can figure out who that 9% is who think that Illinois is moving in the right direction, tell me so I can determine what hallucinogen they’re using.

0 comments

Spitting Contest

Former presidential candidate Mitt Romney tore into present Republican frontrunner in a speech at the University of Utah, as reported by the Washington Post:

“Donald Trump is a phony, a fraud,” Romney told nearly 700 people at the University of Utah. “His promises are as worthless as a degree from Trump University.”

This is the part that caught my attention:

“He’s playing members of the American public for suckers…”

Clearly this is a turf battle. Everybody knows that’s the job of elected officials.

Gov. Romney apparently hasn’t realized that’s part of the reason for Trump’s popularity. A good chunk of the American people have come to the realization they’re going to played for suckers in any event.

2 comments