I want to draw your attention to a good article at Vox.com by Max Fisher. The article chronicles the meteoric rise in influence of neoconservatives and their precipitous decline. In about twenty years they went from a fairly obscure clique of intellectuals to dominating Republican foreign policy thought back to the wilderness.
It’s amazing how unpopular you can become when your premises are demonstrably false.
For my money here’s the best quote in the piece:
In a mid-February debate, for example, Trump united the half-dozen other candidates against him by declaring that the Iraq invasion had been a disaster. A week later, he again said something that so outraged the other candidates that they once again all agreed Trump had gone beyond the pale: He declared that he would remain officially neutral on Israel-Palestine. Trump also drew objections for warning that regime change in Syria would risk exacerbating chaos there.
On the surface, these seem like banal and even mainstream positions, especially compared with Trump’s other statements. Official US policy on Israel-Palestine has been neutrality for decades. On Iraq, both foreign policy experts and voters largely consider the 2003 invasion a terrible mistake. Pentagon officials themselves often lament wasteful spending. And most Syria analysts agree that removing Assad by force would worsen the violence.
But Trump’s statements, reasonable though they might seem to many voters, appalled neoconservative-aligned writers and establishment candidates. And that may have been deliberate: Trump was directly challenging neoconservative orthodoxy, which states that the Iraq War was just and necessary, that intervention and regime change are desirable, and that the US must side unequivocally with Israel.
This put neoconservatives in the position of denouncing Trump for positions that are, in fact, quite mainstream. In those moments, as establishment candidates shouted down Trump for saying things that would be uncontroversial to most people, what you were seeing was the degree to which neoconservatives had estranged their party’s foreign policy from the actual preferences of its voters.
Based on the race and region model, we can predict that Hillary Clinton will win three states and Bernie Sanders will win two states on March 15. Clinton is predicted to receive between 65% and 67% of the vote in North Carolina, between 64% and 66% of the vote in Florida, between 52% and 54% of the vote in Illinois, between 46% and 48% of the vote in Ohio and between 45% and 47% percent of the vote in Missouri.
They’re using a simple model, based on just two variables: the percentage of black voters and a dummy variable for region. Their conclusion:
Leaving these important caveats aside, our results suggest that Bernie Sanders is likely to present a strong challenge to Hillary Clinton in the remaining Democratic primaries. Clinton has had a big advantage in the nomination race thus far because so many of the contests have been in the South. After next Tuesday, however, there will be no more primaries in the South. Based on the results presented here, she will be favored over Sanders only in non-southern states in which the nonwhite share of the Democratic primary electorate is at least 40 percent. The key question may be whether the huge delegate lead she has built up by winning southern primaries by landslide margins will be enough to sustain her through the rest of the primary season.
which points to potential Clinton weakness in the general election. Unless you think that Hillary Clinton is going to carry a lot of Southern states in the general election.
You know, I wish that people used the term “myth” more precisely. A myth is a story that illustrates some truth. The myth itself may be an actual event or it may be a confabulation. It doesn’t really make any difference; it’s the underlying truth that’s important.
Nowadays when most people use the word “myth” they seem to mean a false story but there’s also some confusion—they may just mean something about which they’re skeptical but which can’t be proven one way or another.
Women are unfairly paid less than men and an act of Congress could remedy that.
A return to the gold standard would eliminate inflation and put the economy on a sound footing.
We need to balance the U. S. budget.
A cut in personal income taxes would be a big help to middle income families.
We didn’t need to bail out the banks in 2008-2009.
Eliminating taxes on investment income will bolster middle income families.
It might be fun to match those “myths” with the candidates with whom they are most closely associated. Some of those are myths (in the sense of false stories), some are just things with which Ms. Dwyer disagrees, and some are genuine myths in the sense of stories that illustrate a greater truth.
One thing I’d add: Ms. Dwyer seems to confuse a gold standard with a ban on fractional reserve banking. They’re not the same thing. You can have a gold standard with fractional reserve banking. Or not. For about half of my life so far we had a silver standard with fractional reserve banking.
In a post at RealClearScience, Tom Hartsfield presents what strikes me as a novel and potentially extremely disruptive strategy for reforming higher education. Following the guidance of Alec Trebeck, I’ll put his proposal into the form of a question: why are colleges accredited rather than individual classes?
The philosophy is simple. The most important qualification for a job is qualification itself, not the calligraphed paper that represents it.
If a job requires some knowledge of biology, it often demands a degree in the subject. Why not, instead, ask for just the particular set of biological knowledge germane to the task?
One applicant to a job opening could present an entire preciously expensive degree showing their breadth of knowledge. Individual accreditation would allow a second applicant to instead present a smaller, leaner, more targeted package of professionally certified skills to compete with the first at a much lower cost.
A can think of a response to that. Courses of study, not just individual classes but whole courses of study, are designed by professional scholars and represent what an educated person is supposed to know about the subject matter.
Of course, colleges and universities largely abandoned that strategy nearly a half century ago which strengthens Dr. Hartsfield’s case considerably.
According to the Republican Party, the biggest threat to rural America was Islamic terrorism. According to the Democratic Party it was gun violence. In reality it was prescription drug abuse and neither party noticed until it was too late.
I don’t think any of those is the greatest threat. I think the greatest threat is despair.
Read the whole thing, an explication of why Donald Trump’s candidacy is resonating with some Americans.
Following up on my last post, I think the Hegelian dialectic is widely misunderstood. It is not a process of compromise. When the common truths of thesis and antithesis are reconciled into the synthesis it’s not a compromise. It is a new thesis, both like and unlike the original thesis and antithesis.
If there are common truths to be reconciled in the splintering Republican Party, it’s really not clear to me how that’s going to be accomplished.
In his latest Tribune column, John Kass says that the “Republican establishment” must rally behind the candidacy of Texas Sen. Ted Cruz:
If the establishment tries a convention power grab here’s what would happen: Angry Trump voters and angry Cruz conservatives would grab their pitchforks, staves and torches and walk out, but only after burning the GOP to the ground.
So if the GOP really wants to stop Trump, they have only one alternative: Cruz.
New polls show Trump whomping Rubio in Marco’s native Florida and leading Kasich in Ohio. Their only recourse is to make this a two-man race.
Either they help clear the field for Cruz or open their arms and embrace The Donald.
I actually think it’s too late for that. Do you really think that Trump voters will rally ’round if Cruz is the candidate? That Cruz voters will take to the polls in numbers to elect Donald Trump? That Jeb Bush or Marco Rubio supporters will joyfully support either of them?
The most famous Republican said it well. You can fool all the people some of the time, and some of the people all the time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time. The establishment had a long run of fooling their voters but it’s over. What if anything well emerge from the wreckage is anybody’s guess.
There’s an exchange in the movie The Big Chill that frequently comes back to me:
Michael: I don’t know anyone who could get through the day without two or three juicy rationalizations. They’re more important than sex. Sam Weber: Ah, come on. Nothing’s more important than sex. Michael: Oh yeah? Ever gone a week without a rationalization?
I won’t engage in a fisking of the article, lest I produce a post that challenges Mr. Goldberg’s piece in length. Suffice it to say that when you operate from the premise that you are always right, you have the bad habit of musing in public, and you are the president of the United States, the only way your premise can be maintained is by engaging in some world-class rationalization.
That no single U. S. act destabilized Libya, prolonged the Syrian revolution, or impelled the Saudis to attack Yemen does not mean that U. S. action had no effect on any of these things at all. The Grand Canyon was not caused by a single drip of water but we can hardly doubt that it was produced by the action of water over time. Just because something is not dispositive does not render it irrelevant.
Actions matter. Inaction matters. If you don’t want your actions or inaction to matter, don’t become president of the United States. Don’t rationalize your decisions to preserve the fantasy of your infallibility.
The president has surrounded himself with foreign policy interventionists. They were not foisted upon him willy-nilly. He chose them. We should be excused for suspecting that he has some sympathy with interventionism. The president may think of himself as a realist but that doesn’t make it so. Pursuing the interests of your country in ways that will accomplish those objectives and recognizing that other countries are trying to do the same thing is what makes you a foreign policy realist.
I don’t know if you’ve been paying attention to the progressively unravelling situation in Europe. In 2015 Europe took in more than a million migrants from the Middle East, Afghanistan, and North Africa. In 2016, bolstered by the welcome mat laid out by German Chancellor Angela Merkel, they’re on track to take in more than twice as many. Germany doesn’t want to accept that many so the Germans are trying to spread those migrants around among other EU countries and many of the other EU countries are balking. The EU diplomats have cut a deal with the Turks whereby the Turks take back most of the migrants, the Europeans accept the Syrians, and the Turks get money and the ability to travel anywhere in Europe without visas. They might get a reconsideration of their application for EU membership, too, although I think we know what the answer will be.
The most recent development is that a quartet of the European countries that are on the front line of this conflict are closing their borders to Middle Eastern migrants. From the New York Times:
LONDON — The route that more than one million migrants have used to traverse southeastern Europe was effectively shut down Wednesday, when four Balkan nations stopped waving the migrants through on their journey northward.
The four countries — Slovenia, Serbia, Croatia and Macedonia — have closed their borders to new migrants with the implicit backing of the European Union, which announced an agreement with Turkey on Tuesday to slow the flow of migrants.
The deal has not been completed — that is supposed to happen at a summit meeting next week. But within hours of the announcement from Brussels, Slovenia and Serbia announced new restrictions on the entry of migrants.
The whole thing is creating an exotic stew of encouraging mass migration, fostering insecurity in Europe, making the Greeks look good, and making the Eurocrats look like the twits that they are.
A recent research report by JPMorgan found that when markets see consecutive quarters of earnings declines, the economy slips into a recession 81 percent of the time. What do you make of this?
That was something I was complaining about in the depths of the Great Recession. A company sees a couple of quarters of declining earnings and management starts to take action. Puzzlingly, the action is never to cut the CEO’s salary or develop new products. It’s always to tighten the belt by laying people off. When you have enough companies doing that, the whole economy slides into recession.
BTW, you might want to to consider the graph at the top of the page long and hard. It tells a story and it’s not a particularly cheery one.