More On the Law of Heckling

At the Washington Post Eugene Volokh helpfully summarized some of the other legal considerations governing heckling. The short version is that an occasional “boo” is no more illegal than applause is but organizing people to disrupt a political rally or meeting is illegal.

My gripe on this issue has been the reaction of the Chicago Police and Rahm Emanuel. Contrary to the mayor’s assertion, Chicago did not stand up for freedom of speech but quite the opposite. It stood up for those who were abusing their freedom to suppress the free speech of others.

Supporting freedom of speech is most difficult when you dislike the speaker or believe that his or her ideas are wrong or pernicious. As has been said, these are the times that try men’s souls.

3 comments

Everything I Needed to Know About the Trump Campaign…

…I learned from watching The Walking Dead.

  • When the world they’ve been living in and depended on is disrupted, people may become angry, desperate, and fearful.
  • Desperate times call for desperate measures.
  • When they are fearful people will do things they wouldn’t have imagined doing otherwise.
  • Under those the conditions the strong may become authoritarian, violent, and tyrannical.
  • Under those conditions even nice people will do bad things.
  • Those who are adapting to the new environment successfully may appear cruel or even insane to those who aren’t.

I’m accepting contributions to this list. Leave your suggestions in the comments.

29 comments

Even Dozen

Today marks the 12th anniversary of The Glittering Eye. Over that period I have written more than 11,000 posts, an average of three per day, and readers have contributed more than 70,000 comments.

I have achieved nearly all of the objectives I had when I started the blog, most importantly a vibrant, mostly productive comments section and for that I want to thank the regular readers of this blog. You know who you are.

I suspect the one goal I have not realized will elude me.

The Glittering Eye continues to provide therapy for me. It keeps me engaged and interested. Believe me, without it my faculties would have become greatly dulled. Like the Red Queen, I must run twice as fast to stay in the same place.

So I plan to keep writing on an indefinite basis. My health is good and I still have my wits about me. I don’t work as hard on the blog as I used to. I used to read hundreds of blogs from all across the political spectrum and devoted to a huge number of suspects, searching for things to write about. That number is now down to about 20.

11,000 is a lot of posts but despite that number I still have lots of ideas. As I think I’ve mentioned before, I discard at least two ideas for every post I actually write. The only reason I don’t write more is that having returned to a full-time job places demands on my time and energy.

As usual I’ll take this opportunity to highlight a few of the posts of which I’m particularly proud:

My first real post
Anthems
Learning From History: the Relief and Rebuilding of New Orleans
The Influence of Immigrants on American Political Thought
My most-read post: How to Poach a Chicken Breast

9 comments

Forum Question: Today’s Primaries

The Council Forum question this week was about the members’ predictions of the results of the primary elections taking place today. You can read the Council members’ predictions here.

I think that by and large they’re reading Illinois wrong but we’ll see.

0 comments

The Heckler’s Veto Is Illegal

Just a little food for thought, provided by Noah Feldman at Bloomberg:

The melee at the Donald Trump rally Friday night in Chicago raises a fundamental First Amendment question: When a speaker, such as the Republican presidential candidate, is confronting angry protesters, whose speech rights come first: the speaker’s or the protesters’?

The U.S. Supreme Court’s answer to this question has evolved over the years. At one time, the court was ambivalent, sometimes favoring the speaker and sometimes willing to shut down the speaker to avoid public disorder.

Today, however, the norm is clear: Protesters who disrupt a rally can be removed by police so that they don’t exercise what’s called a heckler’s veto over the rally’s organizer. It shouldn’t matter whether it’s the Ku Klux Klan interrupting a civil-rights speaker or civil-rights protesters interrupting a racist diatribe. The law considers the speaker’s rights as paramount.

I hold no truck with Donald Trump. I will not vote for him under any circumstances whatever. He shouldn’t encourage violence in his supporters. But he has a right to speak and “protesters” don’t have a right to prevent him from speaking.

And our arse-hat in chief here in Chicago, Rahm Emanuel, is wrong on the law. He’s defending the wrong people.

17 comments

The Drone Fiction

Consider Conor Friedersdorf’s remark at Atlantic:

The notion that the Obama Administration has carried out drone strikes only when there is “near-certainty of no collateral damage” is easily disproved propaganda. America hasn’t killed a handful of innocents or a few dozen in the last 8 years. Credible, independent attempts to determine how many civilians the Obama administration has killed arrived at numbers in the hundreds or low thousands. And there is good reason to believe that they undercount the civilians killed.

Drone warfare isn’t the clean, sanitary, nearly foolproof strategy its advocates claim. The strikes frequently rely on intelligence provided by other countries and all too often we’re striking against enemies of the present regime rather than our own enemies. It contributes to our disrepute in the regions in which we’re using them. Drone operators suffer the same rate of PTSD as pilots flying combat missions.

1 comment

She’s Lousy But Vote For Her Anyway

Jeff Greenfield has a pretty fair post at Politico explaining how lousy a candidate Hillary Clinton is. For me the most telling quote is this:

A look at Clinton’s political career provides a tougher explanation. Those younger voters who doubt her trustworthiness likely have no memory, or even casual acquaintance with, a 25-year history that includes cattle-futures trading, law firm billing records, muddled sniper fire recollections and the countless other charges of widely varying credibility aimed at her. They may even have suspended judgment about whether her e-mail use was a matter of bad judgment or worse.
But when you look at the positions she has taken on some of the most significant public policy questions of her time, you cannot escape noticing one key pattern: She has always embraced the politically popular stand—indeed, she has gone out of her way to reinforce that stand—and she has shifted her ground in a way that perfectly correlates with the shifts in public opinion.

It’s probably before your time but on his First Family album Vaughn Meader had a great wisecrack: “Vote for the Kennedy of your choice but vote!” Now it’s vote for the Clinton of your choice.

I think that most Democrats aren’t particularly thrilled with Hillary Clinton but are gamely putting up with her on the grounds that she’s the most electable Democrat, a self-fulfilling prophecy if ever there was one. Don’t blame me if she’s the candidate and is defeated due to a lack of interest. It’s not as though I haven’t been warning you.

7 comments

Spending Inequality vs. Wealth Inequality

There are a couple of things I found interesting about the graph above which I sample from this post by Alan Auerbach and Laurence Kotlikoff at The Conversation. The first is that the article argues that inequality is being overstated. If that graph illustrates less overstated inequality, it’s still awful.

The second is that the bottom four quintiles are responsible for the majority of the spending and, if their numbers are correct, that’s true regardless of age cohort. It’s still a bit misleading since individuals within the same age cohort may move from income quintile to income quintile at different points in their lives. Lord knows, that was true of me.

I also have problems with this statement of the authors:

Another key finding is that U.S. fiscal policy acts as a serious disincentive to work longer hours or harder for more pay.

Our system’s plethora of taxes and benefits – designed with a multitude of income and asset tests and with little regard to how they work as a whole – have left many households facing high to super high net marginal tax rates. These rates measure what a household gets to spend (in present value) over its remaining lifetime in exchange for earning more money now.

For example, a typical 40-49 year-old in any of the bottom three quintiles (poor to middle class) of our resource distribution will only get to spend about 60 cents of every dollar he or she earns. For the richest 1 percent in that age group, it’s just 32 cents.

My reaction was “so what?”. Maybe I don’t understand what they’re saying but I don’t think that’s relevant to either income or wealth inequality for one simple reason. Most people who aren’t already in the top quintile of income earners don’t have the option of working longer or harder for more pay, either because they’re already full up or there are no additional jobs for them to do. I know many, many more people who are already working multiple full-time minimum wage jobs trying to keep body and soul together than I do people who could work a few more hours and get more pay.

I’m skeptical that tax cuts will ameliorate either variety of income inequality. Basic optimization theory is that you optimize where there’s something to optimize. That’s at the lower end of the income spectrum rather than the top end.

For those who think that we can remedy income inequality by increasing taxes, I still want to know how. Somehow the proponents never get around to explaining how they plan to increase effective tax rates. You can raise nominal rates to the moon and it won’t do a darned thing unless you can boost the effective rates while you’re doing it.

7 comments

Multiple Choice on North Korea

There’s more saber-rattling from North Korea and its tone is becoming increasingly dire. From The Daily Mail:

North Korea has warned it could ‘burn Manhattan down to ashes’ by firing a hydrogen bomb in to the heart of New York City.

Kim Jong UN’s regime said it was capable of sending the weapon to America’s East Coast using one of its ‘intercontinental ballistic missiles’.

Pyongyang’s state-run media outlet claimed the country’s hydrogen bomb was ‘much bigger than the one developed by the Soviet Union’.

Other reports have somewhat different accounts, including much more direct threats, i.e. if we don’t end military exercises, they’ll nuke New York.

What should we do in response to these threats?

  1. Nothing. They don’t have the capability to do what they’re threatening.
  2. Nothing. They’re blustering.
  3. Ask the Chinese to curb their dog otherwise we will.
  4. Be on standby. If anything hinky starts happening, nuke them.
  5. Nuke them. Now.
  6. Other

I think C but threatening nuclear attack is not to be taken lightly and Kim is a nutcase.

3 comments

The Illinois Primary

Tomorrow are the Illinois primary elections and, for the first time in a long time, what happens in Illinois could actually matter. I have been deluged with robocalls, mostly for local races, TV is filled with political advertising, and about a third of the lawns in my neighborhood are decorated, if that’s the right word for it, with signs hawking one candidate or another.

In my neighborhood I’ve seen a few Sanders signs. I haven’t seen a single Clinton sign, poster, or billboard. Maybe the Clinton campaign doesn’t care about us. Maybe it thinks this overwhelmingly Democratic neighborhood is not favorable to it. Maybe they don’t think these old-fashioned strategies for campaigning and drumming up interest are effective any more. Maybe they don’t know what the heck they’re doing.

I don’t honestly know what’s going to happen in the primary elections in Chicago, in Illinois. I just have no feel for them. What I hope and what I expect are two different things.

On the presidential side, I hope that the Republican vote goes to Kasich and the Democratic vote to Sanders. Although poll after poll leading up to the primary have shown Hillary Clinton with a comfortable lead in Illinois the most recent CBS poll has shown that Bernie Sanders has a two point lead, presumably within the margin of error.

As in other states I think that polls have lost their effectiveness in Illinois. They oversample land lines, they oversample certain demographics, poll-weary and poll-savvy people don’t tell the truth to pollsters, any number of reasons.

On the downticket races I hope that a lot of incumbents go down in flames.

What I expect is moderate turnout for a primary and victories on the part of the usual suspects. Maybe I’ll be surprised.

13 comments