No Man Is An Island

Just a quick reminder. Nobody and nothing can stand up to scrutiny once you’re going the “guilt by association” route. Everything is related to everything else.

And you need a lot more than imputed motive. Something much more direct.

2 comments

The Taxonomy of Climate Change

I’m a sucker for taxonomies. I find them handy ways of organizing my thoughts. When I was a kid I remember poring for hours over the huge trees illustrating the relationships among species of animals or the Indo-European languages. Some of my earliest posts were attempts to identify a taxonomy of blogospheric positions on the war in Iraq.

For similar reasons I found this classification of positions on climate change from physics prof Richard Muller at Huffington Post interesting. The positions he identifies are:

  • Alarmists
  • Exaggerators
  • Warmists
  • Lukewarmists
  • Skeptics
  • Deniers

For a more detailed explanation read the linked post.

I don’t know that I’ve seen a better example of how revealing naming something can be about how you think about it. For some reason those classifications give me the impression that anyone other than a “warmist” or “lukewarmist” would object to the classification under which they found themselves.

My own view as is so often the case doesn’t fit handily into the classifications. Maybe a “warmist” or “lukewarmist” but with a difference: I’m much more interested in the policy prescriptions. Far too often I find the prescriptions of the “alarmists” are only tangentially related to the problem they’re trying to solve. I keep remembering (I still don’t remember who said it) that when Party A wants to take money from Party B to help Party C, smell a rat.

I think that when you start trying to nail down an effective policy that could be politically possible you end up with a hybrid energy future that includes fossil fuels and nuclear as well as “alternative” sources coupled with engineering approaches to reduce the carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. Otherwise you always run afoul of the economic equivalent of Augustine’s wisecrack: “O Lord, grant me chastity and continence but not yet.”

11 comments

A Pig in a Poke

The Wall Street Jourrnal reports that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia has made a startling announcement:

Saudi Arabia plans to list up to 5% of its state-owned oil company on stock exchanges in Riyadh and possibly the U.S., setting up an IPO that could pose big rewards for bankers and even bigger risks for investors.

Deputy Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman outlined the plan Monday. He said Saudi Arabian Oil Co., better known as Aramco, was worth between $2 trillion and $3 trillion. That means a 5% listing could in theory raise $100 billion to $150 billion for the kingdom as it works to defray the impact of the steep drop in oil prices.

As I see it there are a number of possible reasons for the development and they aren’t mutually exclusive:

  1. The KSA doesn’t have nearly as much oil as they’ve been leading us to believe.
  2. The KSA has seen a sudden uptick in its expenses or expects an uptick.
  3. They believe that their access to the international banking system may change and they want to get more money faster than they could be selling oil.

just to name a few. I don’t find any of those explanations particularly heartening.

7 comments

The Best Thing I’ve Read

The best economic policy advice I’ve read in some time is from this piece by Carolyn Zelikow at Market Urbanism critiquing the “Creative Class” notion popularized by Richard Florida:

There are economic growth strategies that work for low- and middle-skill workers. And there are many American cities that are doing just fine without a preponderance of Creative Class representation: Houston, Atlanta, Oklahoma City all come to mind. Florida never even addresses these places. James Fallows writes about a trio of counties in Mississippi that banded together to successfully train their workforce to attract high-end manufacturing plants. Joel Kotkin writes about growth corridors in the Midwest and South. This is the kind of unsexy economic development that our brightest minds really need to be focusing on – not solely creating better amenities for the young whites who populate coworking spaces and bike shares, much though I love them. These are luxury goods, and the affluent can access them without public assistance.

I think the “Creative Class” foolishness is what’s motivating Rahm Emanuel’s policies here in Chicago and it’s fatally flawed. More than half of the people will always fall below that standard. The upper limit on the percentage of people who would benefit from higher education has always been below 50%.

We’ve had three consecutive administrations in Washington that have used a higher education policy as their national economic policy. It’s high time we started following policies that focused on the majority of the people rather than the few.

1 comment

The Retort

At Slate Jamelle Bouie responds to Emmett Rensin’s post to which I linked last week:

This is blinkered. And the result is an essay that doesn’t criticize “liberalism” so much as it positions Rensin against other members of his cultural cohort. It’s what you might write if you’ve mistaken the consumption habits and shibboleths of your tribe for a politics that drives one of two major political parties in a democracy of over 300 million people, if you’re convinced of your own centrality to the currents in American history.

It’s a thought-provoking post but I have reservations about it. Among the reservations are that I think that Mr. Bouie is too quick to dismiss the vanguardism to which I referred in my post and he conflates “liberals” with the Democratic Party. Those aren’t scare quotes—it’s the term he uses. Today’s progressives are not liberals and they constitute less than half of the Democratic Party.

1 comment

Okay, I’ll Bite

GeographyofTerrorDAESH

The graph above, sampled from Leonid Bershidsky’s post at Bloomberg titled “To Defeat Islamic State, Treat Muslims Better”, caught my eye. For an interactive (and more informative) version go to the linked post.

Here’s a snippet of the accompanying text:

Thomas Piketty, probably the most fashionable economist since the 2008 financial crisis, has linked the phenomenon to the high income inequality in Middle Eastern nations, which he argued the West had helped foster by letting oil sheiks get rich and share little of their wealth.

Okay, I’ll bite. How might we have accomplished that?

First, I wonder who he means by “we”? Mostly “we” didn’t do anything other than buy oil from the legitimate, internationally recognized governments of Middle Eastern countries. And most of the “we” in that case were European countries.

We (meaning Americans) bought significantly more oil from Canada and Mexico than we did from any countries in the Middle East. Maybe it’s escaped my recollection but I don’t recall terrorist groups starting in Albert or the state of Campeche.

Should we have invaded the countries and overthrown their governments to ensure a better distribution of oil wealth? That would have gone over well.

I also should point out that “recruits per million population” is a meaningless statistic.

However, this makes sense:

Benmelech and Klor suggested a different explanation for recruitment success: It’s positively correlated with homogeneity in a society. The less ethnically diverse a society is, the more likely outsiders such as immigrants or second- or third generation Muslims are likely to turn to terror. The economists wrote of the Western European nations that supply a relatively high number of fighters:

“The more homogenous the host country is the greater difficulty immigrants such as Muslims from the Middle East experience in assimilating. As other research has shown, isolation induces some of them to become radicalized.”

and it’s what I’ve been saying for some time about Europe’s ethnic states.

But I’m not particularly comfortable with blaming the host countries, either. Have Muslims been treated so horribly in Sweden? Or are they merely a minority?

That’s the one thing which eludes a minority. They’re not a majority. When you’re accustomed to being in the majority and suddenly find yourselves very much in the minority, feeling out of place wouldn’t be particularly surprising. There’s a simple solution for that: go home.

The graph at the bottom of the page in the linked post is much better and tells a somewhat different story. However, it does raise an interesting question. Why does Finland produce so many terrorists compared to France?

Let me offer a very different explanation than the author does. It’s an artifact of Finland being such a small country and the recentness of its Muslim population. And the language. I’d be willing to bet that not one in a thousand of its Muslim immigrants speaks Finnish when they arrive. It’s a fairly tough language, more different from Arabic than English or French is, and practically useless outside of Finland.

3 comments

Changing Diapers Is a Survival Skill

When you’re the oldest kid in the family and you’re eight years old when younger siblings are still in diapers, you will be drafted into diaper-changing detail. At least you will when your youngest siblings are twins.

And that was in the cloth diaper and safety pin days. It served me well she I was a teenager. I was the only boy I knew with the skills to babysit for infants and their older brothers. I could feed and change the babies, give the older kids judo lessons, and prepare their dinners. No home microwaves in those day, either.

Cooking, martial arts, changing diapers. All survival skills right up there with swimming, ironing, and sewing on a button. Everyone should be able to do them.

5 comments

Do Not

One of the things that may not be apparent to readers who haven’t maintained a blog of their own is that there’s a certain amount of overhead associated with it. Every day I spend at least a little time doing housekeeping.

By far the least agreeable housekeeping is moderating comments. Many are quite obnoxious. I have one operating principle: do not feed the trolls.

Something else that may not be apparent: you’ve got to grow a tougher skin.

12 comments

John Fromm Is Alive and Well

It takes Melissa Boteach quite a while to get around to her prescriptions for reducing poverty in her post at RealClearPolicy. Here they are:

Instead, we should build off of the momentum in states and localities that are alleviating poverty and investing in families, which, not coincidentally, can also significantly reduce the chronic stress associated with a wide variety of illness affecting life expectancy. As noted by the Washington Post in its coverage of the Chetty study, “Among the 100 largest commuting zones ranked by the researchers, six of the top eight for low-income life expectancies are in California” — a state that has pursued many policies that mitigate the stresses associated with poverty, such as paid parental leave, a higher minimum wage, and investments in early care and education.

A serious agenda to cut poverty and promote economic opportunity would include these policies and more, investing in job creation, expanding access to high-quality childcare, and increasing opportunities for post-secondary education and training. It would help families manage work and caregiving through paid family leave and fair, flexible, and predictable work schedules; it would protect and strengthen the safety net, which is currently reducing poverty by nearly half. Finally, it would invest in high-poverty neighborhoods, as well as remove barriers to opportunity for Americans with criminal records.

or, in other words, she’s promoting the same cargo cult, post hoc propter hoc reasoning that is all too common nowadays. More jobs that truly require post-secondary degrees will do more to reduce poverty than throwing money down the rat hole of subsidizing higher education.

Most of the rest of her prescriptions are just different ways of saying that the compensation paid for jobs should be higher. I agree. It would be in a tighter labor market.

3 comments

President Asterisk

At Huffington Post H. A. Goodman argues that there will be an asterisk next to Hillary Clinton’s name until the FBI investigation of her private email server has been completed one way or the other:

At the end of the day, Americans everywhere will realize that the rule of law applies to Hillary Clinton, and that honesty and integrity will propel Bernie Sanders to the presidency. The FBI’s reputation is at stake, both globally and at home, and I explain why in this YouTube segment. James Comey and the agents who’ve devoted endless hours to Clinton’s email investigation will soon disclose their findings to the American people; to think nothing will result from this year-long probe is naive. Remember, the FBI doesn’t give parking tickets.

There will indeed be political repercussions for Clinton, especially if the FBI recommends indictment, and Democrats will need Bernie Sanders. The DNC will need Bernie Sanders. The country will need Bernie Sanders.

We haven’t veered that far away from our former value system as nation, when possible criminal conduct meant the end of presidential campaigns, for the DNC to continue to back Hillary Clinton, even after the FBI recommends indictments.

Think I’m nuts?

Basically, I think that horse has already gotten out of the barn. What will be will be.

I wish the FBI had seen fit to accelerate its investigation so that whatever happens happened before we were so deeply into primary season but, alas, that was not to be. If you think the legitimacy complaints that followed the 2000 election were bad, you ain’t seen nothin’ yet. It was a simpler, gentler time.

6 comments