Education For the Other 80%

Here’s an example of what I’ve been talking about. From Today:

When he decided against going to a traditional high school, Warner Adams got teased. But now he’s getting the last laugh.

“People always make fun of vocational schools, but now they’re like, ‘Oh man, I wish I went there,’” said Adams, now a junior at Pathfinder Regional Vocational Technical High School, where every recent graduate found a job upon graduating.

In Massachusetts, where the school is located, the average starting salary in manufacturing is about $45,000. “I can make as much money as someone going to college, coming straight out of high school, and I don’t have to pay for college loans or anything like that,” Adams said.

Read the whole thing. It’s too bad we don’t have leaders with the guts to say that for most people colleges aren’t job training programs and, unless you’re part of that relatively small percentage who will go on to become docs, dentists, lawyers working for big law firms, or financiers, the primary beneficiaries of the push towards higher education are college deans or bankers. As things look now we’re going to pursue the same inadequate policy we’ve been following for the last 20 years.

Hat tip: Instapundit

18 comments

English Is a Funny Language

Has it ever occurred to you that pixellated isn’t the same as pixilated? Or that hippie isn’t the same as hippy? Well, at least it didn’t used to be.

3 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Whatever Became of Tyrannosaurus Rex?

In terms of market capitalization Apple, Google, and Microsoft are the largest companies in the world. As I read this article about the bump in the road that Apple has hit:

Apple’s second-quarter earnings are out, and finally, it’s happened – Apple’s 13-year growth streak has come to an end.

Here’s exactly how it happened.

First, since everyone’s talking about it, let’s look at the iPhone.

Apple shipped 51.1 million units, which isn’t as bad as was expected (the figure to beat was 50.7 million units). That’s a unit drop of 32 percent since the previous quarter, and 16 percent down year-on-year. Notice though how it’s a sharper decline between first and second quarter unit sales than Apple has previously seen.

along with this one from Bloomberg on Carl Icahn’s decision to sell all of his Apple stock:

Icahn held 45.8 million shares in Apple by the end of 2015, about 0.83 percent of the total shares outstanding, worth $4.8 billion at the time. It was the second-biggest holding in his portfolio after Icahn Enterprises LP, his diversified conglomerate. Now, according to Icahn himself, he’s out of the stock he has repeatedly called undervalued.

In October, 2014, when Apple shares traded at about $100, he wrote the company’s chief executive Tim Cook that his analysis showed it should trade at $203. In May, 2015, with the market price at $130, he said a share should be worth $240. These prices, of course, have never materialized: At the end of the first quarter of 2016, when Icahn liquidated the position, the stock traded at less than $110. It has dropped to $95 since, so Icahn has made a sizable profit.

Icahn would have held on to his Apple stake, had he still believed in his previous valuations. The reason he doesn’t anymore, he says, is that he’s worried about the company’s exposure to China because of the unpredictable nature of the Chinese political system…

I had a thought. Will Apple, Google, and Microsoft exist in more or less their present forms in 10 years? In 20?

I think the answer to the second question at the very least is “no” and the reason is something I’ve been predicting for some time. We’re going to see large companies created, skyrocket, and fizzle out at an increasing pace. More, I think we’re going to see whole new industries and business models rise and fall at an increasingly dizzying rate.

There are multiple reasons for that and I’ll just name a few. First, that’s the nature of tech companies. They’re built on the brains and creativity of a few individuals. When those individuals leave or die or just get tired, the businesses just aren’t the same.

The people who built the companies colored outside the lines. Their successors don’t.

There’s a generational difference.

They have lots of leaves but shallow roots.

That’s the reason that Google, for example, is in the frenzy of acquisition it’s been in. It can see the handwriting on the wall—the search business isn’t what it used to be. They’re looking for another direction in which to jump. Right now the CEO seems to think that’s AI. Maybe and maybe not.

7 comments

The Indigo Economy

There is a thought-provoking and, I think, highly optimistic post at RealClearPolitics from Mikhail Fridman, “As Global Instability Spreads, the ‘Indigo’ Economy Rises” which I would like to commend to your attention. Here’s a snippet from it to give you the flavor:

We are entering a disruptive era driven by extraordinary levels of human creativity. A new generation of curious, strong-willed and talented individuals is unhindered by convention or the past. This new “Indigo” generation is now shaping tomorrow’s economy and creating national wealth. I use the term Indigo because it has been used to refer to children with special or unusual abilities. This is an era where abnormally talented individuals and entities are now able to realize new levels of human potential and economic achievement.

and here’s what I think is the meat of the post:

The main source of national wealth is not the resource rent but the social infrastructure that allows every person to realize his or her intellectual and creative potential. It is for this reason that Exxon, once the world’s largest company, has been overtaken by Apple and Google. This represents a paradigm shift in which creative, non-linear thinking and random ideas are turned into new scalable services in a short space of time.

Yesterday in comments we had a substantial discussion about infrastructure. Too often the role of roads and bridges in America’s vital infrastructure have been over-emphasized. Other important areas of infrastructure like sewers or the power grid don’t encompass the totality of our infrastructure.

I might argue that our most important infrastructure includes institutions like a sound currency and banking system and the rule of law. Let’s not ignore those in a slapdash run to put additional lanes on a highway or build the 153rd bridge across the Mississippi. They’re among our most valuable infrastructure and their lack is retarding the growth of many of the world’s countries.

10 comments

The American Experience in 2016

This post was prompted by a suggestion in comments from a regular commenter that I look at this post at Five Thirty Eight by Jed Jolko which points out that the United States is no longer a country of white people living in small towns or the country:

Earlier this week, Jim VandeHei, a former executive editor of Politico, wrote an op-ed article for The Wall Street Journal accusing the Washington political establishment of being out of touch with “normal America.”

“Normal America is right that Establishment America has grown fat, lazy, conventional and deserving of radical disruption,” he wrote, citing his regular visits to Oshkosh, Wisconsin, and Lincoln, Maine, as his credentials of normality.

It’s a familiar accusation in a year in which most presidential candidates are trying to pretend they have nothing to do with the coastal elite, and after one — Ted Cruz — spent weeks attacking “New York values.” Even PBS, a standard-bearer of the media elite, recently featured a quiz designed to assess in-touchness with “mainstream American culture” with questions about fishing, pickup trucks and living in a small town.

But that sense that the normal America is out there somewhere in a hamlet where they can’t pronounce “Acela” is misplaced. In fact, it’s not in a small town at all.

Read the whole thing.

I don’t believe that his methodology is useful or helpful for a simple reason: the variations in demographics and residence in the United States are not distributed uniformly throughout the country.

It’s true that the United States is no longer as white as it used to be and that more people live in metropolitan areas. Just about 50% of Americans live in the largest 48 metropolitan areas. That also means that about 50% of Americans don’t live in the largest 48 metropolitan areas.

However, when you begin to dive into the details the picture that emerges is much more complex. Let’s look at the statistics. According to the Census Bureau about an eighth of Americans are black, a sixth are Hispanic, and three-quarters are white.

If that’s what America looks like, a lot of the cities in those 48 don’t look like America. The metropolitan areas of San Francisco, Phoenix, Riverside, Seattle, Minneapolis, Denver, Portland, San Antonio, Pittsburgh, Sacramento, San Jose, and Salt Lake City have been 3% (Portland) and 8% (Pittsburgh) black population. Other major metropolitan areas have black populations considerably larger than the national level. Hispanic population is similar. Most of the major metropolitan areas have considerably fewer than the national percentage while the others have many more.

Just as the United States doesn’t look like small town early 20th century America it doesn’t look like Brooklyn (or Chicago), either.

I would tell a very different story about the United States today. I think that from an experiential standpoint what the country “looks like” depends on who you are. I think that most whites in the United States experience life as about 85% white, 5% black, 10% Hispanic, and the rest Asian, Pacific Islander, etc. while blacks experience life as about 50% black, 45% white, and 5% everything else. Both groups estimate the numbers of the racial and ethnic demographic groups incorrectly, typically overestimating the proportions of blacks and Hispanics.

I also think that most Americans either live in small towns or suburbs which are effectively small towns but that’s a subject for another post.

The graphic above illustrates the white percentage by state. If you mouseover a state, it will show you the percentage.

30 comments

Beat the Clock

How many of Time’s most important people of the 20th century can you name in 15 minutes?

I got 40 and was strongest in “Leaders and Revolutionaries” and “Artists and Entertainers” which I guess reflects my interests. Some of those on their list are pretty bogus IMO.

12 comments

Trending the Wrong Way

ACAApproval201604

According to this article from Pew Research it certainly looks as though public opinion on the ACA is trending the wrong way:

The public’s views of the Affordable Care Act, which were evenly divided following the Supreme Court’s ruling last summer upholding a key section of the law, are again more negative than positive. Currently, 44% approve of the 2010 health care law, compared with 54% who disapprove of the law.

The fate of the ACA will, obviously enough, be decided by future administrations. If a Democrat, presumably Hillary Clinton, lives in the White House after January 2017, the legislation will continue to be called “Obamacare” and will continue to live on in one form or another. It will still need a major overhaul. Viability of the program can’t be maintained based on wishful thinking alone.

If the next administration is a Republican administration they might repeal the plan but whatever they replace it with will retain a number of the ACA’s features, e.g. community rating, automatic issue, coverage for pre-existing conditions, etc. I guess that’s a form of immortality.

11 comments

Free Flight of Fancy

Ron Fournier’s free flight of fancy on a Hillary Clinton presidency (“the right way”) at Atlantic is getting a lot press so I may as well remark on it. At Atlantic Mr. Fournier posted a set of recommendations to Hillary Clinton in the form of an open letter to her. Rather than doing a full-fledged fisking of it I’ll just concentrate on two of his bullet points: infrastructure and executive authority.

Infrastructure

Mr. Fournier’s statement:

This is another issue upon which most Americans agree: The nation’s roads, bridges, airports, and other concrete components of a modern nation are crumbling. You could launch an infrastructure “moon shot,” creating millions of jobs and positioning the nation for another century of dominance.

Just as was the case with the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (the “stimulus package”) there is no earthly way any foreseeable infrastructure spending plan whether presented by Sec. Clinton or anybody else will produce the results he foresees.

Roads, bridges, etc. are built by vendors from an approved vendor list. Present day governance rules require it. They’ve already bought their equipment and already hired their workers. Such a program would actually do relatively little in the way of creating jobs.

If you want to actually accomplish anything with a program of federal spending (a “moonshot” project) it’s got to be in an area in which megavendors aren’t already mobilized to suck up any money that’s put on the table. That won’t be aerospace, defense, healthcare, education, or any thing else I can think of. I don’t know what that might be.

Besides our actual problem is that we don’t maintain what we build. The lion’s share is always spent on new construction. Unless you can envision the Paul Ryan Pothole Filling or the Harry Reid Highway Resurfacing, that’s going to remain the case.

What will actually happen would be that a lot of money would be appropriated which would disappear into the coffers of the already wealthy and some of it would make its way into the campaign funds of incumbent politicians. It wouldn’t do much to improve “crumbling” infrastructure.

IMO that’s something that should be done by state and local governments anyway. Why should the taxpayers of Illinois be paying for causeways in Alaska or a bridge in Maryland? I just don’t see it.

Executive Authority

Mr. Fournier’s statement:

You should use the singular power of clemency to bring justice to minorities given draconian drug sentences. So far, Obama has shown relatively little mercy. On the other hand, you should cede to Congress powers that both Obama and President George W. Bush abused for war-making, domestic spying, and immigration.

If there is one thing on which Democratic and Republican presidents agree, it is the desirability of expanding presidential power. Besides “war-making, domestic spying, and immigration”, horrifyingly, have become valence issues.

A valence issue is one on which the parties agree. Motherhood and apple pie issues. Different candidates vie with each other over how ardently they support the issue. A strong defense is a valence issue.

If there’s one thing we’ve learned from the Democratic presidential primary debates it is that de facto open borders has become a valence issue among Democrats. Sanders and Clinton only argued over how little they would enforce our immigration laws.

My recommendation to Mr. Fournier is that he should dream no small dreams. Rather than the tepid, paltry, inside baseball suggestion he’s proposing he should imagine that Sec. Clinton reconstruct herself as some sort of unlikely amalgam of Eleanor Roosevelt, Mother Theresa, and Joan of Arc. It would make for more interesting reading and would be no less fantastical than what he’s actually written.

If Hillary Clinton is elected president, for good or ill she will remain who and what she is. She won’t suddenly sprout wings and fly. Take it or leave it.

16 comments

What’s Wrong?

What’s wrong with this sentence:

A recent study about the complexity of the women’s dense breast notifications (DBN) determined that some letters are too complex for the average person to understand, considering that about 20 percent of the population reads below a 5th-grade level.

I think the article actually has a good point to make but they should try phrasing their opening sentence differently.

7 comments