Ron Fournier’s free flight of fancy on a Hillary Clinton presidency (“the right way”) at Atlantic is getting a lot press so I may as well remark on it. At Atlantic Mr. Fournier posted a set of recommendations to Hillary Clinton in the form of an open letter to her. Rather than doing a full-fledged fisking of it I’ll just concentrate on two of his bullet points: infrastructure and executive authority.
Infrastructure
Mr. Fournier’s statement:
This is another issue upon which most Americans agree: The nation’s roads, bridges, airports, and other concrete components of a modern nation are crumbling. You could launch an infrastructure “moon shot,†creating millions of jobs and positioning the nation for another century of dominance.
Just as was the case with the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (the “stimulus package”) there is no earthly way any foreseeable infrastructure spending plan whether presented by Sec. Clinton or anybody else will produce the results he foresees.
Roads, bridges, etc. are built by vendors from an approved vendor list. Present day governance rules require it. They’ve already bought their equipment and already hired their workers. Such a program would actually do relatively little in the way of creating jobs.
If you want to actually accomplish anything with a program of federal spending (a “moonshot” project) it’s got to be in an area in which megavendors aren’t already mobilized to suck up any money that’s put on the table. That won’t be aerospace, defense, healthcare, education, or any thing else I can think of. I don’t know what that might be.
Besides our actual problem is that we don’t maintain what we build. The lion’s share is always spent on new construction. Unless you can envision the Paul Ryan Pothole Filling or the Harry Reid Highway Resurfacing, that’s going to remain the case.
What will actually happen would be that a lot of money would be appropriated which would disappear into the coffers of the already wealthy and some of it would make its way into the campaign funds of incumbent politicians. It wouldn’t do much to improve “crumbling” infrastructure.
IMO that’s something that should be done by state and local governments anyway. Why should the taxpayers of Illinois be paying for causeways in Alaska or a bridge in Maryland? I just don’t see it.
Executive Authority
Mr. Fournier’s statement:
You should use the singular power of clemency to bring justice to minorities given draconian drug sentences. So far, Obama has shown relatively little mercy. On the other hand, you should cede to Congress powers that both Obama and President George W. Bush abused for war-making, domestic spying, and immigration.
If there is one thing on which Democratic and Republican presidents agree, it is the desirability of expanding presidential power. Besides “war-making, domestic spying, and immigration”, horrifyingly, have become valence issues.
A valence issue is one on which the parties agree. Motherhood and apple pie issues. Different candidates vie with each other over how ardently they support the issue. A strong defense is a valence issue.
If there’s one thing we’ve learned from the Democratic presidential primary debates it is that de facto open borders has become a valence issue among Democrats. Sanders and Clinton only argued over how little they would enforce our immigration laws.
My recommendation to Mr. Fournier is that he should dream no small dreams. Rather than the tepid, paltry, inside baseball suggestion he’s proposing he should imagine that Sec. Clinton reconstruct herself as some sort of unlikely amalgam of Eleanor Roosevelt, Mother Theresa, and Joan of Arc. It would make for more interesting reading and would be no less fantastical than what he’s actually written.
If Hillary Clinton is elected president, for good or ill she will remain who and what she is. She won’t suddenly sprout wings and fly. Take it or leave it.