How Do Countries Become Rich?

Although I found econ prof Deirdre N. McCloskey’s Wall Street Journal article about the sources of American, British, etc. wealth thought-provoking and a good point of departure for reflecting not only on what was done in the past but what we might want to be doing in the future:

Nothing like the Great Enrichment of the past two centuries had ever happened before. Doublings of income—mere 100% betterments in the human condition—had happened often, during the glory of Greece and the grandeur of Rome, in Song China and Mughal India. But people soon fell back to the miserable routine of Afghanistan’s income nowadays, $3 or worse. A revolutionary betterment of 10,000%, taking into account everything from canned goods to antidepressants, was out of the question. Until it happened.

What caused it? The usual explanations follow ideology. On the left, from Marx onward, the key is said to be exploitation. Capitalists after 1800 seized surplus value from their workers and invested it in dark, satanic mills. On the right, from the blessed Adam Smith onward, the trick was thought to be savings. The wild Highlanders could become as rich as the Dutch—“the highest degree of opulence,” as Smith put it in 1776—if they would merely save enough to accumulate capital (and stop stealing cattle from one another).

Although I think there’s an element of truth in her preferred explanation, personal freedom:

If capital accumulation or the rule of law had been sufficient, the Great Enrichment would have happened in Mesopotamia in 2000 B.C., or Rome in A.D. 100 or Baghdad in 800. Until 1500, and in many ways until 1700, China was the most technologically advanced country. Hundreds of years before the West, the Chinese invented locks on canals to float up and down hills, and the canals themselves were much longer than any in Europe. China’s free-trade area and its rule of law were vastly more extensive than in Europe’s quarrelsome fragments, divided by tariffs and tyrannies. Yet it was not in China but in northwestern Europe that the Industrial Revolution and then the more consequential Great Enrichment first happened.

Why did ideas so suddenly start having sex, there and then? Why did it all start at first in Holland about 1600 and then England about 1700 and then the North American colonies and England’s impoverished neighbor, Scotland, and then Belgium and northern France and the Rhineland?

The answer, in a word, is “liberty.” Liberated people, it turns out, are ingenious. Slaves, serfs, subordinated women, people frozen in a hierarchy of lords or bureaucrats are not. By certain accidents of European politics, having nothing to do with deep European virtue, more and more Europeans were liberated.

I don’t think she’s got it quite right. Why did the United States and the countries of Western Europe become rich while China, India, etc. did not?

Let me begin my interpretation of events by explaining what borrowing and investment are. Borrowing is shifting future consumption into the present. Investment is postponing present consumption until some time in the future.

Armed with that let’s start listing the critical success factors for a country’s becoming rich. First, you need to be able to produce a surplus. That’s something that nomads, bands of hunter-gatherers, and subsistence farmers can’t do.

Second, you must be able to invest—to defer consumption. If your surplus is taxed away or if you consume everything you produce (or consume more than you produce by borrowing), you won’t become rich. Once modernization allowed the Japanese to grow beyond subsistence farming, Japan became rich in part because of distinctively Japanese cultural traits which encouraged Japanese people to invest rather than consuming what they produced.

Third, you must have not just one or two but a whole complex of institutions that support the accumulation of national wealth. Those include the rule of law, a sound currency, a government that maintains a fairly stable set of rules, and a general agreement that you should play by the rules.

I’m skeptical of Dr. McCloskey’s favored explanation for a number of reasons, the most important being that “liberty” is pretty hard to define and few countries including England have the absolutist sort of notions of freedom that have prevailed in the United States and to some extent still do. Germany is a rich country, too, and Anglo-American notions of liberty have never prevailed there.

And, most importantly, you do not have to resort to liberty as an explanation. Compound interest will do.

9 comments

It’s Not Anger—It’s Frustration

The key point of Amy Walter’s recent piece at The Cook Political Report is quotidian enough. Americans are less angry than they are frustrated:

Americans are angry, say the cable TV pundits and armchair political observers. They are angry at a dysfunctional Washington, D.C. Angry at the out-of-touch political class. Angry at an out-of-control bureaucracy. The only problem with this argument is that, well, Americans aren’t actually any angrier at government today than they were a year ago, or even four years ago. In fact, according to data from the Pew Research Center, the percent of Americans who say they are “angry at the federal government” has remained rather consistent over the last six years, ranging from a high of 32 percent in October 2013, to a low of 13 percent in March 2011. Today, 22 percent of Americans say they are “angry.” Even when asked their feelings about the broader category of “politics” just 21 percent say they are angry.

So, why the obsession with anger? Well, like just about everything else we talk about this year, it has an association with Donald J. Trump. Among Trump supporters, Pew found in March, 50 percent said they were angry with the federal government. Forty percent said they were angry with politics. Meanwhile, just 30 percent of Cruz and 18 percent of Kasich backers described themselves as angry with government. Even those who support Sanders, who is often described as the angry candidate on the left, are not any angrier about “politics today” than Clinton supporters are – 18 percent to 14 percent.

Americans are – and quite frankly have been for a while – frustrated. According to the same Pew data, 57 percent of Americans consider themselves “frustrated” with the federal government. But, this 57 percent isn’t that out of the ordinary either. In fact, since 1997, a majority of Americans – between 51 percent and 62 percent – have described themselves as frustrated.

There are, however, some pearls of wisdom that I think are worth passing along. For example:

A recent study for the National Urban League found that African-Americans are doing “much better than they did when its first ‘State of Black America’ report came out 40 years ago.” While overall, African-Americans are still doing less well on issues like poverty and high school graduation rates than whites, they are doing better on these measures than they were back in 1976.

As someone who was alive back in those olden days, I don’t see how anyone with eyes can deny that black folks are better off than they were forty years ago. Fewer young black men are being murdered today than then. Far fewer are being shot by police. Why the palpable anger, well beyond frustration, of the BlackLivesMatter folks? I think it’s because it works.

Or this:

Where Americans do find common ground, however, is that few think life for the next generation will be better. Just a quarter of all voters, 18 percent of Republicans and 29 percent of Democrats think life for the next generation will be better. It is whites, however, who are the most pessimistic, with 54 percent saying they see things getting worse for the next generation – 10 points higher than African Americans and 17 points higher than Hispanics. This is an electorate that is not satisfied with the status quo AND worried that it won’t get better anytime soon.

You’d think that level of dissatisfaction would lead more people to the conclusion that we’ve got to start doing things differently than we have for the last several decades. I guess the level of frustration hasn’t risen high enough yet.

7 comments

The Fourth Great Awakening

Recently, I was reminded of Tom Wolfe’s great essay, published in the New Yorker nearly 40 years ago, “The ‘Me’ Decade and the Third Great Awakening”. It was in that essay that he coined the phrase “the ‘Me’ decade” to describe the 1970s.

See if any of this sounds familiar.

The two most popular new figures in the 1976 campaign, Jimmy Carter and Jerry Brown, are men who rose up from state politics . . . absolutely aglow with mystical religious streaks. Carter turned out to be an evangelical Baptist who had recently been “born again” and “saved,” who had “accepted Jesus Christ as my personal Savior”—i.e., he was of the Missionary lectern-pounding amen ten-finger C-major-chord Sister-Martha-at-the-Yamaha-keyboard loblolly piny-woods Baptist faith in which the members of the congregation stand up and “give witness” and “share it. Brother” and “share it, Sister” and “Praise God!” during the service.* Jerry Brown turned out to be the Zen Jesuit, a former Jesuit seminarian who went about like a hair-shirt Catholic monk, but one who happened to believe also in the Gautama Buddha, and who got off koans in an offhand but confident manner, even on political issues, as to how it is not the right answer that matters but the right question, and so forth.

Newspaper columnists and newsmagazine writers continually referred to the two men’s “enigmatic appeal.” Which is to say, they couldn’t explain it. Nevertheless, they tried.

Why are our pundits always so puzzled?

Well, my God, the old utopian socialists of the nineteenth century—such as Saint-Simon, Owen, Fourier, and Marx—lived for the day of the liberated workingman. They foresaw a day when industrialism (Saint-Simon coined the word) would give the common man the things he needed in order to realize his potential as a human being: surplus (discretionary) income, political freedom, free time (leisure), and freedom from grinding drudgery. Some of them, notably Owen and Fourier, thought all this might come to pass first in the United States. So they set up communes here: Owen’s New Harmony commune in Indiana and 34 Fourier-style “phalanx” settlements—socialist communes, because the new freedom was supposed to be possible only under socialism. The old boys never dreamed that the new freedom would come to pass instead as the result of a Go-Getter Bourgeois business boom such as began in the United States in the 1940s. Nor would they have liked it if they had seen it. For one thing, the homo novus, the new man, the liberated man, the first common man in the history of the world with the much-dreamed-of combination of money, free time, and personal freedom—this American workingman didn’t look right.

They look like ordinary suburban folks. Or hipsters.

The old alchemical dream was changing base metals into gold. The new alchemical dream is: changing one’s personality—remaking, remodeling, elevating, and polishing one’s very self . . . and observing, studying, and doting on it. (Me!)

new new alchemical dream is transmuting the entire world so that other people treat you as though you were what you have imagined yourself to be.

Journalists (historians have not yet tackled the subject) have shown a morbid tendency to regard the various movements in this wave as “fascist.” The hippie movement was often attacked as “fascist” in the late 1960s. Over the past several years a barrage of articles has attacked Scientology, the est movement, and “the Moonies” (followers of the Reverend Sun Myung Moon) along the same lines.

Frankly, this tells us nothing except that journalists bring the same conventional Grim Slide concepts to every subject.

Mostly what it tells you is how myopic pundits are.

Tocqueville’s idea of modern man lost “in the solitude of his own heart” has been brought forward into our time in such terminology as alienation (Marx), anomie (Durkheim), the mass man (Ortega y Gasset), and the lonely crowd (Riesman).

Now we have “bowling alone”.

14 comments

Going, Going…

According to WGN, Chicago may not remain the third-largest city in the United States for long:

CHICAGO — The population in Chicago is dropping, and if it continues, we could lose our status as the third biggest city in the United States.

Last year, the city lost close to 3,000 residents while Houston saw population increases. It is currently the fourth largest city.

If the trends continue, Houston could pass Chicago in about 10 years.

And then there’s this:

Residents leaving Chicago and Illinois blame high taxes, the budget stalemate, crime, unemployment and the weather, according to a Tribune survey.

Chicago doesn’t have mountains, an ocean, a benign climate, or redwoods. It’s a place to work. Sandburg called it the “city of broad shoulders”. Those weren’t from playing tennis.

2 comments

Domestic Politics As Foreign Policy

There’s a pair of posts at Foreign Policy which together make a pretty fair case for the ways in which the Obama Administration’s strategy for waging the War on Terror has not only fallen short but how catastrophic it has been. In the first Micah Zenko reminds us of the heavy commitment of contractors in our overseas conflicts:

Obama has authorized the continuation or re-emergence of two of the most contractor-dependent wars (or “overseas contingency operations” in Pentagon-speak) in U.S. history. As noted previously, there are roughly three contractors (28,626) for every U.S. troops (9,800) in Afghanistan, far above the contractor per uniformed military personnel average of America’s previous wars. In Iraq today, 7,773 contractors support U.S. government operations — and 4,087 U.S. troops. These numbers do not include contractors supporting CIA or other intelligence community activities, either abroad or in the United States.

There is practically no way to know how many contractors have taken part in our foreign adventures or how great their casualties have been but at least 1,500 U. S. contractors have been killed since President Obama took office.

Who cares? At least there aren’t any U. S. boots on the ground.

In the second piece Jack Watling and Namir Shabibi describe the havoc that a combination of bad incentives and the drone war have wrought on Yemen:

Washington and London had sought to increase training and assistance to the bitter end, but without political reform, it had been rendered entirely useless. Today, al Qaeda is in direct control of a large swathe of southern Yemen and is no longer entirely dependent on its tribal allies.

The futility of the Western training program is reflected in the bitter recollection of some British personnel who took part. One lamented the fact that “most of the guys we were mentoring are dead now. There are two who I know are working for Yemeni headquarters in Saudi, but the rest of them are dead.”

“What happened in Yemen,” explained another British official, “was just a lot of money spent, a lot of time wasted, and nothing whatsoever was achieved.”

I’ll repeat my claim. This is what happens when the only yardstick used to measure the effectiveness of foreign policy is its effect on domestic politics. Of course domestic politics will play a role in any decision. But effective decision-making is impossible when domestic political considerations are the only factor that is considered.

3 comments

Apologize For What?

There’s been quite a bit of speculation about what President Obama will say when he visits Hiroshima next week. Some say they think that the president should apologize. This report from ABC News should provide a taste:

A group representing Japanese survivors of U.S. atomic bombings urged President Barack Obama to hear their stories and apologize when he visits Hiroshima next week.

Two leaders of the Tokyo-based nationwide group told a news conference Thursday that many survivors still want an apology, though they have long avoided an outright demand for one out of fear that it would be counterproductive.

Toshiki Fujimori, a survivor of the Hiroshima atomic bombing, said he found it awkward to hear local and central government officials say they are not asking for an apology.

“I suspect there was a pressure (not to seek an apology) to create an atmosphere that would make it easier for Obama to visit Hiroshima,” Fujimori said, declining to identify where the pressure was coming from. “But many of the survivors don’t think they can do without an apology at all.”

Apologize for what? For saving the lives of millions of Japanese? That’s how many would have been killed in the invasion for which the Japanese were preparing. Not to mention the tens or even hundreds of thousands of Americans who would have been killed.

For many years I thought that our use of atomic weapons on Hiroshima and Nagasaki had been a ghastly mistake. Then I applied what I knew of the Japanese culture of the time and realized that we had, literally, no other way to communicate to the Japanese that the war was over and they had lost. Only the emperor could have told the Japanese people that and the only way of communicating that reality to the emperor was through demonstrations so graphic and awful they could not be denied.

James Gibney, writing at Bloomberg, arrives at the same conclusion:

After reading this book, though, I found it hard to argue with what Yamashita told me: “Had the bombs not been dropped, and had the Allies invaded as they were planning to, it would have been horrible beyond belief.” The numbers support him: As many as 150,000 civilians may have perished in the battle for Okinawa alone, for instance. Never mind the Allied servicemen who might have died — including perhaps my father, a battlefield interrogator in U.S. naval intelligence who went on to join a cadre of postwar Japanologists. Spare a thought for the Japanese boys and girls training to throw themselves under advancing U.S. tanks with bombs strapped to their chests.

I would hope that whatever the president says on his visit, he fixes his gaze upon the future rather than dwelling on the past. Reflexion and mourning are fine. But no apologies.

Update

Here’s Harry Truman’s statement after the atomic bomb was dropped on Nagasaki:

The British, Chinese, and United States Governments have given the Japanese people adequate warning of what is in store for them. We have laid down the general terms on which they can surrender. Our warning went unheeded; our terms were rejected. Since then the Japanese have seen what our atomic bomb can do. They can foresee what it will do in the future.

The world will note that the first atomic bomb was dropped on Hiroshima, a military base. That was because we wished in this first attack to avoid, insofar as possible, the killing of civilians. But that attack is only a warning of things to come. If Japan does not surrender, bombs will have to be dropped on her war industries and, unfortunately, thousands of civilian lives will be lost. I urge Japanese civilians to leave industrial cities immediately, and save themselves from destruction.

I realize the tragic significance of the atomic bomb.

Its production and its use were not lightly undertaken by this Government. But we knew that our enemies were on the search for it. We know now how close they were to finding it. And we knew the disaster which would come to this Nation, and to all peace-loving nations, to all civilization, if they had found it first.

That is why we felt compelled to undertake the long and uncertain and costly labor of discovery and production.

We won the race of discovery against the Germans.

Having found the bomb we have used it. We have used it against those who attacked us without warning at Pearl Harbor, against those who have starved and beaten and executed American prisoners of war, against those who have abandoned all pretense of obeying international laws of warfare. We have used it in order to shorten the agony of war, in order to save the lives of thousands and thousands of young Americans.

We shall continue to use it until we completely destroy Japan’s power to make war. Only a Japanese surrender will stop us.

Let’s have no more talk of apologies.

16 comments

Uneasy Lies the Head

As I read this post at Bloomberg by John Mickelthwait to the effect that Germans are tired of trying to cope with Europe’s problems:

Look, for instance, at Europe’s two main enduring crises. On Sunday the Greek parliament is supposed to approve another package of structural reforms, prior to a meeting of euro-zone finance ministers in Brussels on May 24. Greece needs another dollop of aid to meet its July interest payments, but the International Monetary Fund has been (rightly) worried that the country’s debt burden is too big and it will miss its target of a 3.5 percent primary surplus in 2018. A Merkellian fudge has been readied: In return for the new reform package, Germany and the IMF will accept some of Greece’s more heroic forecasts and stretch out debt repayments.

Default has thus probably been skillfully averted again. But nobody in Berlin believes Greece will ever be able to pay off its debts. “It is really an emerging economy, not a developed one,” says one senior German, adding wryly that the Greeks should be dealing with the World Bank, not the IMF.

Worse, from Germany’s perspective, the lack of progress in Greece is symptomatic of the whole continent’s uncompetitive economy. Six years into the euro crisis, France has barely started structural reform (German ministers roll their eyes whenever you mention “Francois Hollande” and “reform” in the same sentence), and Italy is still trying to fix its banking system. The single market is worryingly incomplete. Very few of the structural underpinnings of a successful single currency are in place.

This contempt comes with a hefty dose of hypocrisy and self-delusion. Merkel has done few structural reforms herself; the hard work was done by her predecessor, Gerhard Schröder. Content in their prosperous economic bubble, German voters have condemned the rest of Europe to needless austerity, resisted liberalization (notably in the country’s lackluster service industries), and refused to stomach common Eurobonds and other long-term solutions to preserving the single currency. So the Germans are not the thrifty saints they imagine themselves to be. But, as they endlessly point out, they are the ones who write the checks every time there is a bailout — and they don’t feel as if they get a lot in return.

Germans have more justification for their resentment when it comes to Europe’s other main crisis: the flood of Syrian refugees. On the plus side, Merkel has found a way to stem the flow of people that threatened to overrun her country (and her chancellorship). Turkey has agreed to hold refugees within its borders in exchange for 6 billion euros in aid from the EU, while Italy and Greece are also getting help in exchange for not letting refugees who land on their coasts surge northward.

it occurred to me that the problems that are being complained about are largely of Germany’s own making. Unless you can make a case that Syria’s problems are a direct consequence of the U. S. invasion of Iraq, something I think is a stretch. Greece wouldn’t be in the straits in which they find themselves if it weren’t on the euro and the primary advocates for expanding the eurozone are, you guessed it, the Germans. And Syrian refugees are begging, borrowing, and stealing the means to get to Germany because some mischievous, unnamed individual invited them. Who could that possibly have been? Oh, yes. Angela Merkel—German chancellor.

What country abetted the collapse of Yugoslavia? Germany. Wanted the Baltic states to join NATO? Germany. Urged the admission of Ukraine into NATO? Germany.

Here’s my suggestion. If the Germans are tired of dealing with the consequences of their own policies, why don’t they try changing policies? They’ve been largely getting their way for the last 60 years. Some people are never satisfied.

1 comment

Don’t Export!

I can’t excerpt this post by former Fed governor Narayana Kocherlakota at Bloomberg enough to explain my point without quoting the whole thing.

Isn’t Dr. Kocherlakota saying that the U. S.’s increasing exports would be a bad strategy? I seem to recall a number of articles from just a day or so ago pointing to a U. S. cheese glut that resulted from the stronger dollar.

1 comment

As Fast As This

“Regulatory capture” refers to a form of government failure in which a regulatory agency reflects the interests of the institutions it was intended to regulate rather than those of the public. How long does it take for a regulatory agency to be captured? As fast as this, reports the Daily Caller:

Three of the top four officials at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau have jumped from CFPB to lucrative posts representing financial services industry firms their former agency regulates, according to a Daily Caller News Foundation investigation.

The latest of the departures is Quyen Truong, formerly deputy general counsel, who accepted a position this month with the law firm Stroock & Stroock & Lavan.

Truong’s new law firm represents banks such as Citigroup, Bank of America Merill Lynch, Barclays Capital, Credit Suisse and Deutsch Bank. The company also assists high-flying hedge funds including Carlyle Group, JP Morgan Asset Management and Goldman Sachs, according to its website.

Truong was preceded out the door by her former boss at CFPB, General Counsel Meredith Fuchs, who left in February to join Capital One.

The CFPB was formed in 2010 as part of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street reform bill.

A more cynical man than I might be tempted to think that rather than protecting the interests of consumers the CFPB was created to be yet another venue for placing party apparatchiks in lucrative financial sector jobs.

4 comments

Who’s for a Bucket of Warm Spit?

The Council Forum question this week is about who the running mates for the Democratic and Republican Parties’ eventual presidential nominees will be? For my fellow Council members’ answers see here.

Here’s what my answer was:

I think that Hillary Clinton will select Julián Castro. She’s a serial bungler so it’s a miscalculation.

On the Republican side I have no idea whom Trump will pick. Gingrich is pretty clearly running for the job but I don’t see how he fits in with Trump’s outsider persona. I don’t think he can pick any regular Republican who will enhance the ticket and put more states in reach.

I’d speculate it will be someone from out of left field. Someone with strong name recognition but not a politician. Think Kanye West or someone of the sort.

I think that with respect to who Trump will pick my fellow Council members are still thinking too much inside the box.

Regarding the title of my post, I have it on good authority that’s not what John Nance Garner said about the vice presidency but this is a family blog.

16 comments