Critical Success Factors

Put the following factors in decreasing order of significance in major terrorist attacks in the U. S. over the period of the last 25 years.

  1. The easy availability of semi-automatic weapons and high capacity magazines.
  2. The availability of automobiles.
  3. Telecommunications, e.g. cell phones, Internet access.
  4. Second generation immigrants, i.e. children of immigrants.
  5. Radical Islam.

A fundamental principle of optimization is that the best target for optimization is where there’s the most to optimize, in other words tackle the most significant factors first.

15 comments

Why the Mismatch?


source: tradingeconomics.com

I think there’s something missing from Caroline Baum’s analysis at MarketWatch of the apparent inconsistency between the low labor force participation rate and the increasing number of jobs on offer:

Businesses do not bid up the price of labor (wages) only to find their profits squeezed, forcing them to raise prices. That is just not how it works. Labor is the largest input cost, especially for service-providing industries, so firms carefully weigh the cost of adding the marginal worker versus the marginal revenue he will produce.

A more compelling argument to explain the large number of reported job openings going unfilled is that demand isn’t strong enough to support economy-wide price increases. Without price increases, higher wages are off the table. All those “help wanted” signs in store windows should probably read “help wanted at a price.”

Let me try to fill in the blanks. Large businesses have a confidence based on experience that, if they kvetch long and loud enough, they’ll get the H-1B visas they want to bring in foreign workers at wages below what would otherwise be the market clearing price of labor. That’s what the discrepancy really tells you. The wages that are being offered are below the market clearing price of labor.

If profits are low enough for long enough, one of two things will happen. Either businesses will close their doors or they’ll get used to lower returns on investment. That’s what I think has happened. For decades businesses have been receiving what would previously have been considered an unusually high rate of return and they’ve gotten used to it. Note how low capital investment has been for so long.

The graph at the top of the page illustrates business investment as a percentage of GDP. A longer series going back to, say, 1980 would make the case even more dramatically. In other words the decrease is not just because of the Great Recession. It’s been going on for some time.

8 comments

Spoiling for a Fight (Updated)

The New York Times and other major news outlets are reporting that a cadre of mostly mid-level State Department officials have circulated an internal memo calling for military action against the Assad government in Syria:

WASHINGTON — More than 50 State Department diplomats have signed an internal memo sharply critical of the Obama administration’s policy in Syria, urging the United States to carry out military strikes against the government of President Bashar al-Assad to stop its persistent violations of a cease-fire in the country’s five-year-old civil war.

The memo, a draft of which was provided to The New York Times by a State Department official, says American policy has been “overwhelmed” by the unrelenting violence in Syria. It calls for “a judicious use of stand-off and air weapons, which would undergird and drive a more focused and hard-nosed U.S.-led diplomatic process.”

I haven’t been able to locate the actual text of the memo but none of the reports I’ve read include any mention of what these foreign service officers think will happen after Assad has been removed. We actually have a good model for that: Libya, where radical Islamists have mostly taken over after the removal of Moammar Qaddafi that we connived at.

As I see it there are at least two problems with their preferred course of action:

  1. With Russia’s active presence in Syria in support of and at the invitation of the internationally recognized government of Syria it sets the stage for major power confrontation, a confrontation from which Russia cannot back down.
  2. It would result in turning Syria over to DAESH. The rump Alawite government would fight it out to the death in the Alawite strongholds in northern Syria because they have no other choice.

What is the vital U. S. interest in putting DAESH in control in Syria and fomenting a nuclear war? I don’t see it. Want a diplomatic solution? Negotiate it with the Russians. If we strike the Assad government in the absence of United Nations Security Council authorization (which won’t be forthcoming because of Russia’s veto at the very least), we will be in the wrong. We will be the bad guys.

To my mind what this memo reveals is how deeply entrenched neoconservatives and liberal interventionists are at the State Department. It sounds to me like a good housecleaning is in order.

Update

Larry Johnson tells the simple truth—the U. S. and Europe are responsible for the carnage in Syria, not the Assad regime:

The United States, along with Britain, Turkey and Saudi Arabia, set the match to Syria. It was covert funding for opposition groups, which included providing weapons and other material support to carry out military strikes against the Syrian Government.

while my old friend, Mary Ellen O’Connell, quoted at Atlantic, lends a touch of sanity:

In a statement, Mary Ellen O’Connell, professor of international law at the University of Notre Dame, said the letter is, in essence, “calling for a grave breach of international law.” She said the U.S. military intervention in Libya had been an “unmitigated disaster,” and “[a]ttacking Syria will have no better results.”

“Diplomacy is the way to end the Syrian civil war,” she said. “State Department officials need to get on that job—not pass the buck again to the military.”

and, as I noted above, the path to diplomacy leads through the Kremlin.

5 comments

Will the Last Person to Leave Illinois Turn Off the Lights?

Over at City Journal Steve Malanga points out some uncomfortable truths about domestic migration:

What is it about blue states that makes people so eager to leave them? That’s a question worth pondering after seeing the results of Gallup’s latest State of the State poll, which, for the first time in eight years, found that more states lean Republican than Democratic. Only 14 states, the survey determined, are either solidly Democratic or trending that way, while in 20 states, the majority of residents are either solidly Republican or leaning right. Gallup deemed the rest toss-ups, with no clear advantage for either party.

The poll revealed other trends. Blue-state residents were far more likely to report that they wished to relocate. Seven of the eight states that residents are keenest to flee are solidly blue—led by Connecticut, where 46 percent of people want to follow the state’s leading employer, GE, to the exits. Also near the top of the list: New Jersey, Illinois, Rhode Island, Maryland, Delaware, and New York. The only state in the Top Eight not predominantly Democratic is Ohio, which Gallup considers “competitive” (neither Republican nor Democratic). Rounding out the Top Ten are Republican-leaning Indiana and Nevada.

What could possibly be inducing people to leave one state for another?

Though demographers offer many reasons for why people move, Gallup focuses on just one: taxes. “Even after controlling for various demographic characteristics including age, gender, race and ethnicity, and education, there is still a strong relationship between total state tax burden and desire to leave one’s current state of residence,” noted Gallup. The polling organization divided the states into five broad categories—or quintiles—of taxation, ranking them from lowest to highest. Six of the ten states where residents were most eager to leave are among the country’s highest-taxed, including New York and New Jersey. A seventh, Illinois, ranks in the second-highest quintile. By contrast, eight states that residents were least interested in leaving were ranked in either the lowest or second-lowest tax quintile. The Gallup survey’s most pointed message for blue states might come from Oregon, one of only two Democratic-leaning jurisdictions that rank with America’s lowest-taxed states—and the Democratic state that residents are least interested in leaving.

A high tax low growth Illinois has very little to offer. It doesn’t have a benign climate or scenic grandeur. It doesn’t have an ocean or mountains. I noted in an article I read recently that only one of the world’s best restaurants (Alinea) is in Chicago. If we could turn homicide into a tourist attraction we’d have it made.

The article doesn’t mention one of the worst aspects of all of the domestic out-migration. Those who leave tend to be the most portable, high income folks who don’t have a problem getting another job. In-migration into these blue paradises on the other hand tends to be of low skill immigrants who pay less in taxes (to the extent that they pay taxes at all) and are higher cost because they need more in the way of social services. In other words, the tax base of these states is shrinking even as the demand for more spending rises.

1 comment

Who the Heck Are We Fighting?

And why? In reaction to the massacre in Orlando, George Friedman wonders what we’re doing:

It is now almost 15 years since 9/11 and we still have not answered the core questions: Are we at war or fighting criminals? And if we are at war, who with exactly? To distinguish between crime and war, you have to look at intent, not means. The means may be the same but the goal is different. Criminals pursue money or are unbalanced and pursue fantasies. Terrorists are pursuing political ends, and therefore, their attacks are consistent with the definition of war. War is a continuation of politics by different means. War is intimately bound up with politics. Crime is not. There are always gray areas, but this definition works.

What are the political ends of Islamist terrorists? Since the rise of al-Qaida, there has been a clear and consistent goal: to overthrow “hypocritical” Muslim states and replace them with jihadist regimes that would create a united global Muslim state called the caliphate.

To achieve this end, the jihadists need to do two things. The first is to demonstrate to the Muslim masses that they have been betrayed by their own governments, and that they have the power to seize control of their own destinies.

The second goal is to drive the United States, Europe and other non-Muslim powers out of the Islamic world. Terrorism is intended to drain the enemy of its will to continue and force withdrawal. This is the same goal of the mass bombings of World War II.

The two goals mesh, because terrorism does not require major organization or resources. It simultaneously strikes at the enemy, and empowers all its supporters who wish to be empowered.

Given this end, there is no question that terrorism is an act of war and not a crime. The problem is defining the enemy. We know that all Muslims are not jihadists. We also know that all jihadists are Muslims.

He continues by raising a point I’ve raised from time to time myself: the takfiri don’t conform to the Geneva Conventions and, consequently, have no rights under the Conventions. I think we’ve erred in sending captured jihadists to Guantanamo.

5 comments

What Role Should the Schools Play?

My wife, with characteristic incisiveness, on reading my remarks yesterday on the role of second generation Americans in the terrorism spree killings we’ve seen lately, of which the massacre in Orlando was an instance, pointed out that the schools aren’t doing their job.

The first and original purpose of the public school system wasn’t babysitting, job training, helping people to lead richer, more fulfilling lives, or employing people with college degrees who otherwise wouldn’t be able to find jobs. It was acculturation. Read John Dewey. It was to ensure that the children of the newly arrived immigrants at the turn of the 20th century became Americans. As an example of just how successful that was, the Vatican’s consistent complaint about American Catholics isn’t that we’re too Catholic. It’s that we’re too American.

If we’ve abandoned that as the purpose of the public schools, how do we expect new immigrants to become Americans? Do we want them to? What strategy do we intend to use to secure the values we wish to preserve? Do we expect that to happen magically?

8 comments

So Many Amendments to Repeal, So Little Time

Okay, okay. In the wake of Rolling Stone‘s call for the repeal of the Second Amendment I’ll start a poll. If you could repeal just one of the amendments to the U. S. Constitution, which would it be?

For me repealing the Sixteenth Amendment would be tempting but I’ll go with the Seventeenth.

7 comments

Okay, What’s Illinois’s Solution?

Richard Epstein’s backgrounder at the web site of the Hoover Institution on Illinois’s fiscal problems is solid and, if you’re interested, I recommend you read the whole thing. It’s not long—just thirteen paragraphs. It ends with a diatribe against public employee unions.

What Mr. Epstein’s post is lacking is a prescription. What is Illinois to do? Neither Gov. Rauner nor Speaker Madigan have any reason to budge. Their face-off continues as Illinois’s credit rating deteriorates, resulting in a higher cost of borrowing tomorrow than we have today. That’s no joke in a state that relies on borrowed money to pay operating expenses.

I’ve read Gov. Rauner’s “turnaround agenda”. Even if it were adopted lock, stock, and barrel it wouldn’t solve Illinois’s problems. And, of course, Speaker Madigan’s implicit prescription—more taxation and more borrowing—solves nothing either. Illinois’s tax base is shrinking even as I type.

States can’t declare bankruptcy but I honestly don’t see any other solution.

I also don’t see a resolution without amending the state’s constitution. Our legislators and governor can’t agree on a budget and we expect them to amend the state’s constitution?

0 comments

About Those Commonsense Gun Law Reforms

In a big chunk of the news media and in the Left Blogosphere the hot topic is gun control. I won’t even bother to link to a sample. Just check any major news outlet.

I think that banning high capacity magazines, i.e. magazines holding more than 10 cartridges, is a reasonable, commonsense measure. I also don’t think it would have any practical effect. If you can make the case that such a ban would have prevented the Orlando massacre, I’d like to hear it.

While I, personally, have no problem with banning the AR-15 or other similar weapons, I don’t think it’s practical. The AR-15 is the most popular “sporting rifle” in the United States. There are already 37 million of them out there. The horse is already out of the barn.

I also have no problem with waiting periods, bans on selling firearms to the mentally ill, bans on selling firearms to non-citizens, or bans on selling firearms to people on terrorist watch lists. I don’t believe that any of those would have prevented the Orlando massacre, either.

What practical, commonsense legal reforms would have prevented the Orlando massacre? Are there any? Or are gun control advocates just blowing off steam?

I’ve already seen the inevitable calls for repealing the Second Amendment. While we’re repealing amendments, why not repeal or amend the First Amendment? Wouldn’t that be more to the point while being narrower in scope?

12 comments

What Are We Worried About?

There’s an interesting, slightly counter-intuitive claim in this post at The National Interest from John Allen Gay:

Because jihadism is unpopular with the majority of Muslims, the only way that the West could experience waves of Islamist violence is by the admission of large numbers of people from places with these cultural tendencies—by a system of mass immigration with no fundamental restrictions on where that mass immigration comes from. And all this comes as mass immigration is on track to get more massive; at current rates, within ten years the foreign-born share of the U.S. population will be larger than any other time in our history. It’s a similar story in Europe. If current trends continue, the West will only see more violence.

I’ll need to ruminate on that for a while but it made me start thinking. What’s our greatest concern?

The perpetrator in the Orlando murders wasn’t an immigrant. He was the American-born child of immigrants. Similarly, Nidal Hasan, the murderer at Fort Hood was the American-born child of immigrants.

Syed Rizwan Farook, the murderer in the San Bernardino terrorist killings, was also the American-born child of immigrants. His wife was herself an immigrant.

The perpetrators of the Boston Marathon bombings were immigrants and IIRC naturalized American citizens. One of the Tsarnaev brothers came here as a young teenager; the other at eight or nine.

The perpetrators of 9/11 were visitors or on overstayed student or tourist visas.

Now let’s look for commonalities. They were all Muslim. Most were young. Most were men. There’s some evidence that they grew up in homes filled with resentment. The perpetrators of the spree killings were, by and large, native-born albeit reared in immigrant homes. The perpetrators of the mass killings of 9/11, the only incidents that were definitely suicide attacks, were not native-born.

Roughly 70 people were killed in the terrorist spree killings with some scores of injured. Thousands were killed in the 9/11 attacks and thousands more were injured. The number of perpetrators in the terrorist sprees is under a dozen. The number of perpetrators of the 9/11 attacks was 19.

I don’t see a great deal of evidence to support the idea that terrorist attacks can be eliminated or their number reduced simply by not accepting large numbers of Muslim immigrants. The terrorist sprees were mostly perpetrated by native-born Americans and the number of perpetrators is quite small.

If you have discovered a way to prevent resentment in young people, please publicize it. You’re the first.

I think the evidence is actually pretty clear. Whether you’re concerned about terrorist spree killings or mass terrorist attacks (like the 9/11 attacks), there are no non-draconian solutions. The problem of terrorist attacks is not amenable to simple solutions, at least not simple solutions that are palatable to a substantial proportion of Americans.

8 comments