The Reviews Are Coming In…

and they’re not good. Hollywood Reporter reviews the fem re-boot of 1984’s Ghostbusters:

However, although the new Ghostbusters follows the template of the original by Dan Aykroyd and Harold Ramis, the witless script by Feig and his co-writer on The Heat, Katie Dippold, has no juice. Short on both humor and tension, the spook encounters are rote collisions with vaporous CG specters that escalate into an uninvolving supernatural cataclysm unleashed upon New York’s Times Square. It’s all busy-ness, noise and chaos, with zero thrills and very little sustainable comic buoyancy.

There’s some knowing amusement in a rep from the Mayor’s office (Saturday Night Live regular Cecily Strong) keeping a lid on public hysteria by using the ghostbusters’ gender to discredit them as “incredibly sad, lonely women.” But those expecting a clever feminist spin or any other sharp 21st century twists will be disappointed, and the upgrade to new-generation VFX yields nothing remarkable.

When I first heard the howls of outrage attending the release of the first trailer for the re-boot, my immediate reaction was what on earth were they thinking? Not only is the original iconic, it was written by two of the funniest writers of their generation and starred some of the funniest performers of their generation.

And then there’s this. Feig’s previous hit, Bridesmaids, grossed $284 million, two-thirds of it from domestic box office and the balance from overseas. Most of the overseas box office came from just two countries: Australia and the United Kingdom. Not entirely surprising. Humor doesn’t translate particularly well. But here’s the point. A $284 million gross on a movie that cost $32 million to make is one thing. The new Ghostbusters reportely cost $150 million to make. To make money they’d need to do a lot better than Bridesmaids. How likely was that? The highest grossing action comedy of all time was Men in Black and that grossed $250 million.

Update

Matt Kamen at Wired liked it:

Ghostbusters is incredibly sharp, with snappy jokes that poke fun at everything from the absurdity of their situation, to politics, to New York property prices (that iconic fire house is far out of the reach of three independently financed researchers). The team’s impeccably dumb himbo secretary Kevin (Chris Hemsworth) is invariably scene-stealing too, his sheer stupidity a brilliant contrast to Hemsworth’s better-known, more serious roles elsewhere. The film’s gags come at a rapid pace, but never feel like they’re trying too hard. It’s close to the perfect action:comedy ratio.

I stick by my analysis. It’s going to take a lot for 2016’s Ghostbusters to succeed.

More. The New York Times reviewer liked it. Vox review: meh.

6 comments

Productivity

The graph above was taken from Noah Smith’s post at Bloomberg View. I’ve taken the liberty of adding a couple of rough trend lines to the graph. There are a couple of things to note:

  1. The increase in productivity from 1980 to 2002 was pretty clearly exponential.
  2. The trend from 2002 to 2006 was linear.
  3. After 2007 to 2011 the increase was linear at a much greater angle.
  4. The present trend is linear with a lower angle than that from 2002 to 2006.

Mr. Smith notes:

In past decades, we would probably have turned to libertarian solutions. The obvious answer in the 1980s would have been to cut taxes and regulation, unleashing the forces of the private sector to innovate, build and invest. Some, such as the Hoover Institute’s John Cochrane, still believe that’s the secret. Many Republican politicians would no doubt agree.

But many economists have slowly been warming to the idea that government, far from being “the problem” (as Ronald Reagan put it), might actually be a big part of the solution. This often manifests in calls for increased infrastructure spending, or for fiscal stimulus to blunt the impact of recessions. But recently, some economists have suggested that government can play a vital role in innovation, technological progress and productivity growth.

One of these has been the University of Sussex’s Mariana Mazzucato, who champions the idea that government research is behind most of our major innovations. But recently, she has been joined by some very heavy hitters: Daron Acemoglu of Massachusetts Institute of Technology and James Robinson of the University of Chicago.

Acemoglu and Robinson are known for their theory that good government is critical to economic development. They believe that strong institutions, such as property rights and the rule of law, are the key to allowing countries to unleash their productive potential. But more recently, these economists have come up with an even bolder thesis. Government, they say, might be central to technological progress itself.

I think the situation is complicated. While government can theoretically be a force driving economic growth, it operates in the realm of politics rather than economics. Healthcare and education spending are consumption not investments. In theory they could be made investments but, frankly, that’s politically impossible. If most of our healthcare spending were devoted to the young rather than the old (as it is now) and educational spending were focused tightly on saleable skills, there might be some argument but as it is? Majors in interest studies, French literature, and art history are rather obviously consumption. While they may have residuals in terms of personal satisfaction, they provide relatively little to the rest of us.

Historically, the federal government has been pretty good at mass engineering projects, e.g. Boulder Dam or the space program, with clear objectives and reasonably well understood science but terrible at other sorts of project, e.g. the “War on Cancer” now entering its 45th year. Rewarding political friends, punishing political enemies, and pursuing projects favored by your political base in recent years have tended to overwhealm projects that might provide actual societal benefits.

4 comments

The State of the Economy in 13 Charts

I’d like to commend a post at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities to your attention. The post contains thirteen charts which summarize the state of the economy from the “Great Recession” to the present plus analysis and commentary. I’ve, er, sampled one of their charts above, the one that illustrates the unemployment rate with and without the ARRA. Their conclusion is that but for the various financial stabilization moves of the Bush and Obama Administrations and the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 the recession would have been much worse.

My interpretation is that the economy is just barely holding on by the skin of its teeth and that the actual performance of the economy has been so close to the CBO’s “low estimates” of performance without the ARRA that it’s hard to believe that the “fiscal stimulus” had any effect at all. Indeed, by everyone’s reckoning any effect it had is now long gone.

It’s too bad that neither political party has anything but pipedreams for an economic policy but that’s the way it is.

3 comments

The Threat

I am no fan of Donald Trump. I cannot imagine circumstances under which I would vote for him for president. However, when I read this editorial at the Washington Post, “Both Are Unpopular. Only One is a Threat”, I could only think of the two of them which one has connived at leading us into three wars and encouraged our participation in more?

Both Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump are threats. The threats they pose are different but they’re both threats. Is it any wonder I don’t want to vote for either one of them?

2 comments

Not the Worst

I disagree with with Myron Magnet’s assertion in City Journal that Barack Obama is the worst president in American history:

But unlike Lincoln, America’s first black president didn’t bind up the nation’s wounds but scratched them open every time police killed a black man—rightly or sometimes wrongly, because when society arms men with guns and authority, it will inevitably attract some bullies, making a police chief responsible for policing his own men vigilantly, as the NYPD especially has striven to do, and as Plato told us was statecraft’s thorniest problem. Anytime a non-black man killed an African-American, Obama cried racism and said it could have been him or his son, if he’d had one. Every time a cop, white or black, killed a black American, Obama’s reflexive instinct was to blame the cop. About the mayhem of black-on-black murder in the nation’s ghettoes, he gave only a single speech.

When the president praises the Black Lives Matter demonstrators, as if they alone of his fellow countrymen know that platitudinous truth, he is only reinforcing black grievance, when his proper role is to convince ghetto blacks that their lives matter enough for them to take responsibility for them, to stop going around with chips on their shoulders and Glocks in their waistbands, to be fathers to the children they beget, and to set for them an example of the responsible citizenship that is theirs for the asking, thanks to the efforts of so many of their countrymen, white and black, living and dead.

I’m willing to cut the president more slack than that. I think that President Obama has a very bad habit of musing in public, something that’s acceptable in a college professor but problematic for a president of the United States. He intervenes in local matters that don’t really concern him and, sadly, frequently speaks before engaging his intellect. Instinctively, he reacts in such a way as to consolidate his political base, even at the expense of greater, more laudable goals.

But there’s just too much competition for the title of “worst president”. William Henry Harrison, Warren G. Harding, Andrew Johnson, and, notably, George W. Bush are frequently mentioned as contenders. I think that President Obama’s record pales in comparison with the turpidity of Harding or the damage of Andrew Johnson. As to George W. Bush, I think it’s too early to tell. He could be a contender.

4 comments

The Divide

In response to a New York Times op-ed, Ann Althouse wrote the following:

What’s missing? Why is racial discord the problem of the summer 2016? If anyone has what it takes to unify the country over race it is Barack Obama, who is President right now and who had been President for 7 1/2 years. If it makes any sense to be deciding the current presidential election on this issue, if this longed-for capacity is something that can possibly exist, then Barack Obama would be doing it now and would have been doing it for years.

Before you push us to judge whether Hillary Clinton or Donald Trump would do better in bringing us together in racial harmony, Mr. Healy, please say a few words about why President Obama has failed.

I think there would be more truth in what Ms. Althouse is asserting if the divide were solely a racial one. But it isn’t. It’s a racial and a cultural issue. President Obama, the son of a black Kenyan father and a white American Anglo mother, reared by his maternal grandparents, mostly in Hawaii, the most racially diverse state in the Union notable for an almost complete absence of a black community. President Obama could not be a pontifex for black Americans because he didn’t share their cultural roots. Skin color was not enough.

There is clearly prejudice in America and it’s largely prejudice against black Americans, the descendants of slaves, who do not come from middle class backgrounds and especially those who grew up in the urban black culture. A consideration of prominent black figures illustrates that clearly.

Rihanna is Barbadian. Kanye West had a middle class upbringing and spent a crucial pre-teen year in China. Beyoncé has a middle class family and was reared by both of her parents. Drake is a Canadian with a black American father and a Jewish Canadian mother. Idris Elba was born in the United Kingdom of African parents. Denzel Washington’s family is middle class and he attended a military academy. Nicki Minaj is Trinadian. Lupita Nyong’o was born in Mexico to Kenyan parents. The list is a lengthy one. These are the rule rather than exceptions.

5 comments

Evaluating the Obama Presidency

As Barack Obama’s presidency enters its final six months, is it too early to grade the Obama presidency? Let’s get a head start, concentrating on a handful of core issues: Iraq and Afghanistan, foreign policy more generally, the economy, healthcare reform, fiscal policy, general atmospherics. Is there anything else I should add? Feel free to suggest more categories in the comments.

I’ve been reading commentary from strong partisans, either claiming that President Obama will go down in history as one of the great presidents or that he’s been an awful president. My preliminary opinion is that President Obama is neither a hero nor a goat and has been at best an average president but I’m still in the information-gathering phase.

3 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Revisiting the Kerner Report

I was considering fisking Julian Zelizer’s article at Atlantic, “Is America Repeating the Mistakes of 1968?”. I reconsidered and will now merely pass it along.

If you’re not aware of it, the Kerner Report was a report on race relations in the United States published in 1968, the work of a commission appointed by President Lyndon Johnson and headed by then Illinois Gov. Otto Kerner (a year later Kerner would be convicted of accepting bribes, the first of four Illinois governors to be convicted for various corrupt practices, but that’s another story).

Nearly every prediction of the Kerner Report has proven factually wrong. For example, it predicted that many if not most American cities would have majority black populations by 1985. That did not happen. What actually has happened is that black populations in major American cities peaked around 20 years ago and have been falling.

Anybody who believes that nothing has changed in the nearly 50 years since the Kerner Report was published is a blind fool and anyone black or white over the age of 60 can testify to that.

Have we achieved some sort of racial parousia? Far from it as events of the last year or so have have dramatized so graphically. But enormous progress has been made. Unfortunately, the young don’t realize just how bad things were so they can’t possibly appreciate how much better they are now.

5 comments

Radicalized With Respect to Race

Writing at City Journal, Steven Malanga lays the blame for any increased racial divisions solidly at the feet of the Obama Administration:

Several Obama administration initiatives have distorted the national conversation on race. In 2010, for instance, the administration’s education and justice departments launched investigations against school districts around the country for disciplining black students more often, proportionately, than students of other races. A Department of Education study observed that black students were three and a half times more likely to be disciplined. The study alleged that, “everyday educational experience for many students of color violates the principle of equity.” In making its charges, the department ignored compelling data showing that black students were more likely to misbehave in and around school—including crime statistics revealing that blacks were 25 times more likely than their white counterparts to be arrested at schools for serious offenses like battery.

Similarly, the administration’s Department of Housing and Urban Development, through a policy known as Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing, now is essentially charging wealthier suburban communities like those in Westchester County, New York, with housing discrimination if their populations are not diverse enough for the administration’s taste. Under the new rules, the federal government no longer must prove that these communities are actively engaging in racial discrimination in order to compel them to cast aside local zoning rules and build housing that would attract low-income residents. The mere fact that a town’s population is not diverse suffices for the Obama administration to demand that the community make efforts to transform itself. “HUD’s power grab is based on the mistaken belief that zoning and discrimination are the same,” Westchester County Executive Rob Astorino wrote in 2013. What’s particularly ironic about this implication of racism in Westchester’s case is that the county voted by nearly a two-to-one margin for Obama in 2012.

Consider this statement of President Obama’s in reaction to the murders of police in Dallas on Thursday as a case in point:

First of all, I think it’s very hard to untangle the motives of this shooter. As we’ve seen in a whole range of incidents with mass shooters, they’re, by definition, troubled. By definition, if you shoot people who pose no threat to you—strangers—you have a troubled mind. What triggers that, what feeds it, what sets it off—I’ll leave that to psychologists and people who study these kinds of incidents.

A mind less subtle than President Obama’s would be tempted to take the shooter at his word. As a first order approximation I think stated motives are a pretty good indicator, just as they are with the actions of violent radical Islamists.

When someone is radicalized with respect to any particular issue, it means that they see every event through the lens of that issue. When you are radicalized with respect to race, race becomes the only significant factor for you. A crime suspect is killed while resisting arrest? If he’s black, it must be because of his race. With every encounter with police there is some likelihood of that encounter going wrong and leading to violence. The more encounters, the greater the risk.

Is it possible that black men experience encounters with police at a rate disproportionate to their perpetration of crimes and misdemeanors? Is it possible they are killed by police officers in numbers disproportionate to the number of encounters with police? I think the answer to both questions is “Yes” but we can’t have confidence in the answer because the necessary statistics are simply not collected and maintained.

That might seem like something a good, investigative reporter would latch his or her teeth into. Perhaps at some past time. Now they just take to social media proclaiming its unshakeable truth.

6 comments