The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Not So Bad

George Friedman, in an apparent attempt to assuage our fears, tells us that the present election is far from apocalyptic in its implications:

The United States now knows who the candidates of the two major political parties are. One of these two will most likely become president of the United States in January. As usual, each candidate and their partisans are predicting total catastrophe if the other wins. There are also claims that there has never been an election like this in history. As is normally the case, the candidate of the party out of power is claiming that the United States has reached a catastrophic point because of the current government. The other candidate is saying that the country is not collapsing but that it will collapse if the opposition’s candidate is elected.

This is pretty normal stuff, including the belief by much of the public that there has never been such an election before. But that is wrong. There have been others with much more at stake. The 1860 election resulted in a civil war that killed 600,000 soldiers on both sides. In 1968, the leading candidate of the Democratic Party, Robert Kennedy, was murdered after winning the California primary. Martin Luther King Jr. had been murdered a few months before and the Democratic Convention was held amid massive riots outside the convention hall. In the end, Richard Nixon was elected, about which no more needs to be said. In the 2000 general election, there was a recount in Florida and the case wound up in the Supreme Court. The Democrats continue to claim the election was stolen.

I think the situation is much worse than he suggests. I don’t believe that most voters in 1860 knew that electing Abraham Lincoln to the presidency would lead to a bloody civil war. That’s a post hoc judgment on Mr. Friedman’s part.

There are similarities between the 1860 election and the present one. It was conducted during a low level insurgency (I don’t know what else you’d call the murders of police officers that seem to be taking place on a weekly basis). The degree of rancor was high. It had a strongly regional character. If a significant proportion of the population come to believe that they need to fight to preserve their way of life, the resemblance will be even stronger.

I think a better analogy would be to the election of 1828 or 1832. Yes, those were apocalyptic. They were foundational. American politics hasn’t been the same since.

4 comments

The Gathering Storm

By all indications the next 14 weeks will be mean, grueling, and infuriating. In the interest of preserving comity if not sanity I want to propose a couple of guidelines.

First, avoid name-calling. Either of the candidates, other commenters, or me.

Second, present evidence for your claims, preferably from reliable sources. WND, Breitbart, HotAir, Democratic Underground, Media Matters, and the Daily Kos are not reliable sources. Major media outlets are reliable on some subjects but not on others, particularly politics. It’s getting darned hard to find consistently reliable unbiased sources.

The same is the case with government data sources. They’re reliable on some subjects but not on others. It’s helpful if you understand the limitations of the data they present and the constraints under which they operate.

Some individuals are authoritative on some subjects but not on others. Noam Chomsky is an authority on linguistics but not on politics or history. Paul Krugman is an authority on certain aspects of international trade and international finance and less so on other economic subjects but not an authority on politics. And so on.

I pledge to do my best to conform to those guidelines myself. It’s going to be darned hard to write about either candidate and remain within those constraints but I’ll do my best.

6 comments

I Won’t Comment on the Trump Economic Plan

I won’t comment or attempt to analyze a Trump economic plan for a simple reason: any announced plan of his would be irrelevant, mere window dressing. Mr. Trump sees everything as a negotiation and his objective is to obtain the best possible outcome from any negotiation. If there are points of contact between the negotiated agreement and his announced plan, fine. If not, the planks of his plan weren’t possible. If you think that’s good, you like it. If you don’t, you don’t.

It would be nice if he would explain his evaluation function to us but I’m quite sure he expects us to trust him which makes me queasy.

3 comments

The Clinton Economic Plan

Over at the Washington Post’s Wonkblog, Jim Tankersley presents a detailed description of Hillary Clinton’s economic plan. Here’s the meat of it:

Her plan includes spending more than $1 trillion to rebuild U.S. infrastructure, allow students to attend college without incurring debt and help working families afford day care for their children and take paid leave to raise them. She thinks such spending would create jobs and accelerate economic growth, help low- and middle-income students gain skills that are increasingly necessary for high-wage work, and reverse a recent trend of women leaving the U.S. workforce.

She would raise taxes on the highest earners and impose a new minimum effective tax rate for them, to pay for those programs and to curb inequality. She would add to the Obama administration’s wave of new regulations on Wall Street. And she would change the tax code to discourage companies from moving operations overseas, while encouraging them to share profits with workers and invest more in long-term opportunities.

Basically, I can’t determine whether that plan would help, hurt, or not do very much at all. Infrastructure projects selected based on return on investment could help a little; projects selected based on political clout could hurt a little. There’s no way to distinguish between the two of them in the abstract.

Similarly with education. Another million actuaries might help a little; another million art majors are unlikely to.

Will increasing the marginal personal income tax rates on the highest income earners realize additional revenue? Or reduce income inequality? Historically, there’s been very little relationship between the highest marginal income tax rate and the amount of revenue realized. The tax code is a lot more complicated than that.

There’s more than one way to “share profits”. Why have workers (particularly unionized workers) tended not to invest in the companies they work for? If they had, they might be sharing those companies’ profits. Why has executive compensation grown so explosively over the last 25 years? I think it’s because of Clinton era tax reforms. It certainly coincides with them.

To my eye most of the plan consists of articles of faith, calling for professions of faith rather than analysis. There are much more straightforward and efficient ways of addressing the ills the planks of the plan are purportedly intended to address. A Pigouvian tax levied on beneficiaries of managed trade agreements with the proceeds distributed to those hurt by the agreements would remediate the harm. Giving money to the poor would do more to promote income equality than taxing the rich. The greatest single thing we could do to help the working poor would be to reduce or eliminate the payroll tax. And so on.

Unfortunately, none of those will ever be proposed by the leadership of either political party. They don’t fall within the tenets of their faiths. They’re heresy.

0 comments

Building Prosperity for Whom?

I want to commend Jacob Hacker and Paul Pierson’s thought-provoking op-ed in the New York Times to your attention. It’s expressly a retort to those who point to low tax states as models for economic growth and prosperity:

Mr. Trump and House Speaker Paul Ryan are united by the conviction that cutting taxes — especially on corporations and the wealthy — is what drives growth.

A look at the states, however, suggests that they’re wrong. Red states dominated by Republicans embrace cut and extract. Blue states dominated by Democrats do much more to maintain their investments in education, infrastructure, urban quality of life and human services — investments typically financed through more progressive state and local taxes. And despite what you may have heard, blue states are generally doing better.

and it’s accompanied by an eye-catching graphic depicting median household income, life expectancy at birth, taxation of the top 1% (state and local taxes), patent rate, and percent of population with bachelor’s degree or higher by state.

I wish they had factored two other things into their thinking—Gini coefficient and percentage black and Hispanic population by state. Their paragon state, Massachusetts, has one of the highest Gini coefficients (least income equality), exceeded only by Connecticut and New York. Its percentage black plus Hispanic population at 18% of total is far below the national average of 30%.

I also wish they had excluded professional degrees from their measure of educational attainment. The very high incomes of medical doctors and a relatively small number of lawyers and MBAs skews the statistics on education to the extent that it’s difficult to draw any meaningful conclusion from them. In response to my conclusion that most bachelor’s and master’s degrees are meaningless with respect to income expectations, someone always brings up statistics that include the lifetime earnings expectations of professionals. Unless your plan is to give everything an MD, JD (from a top law school), or MBA (from a top school), I think your plan is suspect.

We have a problem fostering prosperity in this country and the problem has race written all over it. If your assessment of how we should be fostering prosperity doesn’t take that factor into account, you’re looking at the problem through a keyhole or from a height of 50,000 feet.

How does your plan to make everyone prosperous by seeing that they all get associate’s or bachelor’s degrees reach people who aren’t graduating from high school? Are we actually creating jobs that require associate’s or bachelor’s degrees or are jobs that used to require high school graduation now being taken by people with associate’s or bachelor’s degrees?

I’m eager to listen to any plan that has genuine prospects for making people’s lives better. Let’s not just tell a fraction of the story.

3 comments

“Visually Stunning”

I’ve been reading some movie synopses. Is it my imagination or are the words “visually stunning” primarily applied to otherwise weak movies in which the cinematography and effects have overwhelmed the story, acting, and direction?

0 comments

Clintonized vs. Trumpified

If there are two things that should have become clear over the last two weeks, it’s that the Democratic Party apparatus has become thoroughly Clintonized while the Republican Party has nearly completed the project of becoming completely Trumpified. What does that mean?

The Democratic Party apparatus has been revealed to be deceitful, corrupt, dishonest, vain, arrogant, out for personal gain, and hypocritical. When fully Trumpified the Republican Party will be ignorant, egotistical, self-promoting, opinionated, mendacious, and self-contradictory.

And people say I should prefer one over the other.

18 comments

The Scenarios

Last night my wife and I were discussing the distressing mess in the 2016 presidential election. I told her that I thought the greatest likelihoods were either that Hillary Clinton would win and we’d wonder what all the hoopla had been or that Donald Trump would win and Republicans and Democrats alike would be wandering dazed through the wreckage of their respective parties wondering what the heck had happened.

At this point I’d give Sec. Clinton a slight edge but only a slight one.

2 comments

Who Do I Agree With?

I recently took a little Internet quiz that claimed to determine how my views aligned with various presidential candidates. My results were (in decreasing order of agreement) Gary Johnson, Darrell Castle, Bernie Sanders, Jill Stein, Donald Trump, and, bringing up the rear, Hillary Clinton. My views didn’t align any of them particularly closely.

Some might characterize my results as self-contradictory or confused. I think it’s the opposite. The major political parties are self-contradictory and confused.

0 comments