Just the Facts

Former U. S. ambassador W. Robert Pearson opens his post at RealClearWorld, “The Syria ‘What If’ That May Haunt Obama”, with the following statement:

On Aug. 21, 2013, the Syrian government murdered more than 1,400 innocent Syrians in the Damascus suburb of Ghouta — including several hundred children — in a nerve gas attack.

It is presented as an unassailable fact. That is, indeed, the U. S. government’s position. Is it true?

Since August 2013, the Nobel Prize-winning Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons and a group of weapons experts have produced independent reports which arrived at the conclusion that the attack was perpetrated by jihadis. Over the period of the last two years there have been multiple instances of the use of chemical weapons that were unquestionably by the jihadis, lending credence to those findings.

I don’t know the truth of the matter. I do know that the truth of the matter makes the most difference when your primary argument for more forcible U. S. intervention in Syria is the Assad regime’s use of chemical weapons against the Syrian people. I hold no particular fondness for the Assad regime. I merely think that stability in the Middle East including Syria is in our national interests, that chaos in the Middle East is against our interests, and the path to stability in Syria resides with the Assad regime.

It might be helpful to try explaining President Obama’s subsequent actions. The closest Amb. Pearson comes is an oblique sideswipe at the president’s motives.

5 comments

Shorter Leashes

I don’t comment much on sports here at The Glittering Eye. It’s just not one of my interests. However, I did want to remark on the sorry incident involving a U. S. swimmer (who, by the accounts I’ve read, is a well known shmeggegie) in Rio.

Like it or not the athletes on the U. S. Olympic team are ambassadors. They represent us not just themselves. And in a world of 24 hour news when every smartphone is a videocamera it’s not possible to hush up athletes’ misbehavior as it used to be.

Either we should start taking character into account when awarding positions on the U. S. Olympic team or we should be keeping our team on shorter leashes from the time they arrive in the host country until the time that they leave.

1 comment

Do We Want Unregulated Healthcare?

I think that Richard N. Lorenc’s analysis at the Foundation for Economic Education is right as far as it goes. The title of the post is “Why Luxury TVs Are Affordable when Basic Health Care Is Not” and here’s the story he tells:

Imagine this. You are feeling under the weather. You pull out your smartphone and click the Rx app. A nurse arrives in 20 minutes at your home. He gives you a blood test and recommends to the doctor that she prescribe a treatment. It is sent to the CVS down the street, which delivers it to your door in 20 minutes. The entire event costs $20.

Sounds nuts? Not so much. Not if health care were a competitive industry. As it is, medical care prices are up 105% in the last 20 years. This contrasts with the television industry, which is selling products that have fallen 96% in the same period.

Television sets today are commodities, mostly manufactured outside the United States. Healthcare is highly regulated. The constraints on a completely free market in healthcare include insurance regulations, occupational licensing, patents, certificates of need, the right to sue for malpractice, FDA approvals, and thousands of others.

I think it’s true that if healthcare were completely unregulated it would be cheaper. Here’s my question. Do we really want unregulated healthcare? I don’t think we do and as a society we decided we don’t more than a century ago. How soon we forget!

If we don’t that means the policy solution isn’t eliminating regulation but adopting other alternatives to ensure that the economic surplus is divided between suppliers and consumers rather than being captured almost entirely by suppliers as is the case today.

That means that the political process pokes its nose into the process. It’s messy and inefficient but it’s better than the alternative.

5 comments

Do the Math

I think there are some things that James Moore is neglecting to consider in this piece at Marketwatch on how much more difficult it is to save for retirement today:

The reason for roughly one-quarter of the increase is good news: We are living longer! Life expectancy for a man aged 65 has increased by about 1.6 years per decade over the last few decades, and so today’s 65-year-old can expect to live on average roughly four years longer than his father. The story is similar for women, although not quite as dramatic.

The second piece of the increase in the annuity factor is attributable to lower, much lower, interest rates. Twenty-five years ago, the yield on the 10-year U.S. Treasury TMUBMUSD10Y, +0.00% was a little over 8% versus its current level of around 1.5%. The long steady decline in rates is the major culprit, responsible for three-quarters of the increased cost.

In finance we use an interest rate to calculate the present value of future payments, but to make it more applicable, think about it in reverse: At today’s low rates, savers earn much less yield on the same amount saved than they did 25 years ago.

Put another way, every $100,000 in your retirement savings at 65 buys you about $5,900 of annuity income a year; 25 years ago it was about $11,600.

So three smart things to do:

1) Start saving early

2) Save more

3) Work a little longer.

which are that

  1. Every additional dollar saved is a dollar that disappears into the financial economy and doesn’t go into the real economy where it might create more jobs.
  2. People actually need to eat, pay rent, and buy clothing. They can’t save the entirety of their wages. There are limits on how much they can actually save.
  3. Somebody who’s aged 45 and out of work, a significant fraction of the long-term unemployed, probably won’t have the opportunity of working longer.
  4. A significant fraction of the young people today have substantial education debt not dischargeable in bankruptcy. The limits on their saving are even greater.

He’s preaching to the top 10% and maybe to the top 1% of income earners. What about the rest of the people? His prescription is a bit too Marie Antoinette like for my liking. Keep in mind what happened to Marie Antoinette.

6 comments

What Was It About Dick Powell…?

Every year since 1932 the Quigley Publishing Company has taken a survey of motion picture proprietors to get their opinions of the motion pictures actresses and actors who have brought the most paying customers into their theaters. In 1934 Dick Powell and Ruby Keeler broke into the top 20 in that list and one, the other, or both of them remained in the top ten or twenty in the Quigley list through 1937.

My wife and I watched 42nd Street on TCM last night for the umpteenth time. That’s the movie that prompted Powell and Keeler’s meteoric rises. It must have as many lines and situations that have become cliches as any other pictures. I you haven’t seen it I recommend it. Great songs by Warren and Dubin, Busby Berkeley production numbers, and fine performances by Warner Baxter (the actual lead of the movie) as well as the supporting cast, including Bebe Daniels, Powell, Keeler, Ginger Rogers, Allen Jenkins, Guy Kibbee, Charles Lane (who gave his last performance in 2006, and my cousin in one his many bit parts.

What struck me in watching 42nd Street was how popular Powell and Keeler became despite how ordinary they are. Dick Powell can’t act or dance, and has a pleasant but not particularly good singing voice. Ruby Keeler can’t act or sing and can dance a little. They’re both nice looking young people—not particularly gorgeous.

I think they must have struck a chord with audiences in the depths of the Depression. Two pretty ordinary young people rising to success through sheer determination. As qualities for becoming a star it sure beats the heck out of today’s crudeness and irony.

5 comments

The Situation in Syria

Rather than critique Aaron David Miller’s post on the situation in Syria at RealClearWorld, which I urge you to read, I’ll offer my own views on Syria in bullet form.

  • Unless defended by some protector, e.g. the Ottoman or the French, the Alawite minority can expect to be subjected to a pogrom by the Sunni majority, particularly after the experience of the last 70 years.
  • The Sunni majority is even more radicalized now than it was 70 years ago.
  • The Alawite regime believes it is literally fighting for its life and those of all Alawites.
  • The most radical elements are increasingly in control of the opposition to the Syrian government.
  • No stable partition of Syria is possible, at least not one that includes the jihadis.
  • Chaos in Syria promotes the interests of the jihadis.
  • Syria is part of Russia’s “near abroad”. It’s in their neighborhood.
  • The Russians are very much at risk from jihadis within their own borders.
  • The first objective of Russia in Syria is stability.
  • That should be our objective, too.
  • To that end we should stop supporting the rebels and encourage our allies to do the same.
4 comments

Is There a Word For It?

Remember the Great Recession? It was in all of the papers. The editors of the Economist point out that with respect to the housing sector the reforms that have been undertaken in the wake of the collapse of the housing bubble may well have actually made things worse:

The banks have cut risk and costs and raised fees in order to grind out decent profits. Bosses and regulators point to chastened lenders and boast that the problem of banks “too big to fail” has been solved. Taxpayers, they say, are safe.

Only in their dreams. That trillion-dollar capital buffer exists to protect banks, but much risk lies elsewhere. That is because, since the 1980s, mortgage lending in America has been mainly the job of the bond market, not the banks as in many other countries. Loans are bundled into bonds, guaranteed and sold around the world. Investors on Wall Street, in Beijing and elsewhere own $7 trillion-worth.

When those investors panicked in 2008, the government stepped in and took over the bits of the mortgage-guarantee apparatus it did not already control. It was a temporary solution, but political gridlock has made it permanent. Now 65-80% of new mortgages are stamped with a guarantee from Uncle Sam that protects investors from the risk that homeowners default. In the heartland of free enterprise the mortgage system is worthy of Gosplan.

What could possibly go wrong? Let me suggest that with lax oversight and underwriting by the federal government it is practically inevitable that increasingly risky loans will be made and, eventually, the entire structure will collapse. Again.

Is there a word for reform that’s actually reform in the wrong direction? “Corruption” doesn’t quite cover it.

3 comments

The Business Model

The late Sen. Robert Byrd was the master of an ingenious strategy to “bring home the bacon” to his home state of West Virginia, bolster its flagging economy, and, coincidentally, be elected and re-elected to nine consecutive terms in the Senate, more than any other senator. The strategy consisted of directing every conceivable federal spending project that could be directed to West Virginia to West Virginia. He didn’t invent the strategy but I think it’s fair to say that he was its unexcelled master.

To get some idea of how successful he was at the strategy, consider the list of places that bear his name. Many if not most of those were built or are funded with taxpayer dollars.

I see no evidence that Sen. Byrd employed his strategy to bootstrap the flailing West Virginia economy. I think it was a simple, opportunistic grab.

In his recent post at RealClearMarkets John Tamny makes a point that should be obvious but I fear is not. We can’t boost the national economy by employing the strategy that Sen. Byrd did in West Virginia:

Just as the Federal Reserve can’t increase credit in locales where economic activity doesn’t rate it, neither can Congress. Clinton’s proposal for greater growth will fail simply because money doesn’t stay long where there’s no return to be had on it. That’s why money is plentiful in high-growth areas like Beverly Hills, Silicon Valley and New York’s Manhattan, and it’s similarly why it’s scarce in Mississippi, West Virginia, and Baltimore, Maryland. Government spending can’t alter this reality. When Clinton says she can, she’s fibbing.

What at least has the potential to change what’s true is more investment in search of risk, or once again, surprise. At present, parts of the U.S. that struggle economically are risky places to commit capital, but because they’re risky they offer high potential reward to the intrepid investor willing to try what hasn’t previously been thought of. Such investing promises lots of failure, and that’s why the rich are so crucial to economic advancement in places where there’s very little. They alone have the funds that they can put at risk precisely because they’re wealthy. When politicians promise to tax away this wealth, they’re promising to reduce the amount of money chasing the ideas of the future that, if successful, will generate enormous amounts of economic growth. Congress can’t do this given the oft-repeated truth in this piece that Congress can only direct money toward what is known, and that for being known doesn’t promise the high returns necessary for booming growth.

So if readers are curious to see what Hillary Clinton will achieve economically assuming she gets her way, they should again take a look at West Virginia. It’s not a pretty sight. The good news, however, is that whether Trump or Clinton, neither will be able to do a fraction of what they promise. This redounds to us all simply because their proposed economic plans, like the Christmas wish lists of most children, thankfully have little to do with reality.

Private investment chases return; historically, public investment has not. We shouldn’t expect spending decisions that were not made based on return to yield return.

3 comments

The Future

James Taranto, in his column at the Wall Street Journal, has seen the future in the discussions of reviewing Seth Rogen’s latest movie among the editorial staff of a “queer publication”, as it is described by its editor, and it is ponderous, humorless, hypersensitive, and radicalized. Here’s a snippet:

Where does one begin with this? We suppose with the sentence about “consent,” which left even some of the site’s commenters incredulous. “Santina” describes it as “not something I would ever have thought I would have to read in my life, ever.” Yet we’d argue it’s not the craziest bit. The animated characters are, after all, anthropomorphic; one can imagine a stylized scene in which sex is portrayed as either consensual or forcible.

Stranger to our mind is the speculation that “she was bisexual.” For goodness’ sake, “she” is a fictitious animated taco shell. Either the film portrayed her as bisexual or not; she has no inner life.

It is also completely Orwellian. Language is eccentric, policed, and rapidly changing.

Under such circumstances practical progress in dealing with the issues at hand grind to a crawl. Now transpose all of those qualities to government or, indeed, any large organization, already nearly fossilized by its sheer size.

1 comment

The Afghan Translators

There’s a strategy which both admits more refugees, something the Obama Administration appears to be committed to doing, and mitigates whatever risk they pose: give preferential treatment to the applications of the people we know the most about—the translators who’ve been working for us in Afghanistan and Iraq, in some cases for many years. The editors of the New York Times call for something very much like that:

As things stand, there are roughly 12,600 applicants with pending petitions and only about 2,500 visas the State Department is authorized to issue. That means that about 10,100 Afghans, who had every reason to believe their service to the United States would be rewarded with a safe haven, may be left behind.

The State Department and other government agencies involved in vetting applications administered the program poorly for years after it was established in 2009. Many applicants waited for several years to learn whether their cases were approved. Other applicants were rejected without being told why. Over the past couple of years, responding to an outcry from veterans and members of Congress, officials have begun to process cases more quickly. But the department expects to run out of visas to issue early next year.

[…]

Failing to keep our promise to Afghans who risked life and limb in the battlefield would add a shameful chapter to the mixed legacy of America’s longest war.

As Sam Clemens put it, “Always do right. This will gratify some people, and astonish the rest.”

1 comment