Who Owns China’s Banks?

China’s largest banks continue to be entirely or mostly state-owned enterprises. Foreign banks do only a tiny fraction of China’s banking business.

Starting in 2001 and to satisfy the commitments it made in joining the WTO, China allowed a small amount of strategic, minority foreign ownership of Chinese banks. To the best of my ability to determine that ownership is at about 3%, far below the WTO target of 8%.

If anyone has information that contradicts that, I’d greatly appreciate the correction.

0 comments

Is That China’s Biggest Economic Challenge?

When I read the editors’ of Bloomberg’s latest observations on “China’s Biggest Economic Challenge”:

The best way to describe China’s economic quandary is also the simplest: It can strive for maximum growth now or later — but not both.

China’s government is well aware that promoting the growth of the world’s largest economy in the long term involves structural changes that will slow the economy in the short term. And its success in striking a balance has surprised many analysts. In several areas it has pressed ahead with ambitious reforms while letting growth moderate to a gentler pace (by Chinese standards) of less than 7 percent a year.

I didn’t know whether to be amused or concerned. I don’t think Bloomberg’s editors have any real understanding of China.

I believe that for the Chinese authorities economic growth is just a means to an end and the end is their continuing hold on power and wealth in China. Given a choice between slower growth and relinquishing power, they’ll choose slower growth every single time.

Meanwhile, I think the most likely explanation is that China has followed the same path that the Soviet Union did 80 years ago. It grew by moving relatively unproductive labor resources from subsistence agriculture to manufacturing. China’s leaders did a better job at maintaining agricultural production during the process than the Soviets did but increasing agricultural productivity stalled more than a decade ago.

China’s working age population has already peaked and, unless present trends change, its total population will peak in 2026. Why should they build new cities when there are few people in some of the cities they’ve already built? How will building more factories spur Chinese economic growth China when China already has the capacity to supply the entire world for the foreseeable future?

China’s truly biggest challenge is that in order to grow the authorities must relinquish control. For people to spend more wages must rise and that threatens China’s status as the labor provider of lowest cost.

0 comments

The Carrier Map: OE3 vs. OE4

I’ve touched on this topic before. Above, courtesy of the McKinsey Center for Healthcare Reform, is a side-by-side depiction on a by county basis of the number of insurance carriers that served each county at the start of the third Affordable Care Act open enrollment (OE3) compared with the number of insurance carriers that will serve each county at the start of the fourth open enrollment (OE4).

As you can see, there is a marked decline in the number of carriers. Whether you think that poses a problem or not depends on whether you think that insurance monopolies will inevitably increase prices or be able to wield monopoly power in other ways.

4 comments

In the Long Run We’re All Dead

Over at Bloomberg Jack Black points out how “fat” central bank balance sheets have become:

Picture for a moment the concept of a lean central bank.

No, not Janet Yellen or Mario Draghi out doing Pilates, but rather the thought that almost a decade after the Great Recession, central banks ought to be slimming down on the amount of financial assets that they hold.

And yet even as the U.S. Federal Reserve holds the level of its total assets roughly steady, in Japan and Europe balance sheets just keep growing.

At the Fed’s annual policy gathering at Jackson Hole, Wyoming through Saturday, questions are being asked about how long this can go on.
Take for example the European Central Bank. The Frankfurt-based ECB is engaged in an asset-purchase scheme worth around 1.7 trillion euros ($1.9 trillion), due to run until at least March next year, in an effort to boost demand and drive inflation in the 19-nation currency bloc away from the deflationary danger zone.

Consider, for example, the chart of Federal Reserve holdings above. Something has obviously changed since 2007. To give you a better idea of how that varies from the historic norm over a longer horizon consider this:

Equally obviously the financial markets are now addicted to central banks’ binge-consumption. The biggest question in macroeconomics is whether at some points central banks will need to purge. In the United States there has been tremendous resistance to the Fed’s taking any action at all, let alone selling off its holdings of financial assets.

As a reminder, Lord Keynes, quoted in the title of this post, believed that government spending to boost aggregate demand during economic contractions needed to be reversed during expansions. We have reached the point at which doing either has become politically impossible.

1 comment

Why Reforming Healthcare Is Hard

Last night, my wife, in reaction to my post on the skyrocketing price of EpiPens and the discussion in comments that ensued, observed that the subject of EpiPens touches a nerve. So many people are very emotional about it since it they or a parent or a child (or their income) are dependent on it. That makes it a poor starting off point for the more general point I was making in my post.

I responded that I was aware of that but that wasn’t just the case for the EpiPen but for everything in healthcare which is why reforming healthcare is so hard.

6 comments

The State of the Election and What Comes Afterwards

This weekend is the last weekend of August and the presidential election campaigns will soon be going into the home stretch. It’s just two months until the general election and I suspect for most Americans the election couldn’t happen soon enough.

I think the greatest likelihood is that Hillary Clinton will win with a decisive number of electoral votes but, possibly, a much less decisive percentage of the popular votes (and still less decisive proportion of the potential vote), maybe even a minority of the popular vote.

If Hillary Clinton wins I suspect that very little will change. She’ll continue most of the Obama Administration’s policies, possibly with a few flourishes of her own. In all likelihood we’ll have a recession early in her first term, at best the present phlegmatic growth will continue (phlegmatic as in 1%).

What happens if she loses? It’s not impossible and keep in mind that the econometric models mostly point to a Trump victory. Some econometric models have been jiggered recently so they don’t predict that because their authors won’t accept the possibility. I suspect that if she loses we will see an outpouring of vituperation unlike anything I’ve seen in my lifetime from both sides of the Atlantic and, possibly, the other side of the Pacific as well. There may well be social unrest unlike anything we’ve seen in the last fifty years. I know people who think that alone is sufficient reason to vote for Clinton and will vote for her despite their opposition to all of her policy positions and for her as an individual.

As I have been saying all year, the outcome will depend on turnout.

5 comments

The Argument Over EpiPens

Now that the cost of EpiPens (auto-injectors for epinephrine) has become a national campaign issue, it might be worth thinking about why they’re so darned expensive—as much as $600 a pop, having risen from $94 for a two-pack over just nine years. Timothy Holbrook considers the question at RealClearHealth and comes up with a couple of explanations: patents and lack of competition, in turn a product of regulatory barriers to entry.

Much of Mr. Holbrook’s piece is a paean to the patent system as the engine of innovation. I think that’s a subject worthy of dispassionate investigation on its own and I’m skeptical that the matter is as cut and dried as Mr. Holbrook suggests. The research budgets of today’s major pharmaceutical companies do not rise with revenues but with inflation. IMO Big Pharma (as these large pharmaceutical companies are called) are best thought of as rent-seeking organizations with small research branches.

Do we really need patents any more? Or would society as a whole be better off with reduced barriers to entry via regulation that is less friendly to the large producers and more friendly to the small?

IMO the reason that the cost of EpiPens is so high is that it’s what the market will bear and until recently consumers didn’t see the rising costs. That changed as deductibles rose and now consumers are starting to complain.

Unfortunately, they’re complaining about the high cost of EpiPens rather than rising deductibles.

24 comments

Why We Need At Least Two Immigration Policies

In an insightful post at the Washington Post Dan Drezner summarizes the U. S. immigration situation like this:

At this time, we know that:

  1. The United States is experiencing a net outflow of Mexican migrants.
  2. The number of individuals living illegally in the United States has declined (contra Krikorian, Pew estimates the number as falling from 12.1 million in 2007 to 11.3 million in 2o14).
  3. The notion that unvetted refugees are flooding into the United States is a complete lie.

This doesn’t mean that illegal immigration flows might not tick up again, particularly if the U.S. economy outpaces the rest of the world in job creation. But it suggests that, right now, the undocumented residents are in fact the biggest part of the problem.

He characterizes that as the “core dilemma” of U. S. immigration policy. While I think that illegal immigrants (most aren’t merely undocumented—that’s a euphemism) form one aspect of our core dilemma, I don’t think that’s really it. Here in summary are my views on immigration:

  1. An ongoing, reliable supply of low wage immigrants hurts poor native-born Americans, particularly African Americans, with much of the benefit going to the highest income earners.
  2. An ongoing, reliable supply of skilled immigrants hurts middle income native-born Americans by depressing wages, with much of the benefit going to the highest income earners.
  3. Many of the skilled immigrants are brought in fraudulently.
  4. A large number of immigrants creates problems for the states. Anyone who has seen a classroom in which no two children speak the same language at home understands this.
  5. A large immigrant population exacerbates income inequality, practically by definition.

Now consider the graphic at the top of this post, gleaned from the Census Bureau’s presentation on immigration using Community Survey data. The United States is the only country in the world that shares a 1,500 mile land border with a country that has a median income 20% of its own. That creates incentives for illegal border crossing different from anywhere else. That this illegal migrant workers will work for lower wages and under conditions native-born workers would protest are incentives for less than scrupulous employers to hire them, indeed, hire them preferentially, something that will continue regardless of any border control we might put in place.

That Mexico along with other Central American countries, many of whose people pass through Mexico on their way to the U. S., figures so prominently, should not come as a shock. A large Mexican population in the United States poses other challenges. I suspect that if Ireland were joined to the U. S. by a land border and the Irish claimed the United States by virtue of St. Columba’s having discovered America in a coracle there would have been even more pushback against the Irish coming here than there was.

Note, too, that people from the third largest source country by number of immigrants, India (1.8 million), also pose special problems. Nearly three-quarters of Indian immigrants to the United States speak a language other than English at home. There are more than 1,500 languages spoken in India. I don’t really know what that means. Cultural preference? Resistance to assimilation? They view themselves as guest workers rather than permanent immigrants?

Consequently, I would say that the core dilemma of U. S. immigration policy is that we need more than one immigration policy, at least two—one that pertains almost entirely to Mexico and another for all other migrants. We may actually need more policies.

5 comments

What Do You Do With an Enemy That Can’t Be Deterred?

Last week the United States government changed North Korea’s status from potential threat to practical threat. CNN reports:

Washington (CNN)The US government is increasingly concerned that advances in North Korea’s weapons program have dramatically decreased the warning time for a nuclear attack on America or its allies, according to US officials.

The regime’s aggressive testing of medium- and long-range missiles — as well as its nuclear testing — makes North Korea now a “practical” threat and no longer a “theoretical” threat, in the words of one US official familiar with the latest US intelligence thinking.

Significantly, North Korea no longer cares if the world sees its test failures, according to the latest analyses, allowing Pyongyang to more openly, aggressively and repeatedly test all of the key components needed for an attack.

As a result, the regime has the ability to hold the US and allies “at risk” with nuclear weapons, the US official said.

On Wednesday North Korea conducted another missile test, this time launching a ballistic missile from a submarine into the waters between North Korea and Japan. From Reuters:

North Korea fired a submarine-launched missile on Wednesday that flew about 500 km (311 miles) towards Japan, a show of improving technological capability for the isolated country that has conducted a series of launches in defiance of UN sanctions.

Having the ability to fire a missile from a submarine could help North Korea evade a new anti-missile system planned for South Korea and pose a threat even if nuclear-armed North Korea’s land-based arsenal was destroyed, experts said.

The ballistic missile was fired at around 5:30 a.m. (2030 GMT) from near the coastal city of Sinpo, where a submarine base is located, officials at South Korea’s Joint Chiefs of Staff and the Defence Ministry told Reuters.

The projectile reached Japan’s air defence identification zone (ADIZ) for the first time, Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga told a briefing, referring to an area of control designated by countries to help maintain air security.

The missile was fired at a high angle, South Korea’s Yonhap News Agency reported, an indication that its full range would be 1,000 km (620 miles) at an ordinary trajectory. The distance indicated the North’s push to develop a submarine-launched missile system was paying off, officials and experts said.

There was, apparently, no report of the class of the particular missile that was tested. It was presumably a KN-11 (also known as a Polaris-1, Bukgeukseong-1, or Nodong-D), the first completely successful test of the technology. Since North Korea is not known to possess nuclear submarines or diesel-electric submarines capable of reaching Hawaii or the Western U. S. seaboard, the capability does not pose a direct threat to the U. S. but it does pose a threat to the South Koreans and the Japanese.

I’m actually a bit surprised that the U. S. still hasn’t done what I suggested some time ago: use these missile tests as handy opportunities for testing missile defenses. My best guess is that we don’t want to aggravate the Chinese.

How do you deal with an enemy like North Korea that manifestly cannot be trusted, that cannot be deterred, and that is not a “rational actor”, at least not as we view reasonableness? North Korea’s only real patron is China and China appears to be willing to put up with any provocation from North Korea as long as the country doesn’t collapse entirely. China itself has been acting in a more provocative manner in the region.

9 comments

Point/Counterpoint on the the PPACA

You might be interested in the Washington Post’s latest point/counterpoint on the Affordable Care Act. Is it entering a “death spiral” or not?

Taking on the defense of the PPACA are Ezekiel Emanuel (Rahm’s brother) and Topher Spiro. Their defense is the conventional one—it’s just growing pains:

So why are insurers substantially increasing premiums or withdrawing from markets? They are making a one-time correction to bring premiums in line with costs. Setting a price is difficult when entering new markets — when the ACA was implemented in 2014, many insurers did not initially price their products accurately, and some may have even underpriced their plans deliberately in an attempt to establish market share.

conjoined with a circular argument—the PPACA won’t collapse as long as more money is put into subsidies by the federal government:

Second, policymakers can take action to further improve the risk pool — for instance, by making student loan payments deductible from younger enrollees’ incomes to boost their tax credits.

The subsidy they’re proposing must come from somewhere. The only available candidate is Uncle Sugar.

This was the statement from their op-ed that caught my eye:

Finally, keeping health-care costs under control is the best way to minimize premium increases. The rising cost of prescription drugs is one major component of growth in medical costs, and the insurance industry must get off the fence and back meaningful solutions, such as value-based pricing.

According to the Kaiser Family Foundation here’s how healthcare dollars are spent:

It might well be true that spending on pharmaceuticals is increasing rapidly. From that you might reasonably conclude that an increasing proportion of healthcare spending is devoted to pharmaceuticals but that doesn’t appear to be the case. Over the period of the last 35 years spending on pharmaceuticals as a proportion of all spending has varied within a fairly narrow range, from 8% to 12%.

What does appear to be the case is that pharmaceuticals are a large proportion of out-of-pocket spending on the part of the elderly. I suspect that Dr. Emanuel is engaging in a political calculation rather than a policy analysis.

In contrast Avik Roy makes the opposite case:

All but the most hardened partisans understand that the Affordable Care Act’s insurance exchanges are in serious trouble. In 2010, the Congressional Budget Office predicted that 21 million people would have exchange-based coverage in 2016; the real number was about 12 million. As insurers head for the exits, the gap between initial hype and final reality will widen.

The tragedy is that this was entirely avoidable. The ACA’s exchanges were fundamentally flawed in their design, something that private-sector experts tried to point out at the time. In October 2009, PricewaterhouseCoopers published a report projecting that by 2016, the ACA would cumulatively increase individual-market health insurance premiums by 47 percent. (PwC’s estimate was conservative. In fact, premiums increased by 49 percent in 2014 alone and by 77 percent through 2016.)

My assessment is that the PPACA wasn’t designed to succeed. It was designed get through the Senate. That means that it satisfied the shibboleths that had surrounded the consensus that had arisen in the leadership of the Democratic Party.

Now it’s become a sacred cow that will be very difficult to amend even when amending it makes sense.

13 comments