Religious Teachings and Presidential Candidates

One observation in James Taranto’s recent WSJ post in reaction to Hillary Clinton’s “basket of deplorables” remark caught my eye:

As Mollie Hemingway suggests, “They are irredeemable” is a strange thing for a professed Christian to say about anybody. Theology aside, it is a shocking thing for someone who aspires to the powers of the presidency to say about fellow Americans, even if she rightly thinks they hold deplorable views.

The emphasis is mine.

But that’s not true. Some Christian denominations, Calvinists for example, believe that humanity is divided into two groups. The elect are the beneficiaries of “unconditional election” to salvation. It doesn’t really matter what they do because they are predestined to be saved. The damned on the other hand are subject to “reprobation”, i.e. they are predestined for eternal damnation. You can tell the difference between the elect and the damned because the elect prosper. If Hillary Clinton really does believe that it explains an enormous amount.

Interestingly, as a child Donald Trump attended the church led by the late Norman Vincent Peale who wrote the best-seller The Power of Positive Thinking which I find telling. Mr. Trump’s version of positive thinking is highly skewed, presumably some would say perverted, but that, too, explains a lot.

I think that Mr. Taranto’s closing explication of Sec. Clinton’s remark is probably accurate:

In the context of the administrative state, the image of the “basket” actually is an evocative one.

Imagine a midlevel worker in some federal agency whose job is to review and sort files. On her desk sit three wire baskets. One is an inbox; each morning it is filled with a stack of folders containing personal information about known or suspected Trump supporters.

After reading the contents of each file, the worker places it in one of the other baskets, marked “Pitiables” and “Deplorables.” At the end of the workday, the folders in the former basket are refiled. The deplorables’ folders are packed up in a box and sent along to another agency for further action.

What kind of action? There are many possibilities. Some are more deplorable than others.

If elected to the presidency, Hillary Clinton won’t just be the president of her supporters or of the Democratic Party. She will be President of the United States including the deplorables and the pitiables. The president is not “prophet-in-chief”. Leading Americans into the light is not the president’s job. If they’re irredeemable, that’s impossible anyway.

The picture at the top of the page is “The Damned and the Elect” by Luca Signorelli from the Brizio chapel of the Orvieto Cathedral in Orvieto, Italy, painted between 1499 and 1504.

5 comments

Monopoly Power

I’ve been saying this for some time but it’s always nice to see the scales drop from the eyes of others. At FT Alphaville Matthew Klein has noticed that 80% of all of the price increases over the period of the last 25 years have been concentrated in just four sectors (really just three): healthcare services, housing, education, and prescription drugs:

In January 1990, those four product categories only accounted for 30 per cent of the money spent on consumption by the average American. (Housing was about half that.) Even after more than a quarter-century in which prices of these goods and services rose significantly faster than everything else, these four sectors still account for less than 40 per cent of total consumer spending.

Put another way, the Federal Reserve would have completely failed at both of its economic objectives had it not been for the dramatic expansion of a handful of low-productivity sectors.

Here’s my point. Regardless of the label they put on the graph reproduced above that’s not how inflation works. It doesn’t magically land on just a few sectors.

That’s monopoly power.

2 comments

Priorities

I think it’s pretty clear that Daveed Gartenstein-Ross has his priorities screwed up. In a New York Daily News op-ed he writes:

Imagine it’s 15 years ago, immediately after the 9/11 attacks. You are told that in September 2016, a couple of major counterterrorism victories would be just around the corner. These impending victories are that a coalition of countries, including the U.S., are on the verge of retaking the Iraqi city of Mosul and Syrian city of Raqqa from jihadists.

To put it mildly, it would be obvious that something had gone horribly wrong in the U.S.’s fight against Al Qaeda and associated movements.

Certainly billions and probably trillions in contracts have been let; incumbents have been repeatedly re-elected; Bush was re-elected; Obama was elected and re-elected; Hillary Clinton is on the cusp of being elected to the presidency.

Surely these are the things of overwhelming importance. Judge by what they do not by what they say.

2 comments

Tredecimum Non Datur

I was surprised that in the list “ideas to save Europe” he presents in Politico EU Jacoppo Barigazzi doesn’t present the one idea that seems most obvious to me. The ideas he does allow his readers to vote for include refocusing on security, economy, and youth unemployment; a eurozone government; more technocracy less politics among others.

But he doesn’t include dumping Germany out of the EU or at least out of the euro. Germany’s GDP is the highest in the EU, its GDP per capita is among the highest, its unemployment is the lowest, and it has the largest trade surplus. Getting Germany off the euro would do more to help the rest of the members of the eurozone than all the other measures put together.

1 comment

There Is No Better Late Than Never

Imagine this. In December of 2008, rather than arguing as he manifestly did that a fiscal stimulus of $800 billion spread out over three years was the perfect medicine for what ailed the U. S. economy, Lawrence Summers had stated what was already obvious—that the stimulus that the Obama Administration wanted was too small and that all of the $800 billion should be disbursed over the first 100 days of the Obama presidency. Yes, there would have been political pushback. There was already political pushback. And carrying water for politicians wasn’t his job. His job was giving economic advice not lending his PhD in economics to strength the president politically.

Apologists for the Obama Administration retort that we didn’t know how deep the recession was in early 2009. True enough. But we knew that there had been shortfall of more than 2% which is what the stimulus represented.

That’s why op-eds like this recent one in the Washington Post from Dr. Summers bother me:

There is a compelling case that infrastructure investments pay for themselves by expanding the economy and increasing the tax base. The McKinsey Global Institute has estimated a 20 percent rate of return on infrastructure projects. If the return is only 6 percent and the government collects about 25 cents on every dollar of GDP, the government will earn 1.5 percent on investments. This far exceeds the real cost of borrowing even over a horizon of 30 years. Debt financing of new infrastructure investment over the next few years would be entirely reasonable.

As my former business partner used to say, I agree with what he says but I will deny to the death his right to say it. Why wasn’t he pushing for more stimulus when it could actually do some good?

In Keynes’s thinking there was no “better late than never”. If shortfalls in aggregate demand were not compensated for on a timely basis, structural changes would take place in the economy. Hasn’t enough time passed? We’re in the long run and, believe it or not, Keynes said things other than that in the long run we’re all dead. If he taught that stimulus spending could increase aggregate product, I missed that.

Meanwhile, some other quibbles with Dr. Summers’s claims. Does he think that all spending is investment? Or does it matter where the investment is placed? Given the changes in personal transportation on the horizon, e.g. autonomous vehicles, ridesharing, over the life of a highway how much spending is investment and how much is just plain deadweight loss?

I also am skeptical about his ability to predict real interest rates 30 years out.

11 comments

The Case Against Intellectual Property

At RealClearMarkets John Tamny argues that we shouldn’t take action to prevent the Chinese from stealing the intellectual property of U. S. companies on the grounds that their theft has done the companies no harm:

In dynamic economies like ours, good ideas in 2016 will mostly be revealed as bad in 2017. At Amazon, founder Jeff Bezos treasures his company’s successful ventures simply because the successes will fund countless experiments that fail. Venture capitalist Peter Thiel freely acknowledges that most of the ideas he backs with venture money die very quickly. So if the Chinese are in fact “stealing” American intellectual property as so many confidently assert, everyone should relax given the historical truth that they’re stealing what is mostly worthless.

Further evidence supporting the above claim is the price of U.S. equities. If the Chinese were truly crippling U.S. companies with thievery, this would show up in crashing U.S. share prices alongside the collapse of the biggest export market for Chinese producers. Yet we’re seeing neither. As for the supposed theft of intellectual bandwidth behind what is already established in the marketplace, readers need only consider all the former assistants for New England Patriots coach Bill Belichick, along with all the former writers for television hit Seinfeld. Having done this, readers need to check the wins/loss track record of Belichick’s past minions as head coaches alongside the hits versus bomb ratio of former Seinfeld writers. Success is hard won, and can rarely be duplicated, or taken.

I have never read John Tamny’s making a broadside argument against intellectual property before but that’s what this post is. If intellectual property isn’t worth defending against the Chinese why is it worth defending against Americans? If the value of intellectual property is determined solely post hoc, as Mr. Tamny argues, that applies to domestic fair use as well as deliberate Chinese theft.

0 comments

Okay, So What Are the Factors?

Glenn Reynolds concludes a post on the migration of high income earners from high (and some medium) tax states, e.g. New York and Illinois, to states with lower taxes like Texas:

Instead of squandering hundreds of millions on political consultants, the GOP donor class would be better served setting up a “Welcome Wagon” that would target these movers (easy to do) and send them information on why the states they’re moving to are doing better.

Okay, I’ll bite. Why? Please quantify the results.

I think that the states with net domestic inmigration over the last five years nearly all produce oil. States with net domestic outmigration are all highly developed. The costs of buying homes has a lot more to do with it than taxes.

8 comments

Are We More Secure?

In the millions of words spoken, in print, and on the Internet that we were treated to yesterday in recognition of the 15th anniversary of the attacks on September 11, 2001, no inconsiderable number were devoted to comparing the circumstances of today with those of September 10, 2001. Are we safer?

Many of those who are notionally responsible for that safety pointed to inputs rather than outputs as proof positive that we were safer, something I regard as strong proof of its opposite. That was particularly true of Jeh Johnson, secretary of the Department of Homeland Security. Doesn’t DHS’s $40 billion annual budget prove we’re safer?

I’d like to present an alternative approach for evaluating the question. It’s simple to state. First, identify the critical success factors of the attack. Then determine whether we’ve blocked them or mitigated the risks that they present.

There is one critical success factor in the attacks that is no longer a factor. We no longer station troops in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. However, we do continue to support the regime there, we provide them with arms, and the regime continues to be repressive. Clearly, some risk remains on that front.

Our continuing interventions in the region have increased the threats for that reason. Did invading Iraq, removing Saddam Hussein or Moammar Qaddafi, or propping up the corrupt Afghan government make us safer?

Much of the attention domestically has been devoted to federalizing airport security. TSA’s high failure rate suggests that a lot of that has been waste motion. I don’t believe the “security theater”, as it’s been called, does much to make us safer and the inevitable revelation that it has been security theater tears down whatever additional safety was provided.

I find few signs that other risks, e.g. the way we extend travel visas or our lax handling of them once extended, have been mitigated at all.

Overall does the conclusion that a lot of effort has been expended to solve the problems of elected officials but relatively little has been done to make us safer sound too cynical? That’s what I think has happened.

3 comments

Constitutional Officers

Please correct me if I’m wrong on this. To the best of my knowledge the only offices mentioned in the U. S. Constitution are president, vice president, and president pro tempore of the Senate.

Additionally, under the terms of the Constitution and the Twelfth Amendment, the president and vice president are a) voted on separately by the electors and b) there is no requirement that the serving president and vice president represent the same political party.

9 comments

It’s Dead, Jim

The effect that American politics has on the rest of the world is truly amazing. If the claims of American pundits are to be believed, it causes people in faraway countries to rebel against their governments, it’s responsible for global warming, it’s the reason for the rise of DAESH, and it induces people to leave their homes to move to other countries. Writing at the Washington Post Jim Hoagland epitomizes such an American pundit:

Count on a European stampede toward Moscow — and an even more precipitous swing to the nationalistic right in European politics — if Trump is declared the winner here in November. That moment would also mark the final burial of that American ideal of internationalism that helped to make Europe a more prosperous and peaceful continent for the second half of the 20th century.

Sorry, Jim. We’re just not that important. Let me make an alternative prediction: European politics will “swing to the nationalist right” regardless of whom is elected president in November because internal economic, social, and political circumstances and fundamentals are a lot more important to our European cousins than the bloviations of our politicians.

The internationalism that Mr. Hoagland longs for is and always has been a will o’ the wisp. It will remain so as long as relative values differ among the peoples of different countries which IMO is likely to be forever. At least as long as I’ll live which for me amounts to the same thing. It is dying of its own pretensions rather than because of anything we’ve done or failed to do.

The reaction of the elites to the predictable outcome of the shell game they’ve been playing reminds me of nothing so much as an old Wizard of Id cartoon.

0 comments