Question About Healthcare Insurance

Is continuity in healthcare insurance plans desireable and what is its value? That occurred to me when I read one of the many articles in which the author complained about having to shop for insurance because his or her old plan had been cancelled or had become unaffordable.

It seems to me that introducing price discovery presumes some level of volatility.

18 comments

Take It and Like It

Writing at the Chicago Tribune, John Kass isn’t the first to notice how issue-less the presidential campaign is and he probably won’t be the last. He remarks:

“My dream is a hemispheric common market, with open trade and open borders, sometime in the future with energy that’s as green and sustainable as we can get it, powering growth and opportunity for every person in the hemisphere,” Clinton reportedly said to investors in a paid speech she gave to Brazilian Banco Itau in 2013.

Here’s the thing about borders. If you don’t have borders, you don’t have a country. Americans are beginning to understand this. Europeans understand it now, quite clearly.

Clinton’s dream also includes a Western Hemispheric common market, like the European common market that is dissolving in chaos, fear and debt.

If that is indeed her dream, then she dreams the internationalist dream that would end America. But Americans aren’t talking about this, perhaps because there is no video involving sex and Hollywood and Trump.

I would love to hear Clinton’s explanation. Perhaps she could put it in some proper context.

Or perhaps she was merely telling the Brazilians something they wanted to hear, because they were paying her a good chunk of cash.

It would be interesting to know but we probably never will.

I presume that’s just how the Clinton campaign wants it. The most favorable conditions for Hillary Clinton’s election to the presidency is to keep the voters’ focus firmly on Donald Trump’s low character while wishing out loud that you could turn to the issues.

And it really won’t make a great deal of difference in this election. We’re going to take whatever the winning candidate wants to do and like it.

3 comments

Which Is Worse?

As I read this article in New York Magazine, decrying Donald Trump as an ignoramus, a judgment with which I concur, something occurred to me. Which is worse, when all you know about Russia is Russian propaganda or all you know about Russia is U. S. propaganda?

Just as an example, the facts in Syria are that Russia and the Syrian government are fighting anti-government rebels there including DAESH while the United States is both fighting and supporting DAESH by supporting rebel groups affiliated with DAESH. Civilians are being killed in DAESH because civilians are killed in war. Are the Russians and the Syrians targeting civilians? I honestly have no idea. I’m confident that the U. S. isn’t targeting civilians but we’re killing them nonetheless.

4 comments

Where Things Actually Have Changed

I wish that Steve Forbes would make a better argument for his preferred policy, more immigration if not open borders, than he does. In particular I’d like him to address the following issues:

  1. If there were really a demand for more unskilled workers in the United States, you’d expect real wages to increase. They aren’t which strongly suggests that there is no such demand.
  2. If there were really a demand for more STEM workers, you’d expect real wages to increase. They aren’t which strongly suggests there is no such demand.
  3. The marginal productivity of labor is flat or declining.
  4. In particular the marginal productivity in labor in sectors that are adding employment, e.g. healthcare, when measured in outputs per hour worked is actually declining and has been for decades.

His main argument is that we have always been a nation of immigrants, an appeal to emotion. Conditions have changed. Real wages increased for most of our history. So did the marginal productivity of labor.

3 comments

Dealing

Am I too cynical in believing the deal that the city seems to be cutting with the Chicago Teachers Union just means that more money that the city doesn’t have will be spent? And that will mean higher taxes which in turn will make Chicago less affordable, particularly on the part of those least able to pay?

If there were a clear relationship between increased spending and better outcomes, it would be one thing but there isn’t.

1 comment

How?

A regular commenter’s response to my post yesterday on technological unemployment was terse:

1) We produce more…
2) With fewer human workers.
3) How?

My answer is equally terse. The same way it has been for tens of thousands of years.

Technological advances have created surpluses. The surpluses have made new jobs possible or even necessary. Some are in primary production. A century ago practically no gallium or germanium was produced commercially. Now they’re essential to our civilization and new jobs mining and refining them have sprung into being. Thousands of tons of the stuff are produced.

At its height there were hundreds of thousands more jobs in the auto sector than there ever had been in the carriage manufacturing sector. That’s an example of increased production not resulting in technological unemployment but in the creation of many more, better paying jobs.

But by far the most jobs will be in secondary production. What will those jobs be? We have no idea but the Department of Labor says that 65% of today’s schoolkids will work for businesses that haven’t been created yet.

Here’s another example of technology making jobs possible that hadn’t been possible before. Writing. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics more than a hundred thousand people earn their livings as authors or writers in the United States alone. Four hundred years ago practically nobody did anywhere. What happened? Advances in technology.

People have been complaining that their jobs were becoming obsolete due to machines for 200 years. While there has been some short term technological unemployment, every instance of that is a tragedy for those involved and I don’t want to minimize that, there has been no massive unemployment due to technology. That was true in 1820. It was true in 1920. It was true in 1990.

Is it possible that today really is different? Sure. But there are very real costs associated with guessing wrong about something like that. The costs not only take the form of the direct costs of dealing with massive technological unemployment that never happens but in the opportunity costs of doing that and the deadweight loss that results.

Additionally, there are other explanations for what’s happening right now and those explanations are demonstrable. Among these explanations are foreign competition, immigration, and deadweight loss (deadweight loss alone is estimated to cost millions of jobs). Taxi drivers and coal miners aren’t just victims of technological obsolescence. Policy preference also pays a role. Treating policy preference and technological obsolescence as though they were the same thing is an overreaction as well as making it more difficult to devise solutions.

The historically slow rate of new business formation is one of the factors in slow job growth, too. New businesses produce new jobs. Old, established businesses cut costs by, among other things, cutting jobs. Over the period of the last thirty years most net job creation has been by new businesses. We don’t know why the rate of new business formation has slowed but policy preference seems to be a likely explanation.

Just to head off a possible complaint about some of my observations above, the alternative to the adverse effects of taxation and regulation isn’t no taxation or regulation. it’s better, more targeted taxation and regulation.

Under the circumstances those who are concerned about technological unemployment need to produce much stronger evidence for their theories than they have to date. It’s not enough just to ask how.

4 comments

My Dad’s Birthday, 2016

Today is my dad’s birthday. I didn’t forget—I’m just busy. I’m taking another class which I’ll write about some other time. It takes me an hour to get out to the class which runs from 8:30am to 6:00pm. Now I’m beat. I’ve got four days of this. It doesn’t help that I just got about four hours of sleep last night.

Recently, I embarked on a great adventure. I’m having all of my dad’s old slides and home movies converted to high definition digital format. Some of the slides go back to the 1930s and some of the movies to the 1940s. If the results are good, I’ll have lots of new pictures of him and other family members, some of which I’ve never seen before. I’ll keep you informed.

Up until now I’ve hesitated about even looking at them. They’re so fragile and irreplaceable.

As I think I’ve mentioned before my dad died at too young an age. I was in my teens. One day he was just gone. I had no warning. I was in shock for months, maybe years. He was the strongest, bravest, smartest, kindest man I’ve ever known.

With all of this season’s movies and TV shows about time travel I’ve been thinking lately about what I would do if I could spend just one more day with him. I have hundreds of questions. And maybe a few answers.

6 comments

How to Think About Technological Unemployment

At EconLog Scott Sumner posts what strikes me as a reasonable framework for considering technological unemployment, i.e. whether “robots are taking our jobs”. Here’s a snippet:

I think it’s possible that automation plays at least a small role in the 2.5% drop—perhaps by depressing the wages of unskilled workers, and making the unskilled work still available less attractive than other options.

In this area, it’s always best to try to approach the issue as unemotionally as possible. It doesn’t help to draw sweeping conclusions, such as “it’s all about laziness, after all the Mexican immigrants can find jobs” or “it’s all about a lack of aggregate demand, after all the big drop occurred during the recession.” People are complicated and dozens of factors can interact to produce a given outcome. Look at the comment section after their debate, and you’ll see how not to think about this sort of issue.

When I think about causation, I approach it in terms of counterfactuals. Suppose we moved away from free trade? Suppose we discouraged automation. Suppose we reduced the benefits paid to middle age people not working. Each policy counterfactual might or might not have much effect, at the margin. My hunch is that reducing benefits and reducing incarceration would slightly boost the participation rate–but nothing dramatic.

He concludes with the observation that we don’t really know.

As I’ve written before, while I think that the hypothesis is possible I think that a) it hasn’t happened yet and won’t happen for some time; b) there are plenty of other factors which can explain present unemployment; and c) the burden of proof is on those who believe that technological unemployment is a present or near term problem.

4 comments

Over the Weekend

I have seen or heard nothing over the last 72 hours that convinces me that Donald Trump is anything but a repellent lout and blowhard and I can’t imagine circumstances under which I’d vote for him. So, nothing has changed.

7 comments

There Goes the Narrative

Frequently you’ll hear someone giving President Obama credit for “saving the economy”. That puzzles me for a couple of reasons.

  1. Barack Obama took office in January of 2009.
  2. The recovery began in June of 2009.
  3. In June of 2009 not one penny of the money appropriated under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (“the stimulus package”) had actually been disbursed.

That makes the claim that the ARRA ended the recession a bit of a stretch. You’d need to believe in a sort of immaculate conception—that the prospect of the stimulus was enough to end the recession.

I think there are reasonable arguments that

  1. President Obama’s stimulus package prevented the economy from going into a double dip.
  2. The Economic Stimulus Act of 2008 ended the recession.
  3. The ARRA was irrelevant to the recovery. It was just too late, too small, and improperly targeted.
  4. The ARRA actually made the recovery more phlegmatic than it might otherwise have been.

I lean towards either A or C. Could someone flesh out the idea that President Obama saved the economy?

4 comments