Their Heaven Is Our Hell

Another article on the battle for Mosul that’s worth reading is Daniel Bynan’s at Brookings. He summarizes the military situation:

The military challenges in the Mosul operation are considerable. (The New York Timeshas produced a useful graphic of how the fighting may commence.) Although the U.S. military estimates that there are only between 3,000 and 4,500 Islamic State fighters in Mosul, compared with tens of thousands of members of the coalition forces—and that excludes the advantage of U.S. airpower—the defenders enjoy the considerable advantages of their position within the city itself. Urban turf is a nightmare for attacking forces.

And the Islamic State has had time to prepare. After the group seized Mosul in 2014, its forces planted bombs and dug tunnels and otherwise sought to create secure communications and supplies, even as drones hover overhead. Over one million civilians are mixed in among the fighters, complicating coalition bombing efforts and creating the risk of atrocities from vengeful Iraqi forces.

and then goes on to sketch the complicated web of conflicting goals among our allies.

Mosul has historically been one of the most diverse cities in Iraq. Most of the downtown area is Sunni Arab while the remainder of the city and the rural environs are populated by Kurds, Yazidis, and Assyrian and Chaldean Christians.

The Iraqi government’s (and their Iranian allies’) definition of victory could well be to extend Shi’ite influence in Mosul, in the name of removing DAESH remnants, of course. I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if the Kurds imagined Mosul as the capitol of an independent Kurdistan. I’m not sure what the U. S. objectives are with respect to Mosul other than uprooting DAESH, far too short term an objective but, then, we’ve always been specialists in short term objectives.

We should be prepared for the possibility that our various allies in the battle have drastically different definitions of victory from ours or from each others’.

If anyone has an idea for how to ensure a happy ending from our point of view at least to the battle in Mosul that doesn’t involve our sticking around to play referee, I’d be interested in hearing it.

7 comments

Stiffeners

I recommend that you read Con Coughlin’s remarks on the battle for Mosul at the Telegraph for the excellent graphic depicting the tactical situation in Iraq’s second largest city if for no other reason. His primary observations in the piece are that a) we haven’t been terribly successful with our proxies in Iraq, Libya, etc. lately—astonishingly, they have their own priorities and agenda; and b) without the 5,000 American soldiers as “stiffeners” the battle in Mosul would be very much in doubt if it were taking place at all:

Our attempts to work with proxies in countries like Libya and Syria, by contrast, have been less successful, not least because our so-called allies have been more interested in pursuing their own agendas. In Libya, many of the anti-Gaddafi militias we supported morphed into anti-Western Islamist factions, while in Syria Western-backed groups are more interested in fighting each other than Assad.

And it is entirely feasible we could experience similar difficulties once the fighting for Mosul is over – for example, the Kurds make no secret of their desire to use land captured from Isil to create their own state. So we need to be clear. The fact that any form of military intervention by the West is now seen as political suicide comes at a heavy price. It means we have no other option than to work with proxies and simply hope they share the same goals about tackling our enemies.

Is it possible that there might be lessons learned about our planned decamping from Afghanistan in the situation in Iraq now? For example, that once we’ve removed the governments in these ersatz countries the only alternatives we have are stationing troops in them for the foreseeable future or allowing them to collapse into chaos?

2 comments

The Case for Talking With Russia

At The Globe and Mail in an op-ed stating the case for why Canada should be negotiating with Russia over the Arctic, Michael Byers summarizes the drastically different perspective that the Russians have about their actions and ours:

Russia is isolated and agitated. As its economy implodes, President Vladimir Putin protects his position by stirring up nationalist sentiments – mostly against the United States.

Russians worry about the deployment of U.S. missile defence in Eastern Europe. They believe that the North Atlamtic Treaty Organization is encircling them as it expands eastward. The annexation of Crimea is, from this perspective, just the latest effort to hold off an aggressive, intentionally destabilizing West.

Russians see the war in Syria as a necessary defence of sovereignty against outside intervention, of stability against Western-induced regime change and chaos. They believe they are acting legally in Syria, because they were invited by the government of Bashar al-Assad.

Russians recoil against the language being used against them. Last month, Samantha Power, the U.S. ambassador to the UN, told the Security Council that “what Russia is sponsoring and doing [in Syria] is not counter-terrorism, it is barbarism.”

Russians see the world differently than we do. They might be wrong. They might even be paranoid. But a bear that feels threatened will often charge. And just as a grizzly will stand on its hind legs to make itself more intimidating; last week, Russia conducted three ballistic missiles tests.

Today, the world is closer to nuclear war than at any time since the Cuban missile crisis. The smallest incident could spiral out of control. Imagine what might happen if a U.S. fighter jet were mistakenly shot down by a Russian anti-aircraft missile, or Russian troops were struck by a U.S. bomb.

It’s not just the Canadians that should be “talking to the bear”, as Mr. Byers puts it.

The only two countries in the world with the present capability of destroying the world are Russia and the United States. There is no more important bilateral relationship in the world than that between the United States and Russia and that relationship is now in the worst shape in which it has been since the collapse of the Soviet Union. The stakes are very high. Talking to the bear rather than poking it is in our interests as well. Considering our serial foreign policy miscalculations of the last 25 years, a little more humility might be called for on our part.

4 comments

Propaganda

Most of what Americans know about history, government, politics, and current events they learn from watching television. And most of that is not from watching news or public affairs program but from watching television dramas or even comedies. That television dramas have enormous power in influencing opinion very nearly goes without saying. That’s not just true in the United States. An astonishing number of Britons learned all they know about criminal law by watching Law and Order. The police in the UK frequently have arrestees demand that they be “read their rights”, something not nearly as significant in the UK but a staple of U. S. police procedurals.

One of the freshman network television dramas this season is Conviction. It’s about a task force of young, attractive lawyers with the job of determining whether convictions were just or unjust. It’s also sort of a re-imagining of Chelsea Clinton in the same way that The American President or The West Wing were re-imaginings of the Clinton Administration or Madam Secretary is a re-imagining of Hillary Clinton. But that’s irrelevant to my point in this post.

Last night’s episode centered around the bombing of a mosque and, frankly, it bugged me. To the best of my knowledge no mosque in the U. S. has ever been bombed. Promoting the idea that American Muslims have a legitimate fear of having their places of worship attacked by anti-Muslim bigots is IMO irresponsible and may spill over into propaganda. It’s particularly irresponsible in the light of the “defending Islam” excuse that radical Muslim extremist terrorists provide as a justification for their crimes.

Here’s the ACLU’s list of “anti-mosque activities”. Many of them, while obnoxious, are legitimate expressions of freedom of speech, e.g. threats on Facebook, dropping burned copies of the Qur’an on doorsteps. And no bombings. The closest activity to a bombing they list is the detonation of a couple of pipe bombs outside a mosque.

The United States is a country of 320 million people. In a country of that size there are bound to be a few nutcases or drunken fools. Promoting that as an actual threat is irresponsible. Even when a major party presidential candidate is a blowhard given to making anti-Muslim remarks or remarks that may be construed that way.

Do you know who has a legitimate fear? Jews. Synagogues have actually been bombed and every year or so a plot to blow up a synagogue is disrupted. According to the FBI’s latest statistics, hate crimes against Jews outnumber hate crimes against Muslims nearly 10 to 1. This despite the fact that there isn’t even a pretext of a rational basis for it. At least not among Americans.

And, of course, there have been many, many more bombings of Christian churches in the U. S. than there have been of mosques or synagogues. Just not in proportion to the number of Christians in the country.

11 comments

Robotics in Surgery

You might find this non-technical article on the use of robotics in surgery at Singularity Hub interesting. I think we will see more of this sort of development rather than less unless it’s strangled in the womb.

As I’ve said before there’s a lot more potential for the automation of expensive processes than there is in cheap ones.

2 comments

It Couldn’t Happen Here

At least not now. That’s what occurred to me when I read this article at Aeon on Soviet attempts to implement something analogous to the network that has become the global Internet. I think that the development of the Internet was an accident of history and that if it hadn’t been invented when it was it wouldn’t have been invented at all.

The history of the Internet goes back about forty years to the ARPANet. The protocols that define the Internet were a federally-funded attempt to produce a computer network that could survive a nuclear war. That’s obviously a product of the Cold War.

The first commercial Internet service providers started up in the late 1980s and in 1992 the Scientific and Advanced-Technology Act largely opened up the Internet to commercial use. I don’t think it was a coincidence that took place at the very peak of neoliberalism in the United States.

There had been many previous attempts at producing largescale commercial networks. France had a national network that preceded the Internet. They had all failed to gain widespread acceptance. It took something non-proprietary to gain that kind of acceptance and that just would not have been possible unless the Internet had developed very much as it did.

1 comment

The Battle to Retake Mosul

The battle to retake Mosul from DAESH has begun. At RealClearWorld Anthony Cordesman remarks:

In fact, the most critical aspect of the battle may not be whether ISIS is defeated. It may be whether Iraq’s deeply divided factions can find some way to cooperate if they win. The alternative could be worse than ISIS: Sunni versus Shi’ite, Arab versus Kurd, and Turkey, Iran, outside Arab states, and Russia all competing to serve their own ends. “Winning” could all too easily divide Iraq on a lasting basis and/or turn into new forms of civil conflict. Here, it is useful to hear about the preparations for the fight. The problem is the lack of any credible public statements as to how the Iraqi and U.S. governments will react once ISIS is defeated.

Both the proper timing and actual success are critical. This battle cannot be safely politicized. Any major reversal in the fighting for Mosul will affect the future stability of every political element in Iraq, the future success of the U.S. effort to create effective Iraqi security forces, and global perceptions of the future of both ISIS and other violent Islamist movements. Here, a certain amount of trust in the U.S. military will be critical. If U.S. military briefings sometimes seem a bit vague, they should be. Focusing on play-by-play descriptions of progress and problems weakens Iraqi trust and U.S. influence, and provides far too much information to ISIS.

Right now there isn’t anything to analyze. Just a few self-serving reports from participants for which it is impossible to gauge the accuracy or authority. When there is something, I will.

Whether the “battle cannot be safely politicized” or it can, believe me, all of the participants will. We’re already seeing it.

For the most informative analysis on the likely aftermath of the battle see this article from Patrick Ryan and Patrick B. Johnston at War on the Rocks. DAESH will likely go underground (as I noted yesterday it may have already).

0 comments

A Mind Is a Terrible Thing to Lose

Has Robert D. Kaplan lost his ever-loving mind? In a Wall Street Journal op-ed he proposes escalating the incipient conflict between Russia and the United States by inserting U. S. troops into the countries of the Baltic:

For example, just as Western military intervention in Syria risks a Russian response in Europe, a robust movement of American forces permanently back to Europe may cause Mr. Putin to be more reasonable in Syria. This may offer a way out of the sterile Syria debate, in which all the options—from establishing safe zones to toppling Bashar Assad’s regime—are problematic and offer no end to the war. By seriously pressuring Russia in Eastern and Central Europe, the U.S. can create conditions for a meaningful negotiation whereby Moscow might have an incentive to shape the behavior of its Syrian client in a better direction.

For the last twenty-five years the U. S. has been engaging in aggressive, provocative actions with respect to Russia. Clinton Administration officials used to brag about it. Not the least of these actions was expanding NATO to include the Baltic countries, a move which did not improve U. S. security one whit.

To understand why the Russians might consider that aggressive, imagine that the U. S. were to reconstitute SEATO with the same “an attack against one is an attack against all” provision. It then expands the reformed organization to include South Korea and starts moving military assets, possibly including nuclear weapons, into South Korea. Do you think the Chinese would find that aggressive and provocative? I think it’s obvious that they would.

An analogy has been drawn between Russia’s nervousness about the Baltic countries and the Cuban missile crisis. That’s right. Except that we’re playing the role of the bullying, aggressive Soviet Union.

If we’re truly interested in defusing the tensions with Russia, a good place to start would be to refocus our efforts in Syria away from regime change and maintain focus on the area in which we and the Russians have a mutual interest: eliminating terrorism. We don’t have to like or support Assad but we could just stop talking about regime change until after we and the Russians have destroyed DAESH.

There’s an old Henny Youngman wisecrack that goes like this. A guy says to his doctor, “Doctor, it hurts when I do that.” (making some contorted gesture) The doctor responds, “Stop doing that.” If we want to defuse tensions with Russia, we might stop doing “that”.

13 comments

Flying the W

My neighborhood on the Northwest Side of Chicago is flying the W tonight. The Chicago Cubs face the Los Angeles Dodgers in Wrigley Field in the second game of the National League playoffs. If last night’s game was any gauge, it looks pretty good for the Cubbies to go all the way.

I think it was Mike Royko who noted that there was no purer expression of fandom in sports than being a Cubs fan, a love unadulterated by thoughts of victory. This year victory might be within Cubs’ fans’ grasp.

4 comments

How Many Homeless Are There in the Big Cities?

Alex Berezow has an interesting post at the American Council on Science and Health on the number of homeless people there are in the largest cities in the U. S., both on a total basis and as a percentage of the cities’ populations. As is not terribly surprising New York and Los Angeles have a lot of homeless people. Chicago is a lousy place to be homeless in the winter time.

The city with the largest absolute number of homeless people is New York with about 75,000. The city with the largest number of homeless people per 100,000 population is, oddly enough, Springfield, Massachusetts. Even when adjusting for population the bluer the state, the more homeless people there are.

It looks to me as though city size, climate, and moral hazard were all factors.

3 comments