No Book Contains All Knowledge

The moral of this article at The Economist, on the extremely high rate of cousin marriage in the Middle East is that the Qur’an was written before we had much knowledge of genetics. Cousin marriage is stigmatized but legal in most of the developed world but commonplace and accepted in the Middle East.

Unfortunately, the practice can render genetic disorders more common as this snippet from the article suggests:

MAHA SAAD ZAKI, a professor of clinical genetics, ushers Ahmed, Fatima and their family into her room at Egypt’s National Research Centre. At least three of their six children have a rare neurological illness that manifests itself around age four, causing mental retardation, loss of the use of their limbs and, later, death. The couple’s nine-year-old daughter slumps, twitching. This congenital illness has appeared because, as well as being husband and wife, Ahmed and Fatima are also first cousins (their names have been changed).

Cases like these are all too common in the Middle East and north Africa. Marrying a close relative markedly increases the chance that both parents are carriers of dangerous recessive genes, which can then cause disease when a child inherits a copy of the gene from both parents, as will happen in 25% of cases. The gamut of such illnesses runs from known ones such as microcephaly (in which children have unusually small heads) cystic fibrosis and thalassaemia, a blood disorder, to wholly new disorders. “Ninety percent of the cases I see are caused by consanguineous marriages,” says Ms Zaki.

The conclusion of The Economist from this, no doubt, is that we should be importing a lot more people from the Middle East to the United States.

7 comments… add one
  • ... Link

    For Est., Inc. types, EVERYTHING is a reason to import more Third World people into the USA & Europe.

  • michael reynolds Link

    I don’t think this really adds to the arguments against allowing immigration from the ME. Syrians moving here will not be marrying their first cousins. And the same indifference to DNA is resent in Judaism: http://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/468337/jewish/Prohibited-Marriages.htm

    A Man May Marry:
    1. His step-sister (a step-parent’s daughter from a previous marriage, even though they were raised together as brother and sister from their earliest youth).
    2. His stepfather’s wife (divorced or widowed).
    3. The daughter-in-law of his brother or his sister (divorced or widowed).
    4. His niece. In American and English civil law, a man may not marry a niece who is the daughter of his brother or sister, but may marry a niece who is the daughter of his wife’s brother or sister. The halakhic permission—even encouragement—to marry the daughter of a brother or sister is superseded by the civil law’s prohibition in this case.
    5. His cousin.
    6. His stepson’s wife (divorced or widowed).
    7. His deceased wife’s sister, but not his divorced wife’s sister (unless she is deceased already).
    8. A woman with whom he had relations in their unmarried state.
    9. A kohen may marry a widow (who was never divorced).

  • michael reynolds Link

    Damn it, screwed up the code. Sorry.

  • Syrians moving here will not be marrying their first cousins.

    Evidence? I think you’ll find that community remains highly endogamous.

  • ... Link

    Evidence? I think you’ll find that community remains highly endogamous.

    And current family reunification policies will help with that.

  • michael reynolds Link

    I meant that there are laws against cousin marriage in the US. Then I checked: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cousin_marriage_law_in_the_United_States_by_state

    WTF? Contrary to the cliché, it’s the Northeast and California, along with parts of the deep south, that allow cousin marriage.

  • Yes, the Midwest and the West tend to have laws against cousin marriage.

Leave a Comment