Is He Beating a Dead Mule?

Ruy Teixeira urges, presumably, the Democratic Party leadership to adopt the following principles:

  • Equality of opportunity is a fundamental American principle; equality of outcome is not.
  • America is not perfect but it is good to be patriotic and proud of the country.
  • Discrimination and racism are bad but they are not the cause of all disparities in American society.
  • Racial achievement gaps are bad and we should seek to close them. However, they are not due just to racism and standards of high achievement should be maintained forpeople of all races.
  • No one is completely without bias but calling all white people racists who benefit from white privilege and American society a white supremacist society is not right or fair.
  • America benefits from the presence of immigrants and no immigrant, even if illegal, should be mistreated. But border security is hugely important, as is an enforceable system that fairly decides who can enter the country.
  • Police misconduct and brutality against people of any race is wrong and we need to reform police conduct and recruitment. However, more and better policing is needed to get criminals off the streets and secure public safety. That cannot be provided by “defunding the police”.
  • There are underlying differences between men and women that should not all be attributed to sexism. However, discrimination on the basis of gender is wrong and should always be opposed.
  • People who want to live as a gender different from their biological sex should have that right. However, biological sex is real and spaces limited to biological women in areas like sports and prisons should be preserved. Medical treatments like drugs and surgery are serious interventions that should not be available on demand, especially for children.
  • Language policing has gone too far; by and large, people should be able to express their views without fear of sanction by employer, school, institution or government. Free speech is a fundamental American value that should be safeguarded everywhere.

in preference to what he says is the present Democratic strategy—pretending those concerns will go away.

I think the problem he’s facing is that those who work on campaigns or on staffs tend to be more radical than those who don’t. When you’re radicalized with respect to race, you can’t accept most of those principles or “values” as Mr. Teixeira calls them. You’ll believe the account laid out in the “1619 Project” which rules out the top four in that list. When you’re radicalized with respect to sex or sexual preference, everything bad that happens can be attributed to sex or sexual preference and rules out accepting some of the others.

He doesn’t even touch on the disparity in beliefs between “normies” and radicalized activists with respect to climate change. When you’re radicalized with respect to climate change, you attribute everything bad that happens to AGW. I suspect that most Democrats believe that human-caused climate change is happening but they still want to have their own cars, heat and cool their homes, etc. That puts them at odds with the radicalized activists and those activists are punching above their weight these days.

I would subscribe to the values he lists as I believe most Americans would. However, I think Mr. Texeira is right:

Then think of how many Democratic politicians, especially national Democrats, are willing to go on record espousing these values. Precious few.

Are there any reasonable prospect for what Mr. Teixeira is urging? Or is he beating a dead mule?

6 comments… add one
  • steve Link

    But the activists arent getting their ideas made into laws. Not even proposals for the most part. There is no law anywhere that has been proposed of which I ma aware that would outlaw, cars farms and require all jobs under $100k be held by Venezuelans as was proposed yesterday. The activists dont even get elected except in areas like San Francisco where they really do represent the public, and even in San Francisco they have booted some of the radicals.

    Steve

  • jan Link

    I look at Mr. Teixeira’s bullet points as refreshing the “normalcy button” in the ever-increasing erosion of our culture and living standards. “If only” comes to mind in wishing more people would look at these principles, taking them seriously to heart. Even though the radical left may still be in the minority, their squeaky wheel tenacity confuses and disrupts the mindsets of a populace, making it far more difficult to concentrate and enact policies having a positive effect rather than cultivating a constant state of polarization.

  • Larry Link

    You first Jan

    ” Even though the radical left may still be in the minority, their squeaky wheel tenacity confuses and disrupts the mindsets of a populace, making it far more difficult to concentrate and enact policies having a positive effect rather than cultivating a constant state of polarization.”

  • Drew Link

    As always, steve, you tell us the issue is non-existent. And yet, objectively, DA’s are letting crooks go, the border is wide open, as Dave will subsequently note, the cost of educating has tripled and so on.

    Perhaps most importantly, the exodus is on. People and businesses are fleeing large, Democrat controlled cities, and left leaning states. Given the high friction costs of moving, its hard to believe the issues are figments of people’s imaginations.

  • steve Link

    As usual, most of the items in the list are straw men. Just go over a few.

    1) Who doesnt agree with that? However, at some point if the disparity os too large or too persistent is it beyond the pale to even suggest that maybe we dont really have equal opportunity, especially when we can document it?

    2) Every liberal neighborhood has 4th of July parade and you find lots of American flags on the houses. I was actually willing to serve my country during 2 different wars, deploying to one of them, but I am not patriotic?

    3) Virtually everyone agrees except for a very small group of zealots with little power.

    4) Again, the huge majority of people agree.

    It would be easy, maybe even fun, to compose a list of ideas believed by the most radical 5%-10% of conservatives and then claim that all conservatives have those beliefs. But what’s the point? Sure it would be fun to ask Drew how many Zimbabwe dollars he has saved up and when he thinks the Jubilee will occur, but I dont think he is actually that crazy.

    Steve

  • steve, you’re underscoring the point of the cited piece. Both Ruy Teixeira and I agree with you that most people believe those values. Does the Democratic leadership? Both Mr. Teixeira and I think the gap between the Democratic leadership and most of the population is significant and widening. That’s the reason the party is losing the support of “normies”, as Mr. Teixeira terms them.

    It should be easy for you to prove your claim. Find one member of the Democratic leadership who says:

    Discrimination and racism are bad but they are not the cause of all disparities in American society.

    and

    Racial achievement gaps are bad and we should seek to close them. However, they are not due just to racism and standards of high achievement should be maintained for people of all races.

    and

    People who want to live as a gender different from their biological sex should have that right. However, biological sex is real and spaces limited to biological women in areas like sports and prisons should be preserved. Medical treatments like drugs and surgery are serious interventions that should not be available on demand, especially for children.

Leave a Comment