Each to His Own Taste But REALLY

There are times when I look at a list of “our favorite movies of all time” in stunned disbelief. Consider, for example, this list from the editors of the Wall Street Journal. I note with sorrow that not a single picture in their list was made before 1950. Was noone’s favorite Casablanca, The Maltese Falcon, The Treasure of the Sierra Madre, or any of a hundred other pictures of not only surpassing excellence but also tremendous entertainment value made before 1950?

But Kangaroo Jack?

8 comments… add one
  • PD Shaw Link

    It didn’t strike me at first, but going back through the list, these all appear to be movies with a conservative theme. That’s the only explanation for choosing The Incredibles over more worthy Pixar movies like Finding Nemo.

  • PD Shaw Link

    I’ve never seen Kanagroo Jack, so I don’t know how it fits in.

  • PD Shaw Link

    Kangaroo Jack represents the wonders of market capitalism, where a movie widely panned by elite, liberal opion-makers, can still receive a direct-to-video release.

  • john personna Link

    Someone warned me that these “best of” lists, with a forward button, are a callow mechanism to boost page views. Since then I never click through.

  • michael reynolds Link

    One of the techniques for creating a character is to give him a list of favorite movies. I don’t do it myself because it’s more of a Writing 101 kind of thing. But it can work in a primitive sort of way to define a character.

    I think that’s what these guys — and yeah, it absolutely had to be guys — were doing for themselves. They were defining themselves as characters.

    Unfortunately they succeeded in defining themselves as obvious and unsubtle, straining embarrassingly for cool, single-mindedly political and devoid of imagination or originality. In other words, if I were writing them as characters and using this technique I’d be describing immature, insecure college Republicans. My guess is this was put together by an intern or the “new guy.”

  • Drew Link

    “Unfortunately they succeeded in defining themselves as obvious and unsubtle, straining embarrassingly for cool, single-mindedly political and devoid of imagination or originality. In other words, if I were writing them as characters and using this technique I’d be describing immature, insecure college Republicans.”

    LOL You were saying something about immature?

  • michael reynolds Link

    Sorry, Drew, was that intern your friend?

  • Jimbino Link

    Actually,

    “To each his own ….” is the better way to phase it in English.

Leave a Comment