I want to commend Peter Nimitz’s lengthy history of Ukraine to your attention:
History is a complex tapestry with many threads, and is constantly rewoven. Sometimes threads decay and disappear. Other times old threads are strengthened. Some threads are ripped out, and replaced with new threads. The shapes made on the tapestry are usually agreed upon, but the story they tell is usually disputed.
To understand the roots of the Donbass Wars and the Russian-Ukrainian conflict, one must first identify the important historical threads. Some such as the recent growth of Protestantism in Ukraine are quite new. Others are very old, and to understand them one must go back deep in the past.
I found it fair, balanced, and amazingly complete given that it’s only a couple of thousand words long. The TL;DR version is:
- Many countries and people have ruled the territory within Ukraine’s present borders over the last thousand years or so including Poland, Lithuania, Russia, the Turks, the Mongols, and the Greeks.
- Prior to 1954 no country with borders approximating those of present day Ukraine had ever existed.
- Without substantial ethnic cleansing bringing peace and order to eastern Ukraine within a united Ukraine is unlikely.
Mr Nimitz himself tweeted it was 15,000 words. I was going to bring up the article in a comment if you hadn’t written the post.
One overarching theme I get is geography matters. Russia and Ukraine unfortunately are in an area (the Eurasian steppe) which has no natural boundaries, and the Wilsonian principle of national self-determination is a recipe for conflict with the invertible mixing of people that occurs here due to geography.
I read it. I didn’t count it 😉. Thanks.
That is absolutely correct. The lack of natural borders other than a few slow-flowing rivers has meant that any passing would-be empire has ruled the country at one point or another. The same is true of Russia and for the same reasons.
Hmm, seemed pretty peaceful until Russia invaded.
Steve
Casualties in Ukraine 2014-2021
Russia invaded Crimea in 2014. What are the stats before 2014? .
Steve
Russia’s invasion of Crimea had zero casualties.
A better formulation is that Ukraine was pretty peaceful before radical Ukrainian nationalists took over the government. That was in 2014.