Blogging, c. 1940

or, How My Dad Became the Editorial Page Editor for the St. Louis Star-Times

Logo for the St. Louis Star-Times
My dad’s relationship with the St. Louis Star-Times began with a letter to the editor he’d written.

The now-defunct St. Louis Star-Times was the result of a merger between the St. Louis Star, which began publishing in 1888, and the St. Louis Times, which started in 1866. The Star-Times closed its doors in 1951 after having been acquired by the St. Louis Post-Dispatch.At the left you can see a copy of the letter my dad received in response to his letter (no, we never throw anything away in my family). Click on the image for a larger image (>1MB). Here’s what the letter said:

Dear Mr. Schuler

We have read with interest your letter of September 25 and the enclosed editorial on the subject of Turkey. [ed. my dad had in fact visited Turkey a couple of years previously] I would like very much to have you write several other sample editorials and send them in to us. Meanwhile, it will be of help if you will fill out the enclosed personnel card for our consideration.

After hearing from you in the above regard, we will get in touch with you further.

Sincerely,

Frank W. Taylor

Managing Editor

And that was that. My dad continued as editorial page editor for the Star-Times for several years. The work paid practically nothing—he was essentially a volunteer. He supported himself by working as an associate with one of the big law firms in town.

Over the next few months I plan to post a number of my dad’s editorials. I think it will be interesting (at least for his grandchildren) to hear a voice from the past on the issues of what were the day but are to us the distant past.

He has a rather formal, 19th century style—out of date even in 1940—but this really was how he spoke.

There are a couple of things about my dad’s relationship with the Star-Times that I think have some relevance for today. First, there’s no doubt in my mind that, if he were around today, my dad would be blogging. He was an early adopter for practically every technology that came down the pike: he was probably the first lawyer in St. Lous to use a dictaphone or own and use a copying machine. Hard to imagine but that’s how stodgy the practice of law was not too very long ago.

Second, it’s only quite recently from a historical standpoint that newspapers were considered professional activities at all. Newspaper reporters were English majors or poli sci majors or graduates of the school of hard knocks and most newspaper jobs paid practically nothing. It’s only in the last generation that this has changed.

Finally, consider the relationship between writer and managing editor. Frank Taylor needed somebody who could write and had ideas. He didn’t view him as a threat but as an opportunity.

10 comments… add one
  • Very interesting to see. I grew up in St. Louis at a time when the PD was ascendant and the old Globe-Democrat was on its last legs. (Oh and to see the rise and fall of the St. Louis Sun.) I’ve often wondered what it would have been like to live in a plce (like the UK) that maintained a newspaper culture.

    I think you are exactly right when you aid:

    “Second, it’s only quite recently from a historical standpoint that newspapers were considered professional activities at all. Newspaper reporters were English majors or poli sci majors or graduates of the school of hard knocks and most newspaper jobs paid practically nothing. It’s only in the last generation that this has changed.

    Finally, consider the relationship between writer and managing editor. Frank Taylor needed somebody who could write and had ideas. He didn’t view him as a threat but as an opportunity.”

    The first thing I’d do is close all the journalism schools, but keep the profs around to teach other majors who might want to minor in journalism.

    The creation of this journalist class is a clear and obvious failure….only there is no one with the ability to report it anymore.

  • That would have been during that period that old family friend Sel Pepper (he’d worked for my dad on the Wash U paper when my dad was editor-in-chief there) was city editor of the PD. Conversations with Sel talked me out of going into journalism.

  • Ann Julien Link

    Do you have a transcription of the article on Turkey? Mom wonders if it has any relevance to the problems of today. She says—“Fred was really good at predicting what things were going to happen. He said before he died that the big hot spot was going to be the Middle East”. Ann

  • I haven’t catalogued all of the clippings yet. I want to get some archival storage material (hopefully I’ll do that tomorow). They’re so fragile I’d like to handle the actual clippings as little as possible.

    I have noticed a couple of things, however. First, they seem to be proofs. Second, there appear to be a number of duplicates.

  • kevin klose Link

    Dear Dave,

    Delighted to read about how your father got to be editorial director of the Star-Times!

    Frank W. Taylor, the managing editor who wrote to your father in ’39, was my maternal grandfather. He was m.e. of the Star-Times for 27 years, working first for John C. Roberts, and then his son, Elzey Roberts.

    My grandfather’ stories of newspapering in St. Louis in the roaring 20s and his life as a newspaper editor stuck with my sibs and me. I spent 25 years at The Washington Post, and am now at NPR, National Public Radio, in DC.

    There are plenty of “FWT” anecdotes around… I bet you’ve got more than one!

    Best regards,
    Kevin Klose

  • Great to hear from you, kevin!

    I’ve been scanning and OCR’ing the proofs of my dad’s editorials that I’ve got around here. Some are remarkably current. I’ll be posting some soon.

    BTW, when you were at the Washington Post did you happen to run into my old college chum, Marie Arana? I understand she’s book editor there.

  • kevin klose Link

    dear dave,

    i’ve been away from your site these many months. would love to see yr dad’s editorials! apols for lengthy delay in responding to yr 4/20/08.

    marie arana is now editor of WashPost’s BookWorld, the Sunday book review supplement. she has also authored several works of fiction & nonfiction, much of her bio via google. we were newsroom acquaintances, and she has had a terrific career there.

    kevin klose

  • Nice to hear from you again, kevin. I’ve posted of my dad’s editorials and I’ll be posting more. This link catches them.

    Marie was one of my closest college friends—friend, not girl friend. A woman with everything: brains, beauty, character.

  • kevin klose Link

    dear dave,

    a true pleasure to read your father’s editorials! they breathe courage, context, and trenchant life into the memories and myths my siblings and i share about the st. louis star-times, the newspaper we knew from our grandfather, frank w. taylor, and our mother, mary virginia taylor klose, the older of two children of frank and florence (brennan) taylor.

    very best, kevin

  • Gerald Fetner Link

    Hello, Mr. Klose,

    I’ve been gathering research materials for an article on Irving Brant– journalist, pamphleteer, and historian.

    I would be interested in any correspondence or articles you might have (or can direct me to) between Brant and Frank Taylor and Elzey Roberts. I’ve looked at some correspondence between them in the Brant collection at the Library of Congress. I am also interested more generally in learning about the Star-Times, which, from what I have read so far, was considered by top political and judicial figures as a voice of responsible and high journalism.

    I am an independent historian with a background in journalism and constitutional history. I’ve just had published an article in American Journalism ( a journal) on Charles Willis Thompson, the Washington correspondent of the New York Times during the first two decades of the 20th century.

    Many thanks,

    Gerald Fetner, Ph.D.
    Director, Institutional Grants
    The Cooper Union for the Advancement of Science and Art
    30 Cooper Square, 8th Floor
    New York, NY 10003
    212-353-4177

Leave a Comment